Where to go to make the best Seafood Platter?
Citarella has been famous for their top quality fish and seafood for years. I would probably have them prepare the platter. Whole Foods can also do that, and Zabar's as well.
2135 Broadway, New York, NY 10023
2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024
10 Columbus Cir, New York, NY 10019
I would go to Citarella -- have put my own together from there in the past. Not a fan of the seafod at Whole Foods, and I believe it is correct that Zabar's doesn't sell fresh seafood, though Eli's on the UES does -- for a price.
Edit -- also not a huge fan of the seafood at Fairway -- nothing wrong with it, but I always go next door to Citarella instead.
Dorian's is my favorite fishmonger in the city -- expensive, but they do deliver.
Dorian's Seafood Market
1580 York Ave, New York, NY 10028
The Lobster Place in Chelsea Mkt is probably a very good bet. Great seafood, wide choice and good prices. You may also want to see if they, or another fish monger, could make you such a platter. It may save you a lot of time and effort. Though I imagine you don't want those oysters opened too far in advance. Good luck.
The Lobster Place
75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011