new Lobster Joint in Greenpoint (in the old Lamb & Jaffy space)
have not eaten here yet, but I spoke with them today, and apparently their lobster rolls are NOT the crappy lobster-salad-style rolls that are sadly prevalent in NYC...the mayonnaise comes on the side (so you can ditch it with ease) and the meat is strictly claws and knuckles. I am super excited to try it out (and hear from other people who have)!
-----
Lobster Joint
1073 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

