Grand Central Oyster Bar: for tourists or Lovers of Good Seafood??
IOW have past mediocre reviews improved??
Grand Central Oyster Bar
89 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017
Short answer: both. The atmosphere / architecture alone makes it kind of a must-see.
That said, no city trip is complete for me w/out a lunch consisting of a dozen fat bivalves of my choice (a choice from, generally, 25-30 different oysters). The stews look good to, if a bit heavy on the cream, and I find most of the other seafood rather overpriced.
there is a pretty much a consensus on this: sit at the counter, eat only the raw oysters (and maybe fried oysters and/or a bowl of soup), enjoy a glass of wine or a beer, and it's a fabulous historic lovely place...but if you sit at tables and eat the bland overpriced cooked food then it feels like a tourist trap...
Completely agree. I love sitting at the counter and eating oysters and clams and a glass of wine - but that's it. I don't even think the pan roasts and chowder are good - basically bland bowls of cream with stuff floating in them. But oysters and wine...and maybe a shrimp cocktail....and shad roe when it's in season. That's it. And I love sitting there.
For tourists? Yes!! Manhattan is a tourist destination. Tourists, especially Chowhounders, love great restaurants and great food. That's not a "bad" thing.
Great oysters and chowders while sitting at the bar?? Absolutely!! Great atmosphere too!!
Good seafood otherwise?? It's ok. We often hit the oyster bar for a dozen as an appetizer and then head off to another restaurant for dinner.
The original comment has been removed