HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >

Discussion

Ella NY Pizza & Pasta only Average

  • 0

Tonight we went to dinner in New City, to Ella NY Pizza & Pasta on Main Street. They were only half full, yet the service was slow. When ordering, I requested soup instead of salad and was told in not so nice a tone "soup costs extra, and there are no substitutions". I suppose I looked destitute and couldn't afford the extra charge? Only kidding - there was no need for the rude tone, we'd gladly pay the difference., and she could keep the attitude.

As for the meal, I settled on the chicken with the lemon butter sauce that I keep forgetting the name of! The chicken was slightly undercooked and I would've liked it slightly better done. Also the portion was on the small-size considering the price. I didn't have a problem finishing it and I usually take home half of my dinner.

My son got chicken parm, and again, he finished it all. He said it was okay but he's had better. So overall, we would rate this okay, but slightly pricey for the portion size. And the rude attitude and "no soup only salad" policy did not leave us with a good enough feeling to want to go back. Thankfully we have other options in New City such as Pasta Cucina, Roccos, Rhoda's, etc. so there's no need to go back to a place that has treated us rudely.

-----
Pasta Cucina
253 S Little Tor Rd, New City, NY 10956

Ella Ny Pizza & Pasta
137 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete