HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese?

Newburgh, NY

Jim Leff Jul 3, 2011 06:08 PM

Quick hits in Newburgh this weekend:

Amistad 74 Mill Street (845) 569-7116 grocery in front, caverous eatery in back. Did not try food, but looked real good. Decent fresh pan dulce in front.

Uriel Tacos 49 Mill St. just up the block from Amistad. Looks bright and cheerful. Very good vibe. This may be "the place".

El Bandolero 466 Broadway (845) 561-5390 drab american/mex coffeeshop. Deserted, depressing, shallow Mexican menu. I stuck with my intuition and waited 20 minutes for my carnitas sopes (a good sign...you don't want fast sopes). They were awfully good.

Barnstormer BBQ (Route 17K Ames Plaza). Pulled pork decent but tough. Sauce toothache sweet, though. Corn bread an abomination: undercooked and super sweet. Ugh. [Edit: woops, this is in Highland Falls, not Newburgh]

  1. georgeb Jul 4, 2011 04:18 AM

    Thanks for the tips, Jim... Always good to hear from one of the originals!

    3 Replies
    1. re: georgeb
      tonyv Jul 4, 2011 03:08 PM

      Didn't Barnstormer BBQ Move. From Yelp We used to go here all the time before they moved to Highland Falls. I updated the address and Phone for Yelp so we'll see how long it takes to see the updated address. Food is as others have said. Great BBQ for next to nothing in the way of price. Not a good place for a first date as you will need the paper towels they place on the tables!

      1. re: tonyv
        ecustard Jul 4, 2011 05:49 PM

        Absolutely correct. Barnstormer moved years ago to Rt. 9W in Ft. Montgomery, NY. Don't know who's serving food at the old location, but it ain't Barnstormer. They only have one location, the one I've listed. Oops.

        1. re: ecustard
          Jim Leff Jul 5, 2011 07:40 AM

          Yeah, sorry about that. I hit the new location in Ft. Montgomery. I thought it was quite a bit south of Newburgh, but my iPhone for some reason thought I was still within city limits.

          tonyv, great bbq doesn't come with toothache sweet sauce. As for the toughness, that might have be an aberration, but the pulled pork I ate was about a C-minus by even merely "decent" North Carolina standards.

    2. menton1 Jul 4, 2011 04:05 PM

      How's the waterfront scene in Newburgh these days? Still overpriced and underwhelming food?

      1. v
        vinouspleasure Jul 5, 2011 07:53 AM

        we were in newburgh last weekend and tried machu-pichu for the first time. We ordered the whole chicken, came with a big plates of fries, chicken rice and salad. Everything was great and the sauces for the chicken, which varied from spicy to mile, were also delicous. Four of us ate for about $35!

        1 Reply
        1. re: vinouspleasure
          Jim Leff Jul 5, 2011 10:20 AM

          Yeah, I spotted it. But also a number of other Peruvians. Would be great to systematically try them all.

          FWIW Peruvian chicken quality isn't always a litmus test; i.e. great Peruvian restaurants can have lousy chicken, and great chicken places can be lousy at all else. That said, great Peruvian chicken is great!

        2. Jim Leff Jul 5, 2011 10:29 AM

          FWIW I like the looks of this place (Anna's in Newburgh...Greek):

          2 Replies
          1. re: Jim Leff
            tonyv Jul 5, 2011 11:40 AM

            The review was not mine it was from Yelp. The only good BBQ places I have been to in the Hudson Valley are now closed Brothers in New Windsor and Big Daves in Goshen.I make my own now, will be making a full Brisket for a party this weekend.

            1. re: tonyv
              Jim Leff Jul 5, 2011 12:06 PM


          2. georgeb Jul 7, 2011 12:19 PM

            So, I headed to Newburgh and Mill Street, with the goal of trying Tacos Uriel, but ended up being diverted to El Gallo Dorado, 53 Mill Street, on the basis of a small sign that said "Tamales". It's a small grocery with three or four tables, very neat and tidy. Sadly, no tamales today, they will have them tomorrow. Then, I noticed a sign for "Desayunos" (breakfasts) and they were still serving. I opted for Huevos con Chorizo. It came with rice and beans and half a dozen corn tortillas, and a garnish of fresh avocado. Very nice, very filling, and cheap.

            I'll have to make another trip to try some of the other mexican specialty stores in the area.

            El Gallo Dorado
            53 Mill St, Newburgh, NY 12550

            16 Replies
            1. re: georgeb
              Jim Leff Jul 7, 2011 12:34 PM

              Yup that sign lured me in for non-existent tamales, too.

              1. re: georgeb
                georgeb Jul 8, 2011 02:06 PM

                I stopped by again, and was told that tamales will be available at 8 am on Saturday, until they run out.

                I also stopped in at the Amistad Bakery, and was told (by a young lady forming tamales on a table in the back) that they will be available at 6 am on Saturday, until they run out.

                Guess who's going to Newburgh tomorrow morning!

                1. re: georgeb
                  Jim Leff Jul 8, 2011 03:23 PM

                  Real tamales, good tamales, are gone by noon. Great ones even earlier.

                  Can't wait to read your report!

                  1. re: Jim Leff
                    georgeb Jul 9, 2011 08:19 AM

                    Sorry, got sidetracked by a friend with an emergency.... Will try again next Saturday.

                    1. re: Jim Leff
                      georgeb Jul 16, 2011 06:06 AM

                      So, I made it back to Mill Street for the express purpose of buying fresh tamales at La Amistad Bakery. I arrived at a little past 7 am on a Saturday, asked for tamales, and was redirected to the back of the bakery, past racks of fresh bread and pastries, to the cafe in the back of the store. A young lady explained that there were three kinds of tamales available, green, red, and another type that I didn't understand. I opted for a dozen of the red tamales. She extracted half a dozen from the very large pot and placed them in a plastic bag. She then did the same with the other six. Happily, I returned to the front of the store to pay my $12.

                      The verdict:
                      Corn Husk, check
                      Dense Masa, check
                      Shredded Spicy Pork, check

                      I have been searching for this kind of tamale since my source in Kingston stopped production. I'm very happy to have found this.... Thanks, Jim, for the tips!

                      p.s. The cafe also seems to have an extensive menu of tacos, tortas, menudo, etc. I was so overjoyed with the tamales, I didn't even notice whether or not there were tables, etc.

                      Mill Street Cafe
                      3 Mill St, Nunda, NY 14517

                      1. re: georgeb
                        Jim Leff Jul 16, 2011 08:28 AM

                        George, I'd have gotten a mixed dozen, to try more types! The third was very likely "rajas", a cheesey/vegetarian tamal with nopales. Either that or a sweet, brightly-dyed dessert tamal.

                        Photo looks great! Glad it turned out well! Oh, and there are a few tables!

                        Next time, why not return to El Gallo Dorado and see how their tamales rate? This sort of legwork is, after all, the essence of chowhounding! :)

                        1. re: Jim Leff
                          georgeb Jul 16, 2011 09:04 AM

                          Yes, I know I should have the plunge for the mixed bag, but my jonesing for the red tamales was too strong for the first trip there... I'll be back (with my adventuring hat on)...

                          1. re: georgeb
                            Jim Leff Jul 16, 2011 11:38 AM

                            I'll try to pitch in some, too. Looking for an excuse to go up that way....

                            Aren't there any other hounds who can help us canvas Newburgh tamales?

                        2. re: georgeb
                          jaylowe Jul 19, 2011 05:57 AM

                          out of curiosity what was your place in Kingston?

                          1. re: jaylowe
                            georgeb Jul 19, 2011 09:25 AM

                            Cruz Market, near Abeel Street.

                            1. re: georgeb
                              jaylowe Jul 19, 2011 01:00 PM

                              I live about 2 miles from there. Ive stopped in a bunch of times over the years for various things and never even noticed they had tamales. Sad to know that i'll now be driving to Newburgh when i could have just driven over the roundout!

                              1. re: jaylowe
                                georgeb Jul 19, 2011 01:34 PM

                                This was several years ago. She was making them on an infrequent basis for one of the restaurants. I would have to ask for them, since they were kept in the cooler. She eventually stopped making them, but they were outstanding. These in Newburgh might be just as good.

                                1. re: jaylowe
                                  georgeb Jan 9, 2012 02:14 AM

                                  FYI, tamales are now available from Cruz Market again, perhaps for only a short time, so give them a call and see how good they are.

                                  1. re: georgeb
                                    Jim Leff Jan 9, 2012 01:02 PM

                                    awesome, thanks. We're coming off a weekend, so I'm supposing you got them on a weekend? They're often not made on weekdays

                                    1. re: Jim Leff
                                      georgeb Jan 9, 2012 04:13 PM

                                      These (at Cruz Market) were made on a Thursday, I believe... I bought them on a Friday. The tamales at La Amistad Bakery in Newburgh are not available until 7 am on Saturdays, and are sold until they are all gone. It's about a 30 mile trip for me, so I make sure that I get there early on Saturday morning. :)

                            2. re: georgeb
                              Nailbangers Mar 3, 2012 02:03 PM

                              If u want really really good tamales try this lil store in the corner of southlander and overlook, a mexican co-worker sent me their cus his mother Iaw cooks them and the store sells them for her or something. I don't really know the name of the store but wow the tamales are amazing. So amazing that I go their at least very other weekend. If u do want to try them u have to go early because they go fast, I go like @9, let me know what u think if u do make it!

                      2. v
                        vinouspleasure Jul 9, 2011 09:03 AM

                        I'm heading to stewart airport today, ate peruvian last time, which of these should we try?

                        1 Reply
                        1. re: vinouspleasure
                          georgeb Jul 9, 2011 02:32 PM

                          I can recommend Tacos Uriel. I tried one of their chorizo tacos... very tasty, lots of filling, spicy, but not too much, didn't even try the green salsa. I did try a large tamale there, in a banana leaf, moister than I am used to.

                        2. v
                          vinouspleasure Jul 9, 2011 07:11 PM

                          we ended up tonight back at machu piichu for more chicken. I didn't want to experiment too much with the kids in tow and my stomach had to survive a train trip to providence and back tomorrow.

                          However, we passed the ixtapa taco truck (of bourdain fame) and I couldn't resist. My kids and I shared the $5 taco special which includes four tacos and a can of soda. The pork tacos were my favorite, on the whole the tacos were good, not great, but for the price, it's a great deal. I could definitely snarf down four tacos for lunch if in the area but would prefer to pay more for better quality (and a place to sit).

                          1. a
                            alt. Nov 27, 2012 08:38 PM

                            BBQ News! Yippee!
                            Brothers opened again in New Windsor/ Vails Gate last month, and is better than ever. Wings are the best, with ribs not far behind. Even better than Billy Joe's Ribworks down by the Hudson waterfront, (but they have beef, too). and Barnstormer in Highland Falls on 9W. The Bros. tell me they plan to offer big beef ribs soon. Prices up a bit (were low before), but so is quality. Haven't tried Roundup on Rte. 9, Cold Spring, yet.

                            1. Jim Leff Nov 30, 2012 08:58 AM

                              To update....Amistad is now selling authentic homemade Oaxacan black mole, and Oaxacan tlayuda shells (they say you still have to go up to Pougkeepsie for actual cooked Oaxacan food).

                              Show Hidden Posts