HOME > Chowhound > Food Media & News >
Do you create unique foods?

Rachel Ray's $40 a Day vs. Giada's Weekend Getaways

hobbess May 19, 2011 01:54 AM

They're both travel shows with a similar concept, where they both eat and sight see in a particular city.

And, oftentimes, they'll both visit the same city at some point.

But, if you had to follow their choices and eat at the same places they chose, which show would you look to as your restaurant guide?

I'm curious about their recommendations in cities in which chowhounds live in, and what chowhounds thought of Rachel Ray's and Giada's choices.

  1. m
    melo7 May 19, 2011 09:10 AM

    $40 a Day teaches the viewers that a 10% tip is perfectly acceptable. It's a joke.

    1. r
      rjw_lgb_ca May 19, 2011 01:52 PM

      [Deep breath:]

      Rachael Ray blah blah blah horrible cook blah blah blah awful grating voice blah blah blah not a chef blah blah blah no knife skills blah blah blah god I hate her blah blah blah.

      Giada de Laurentiis blah blah blah huge head blah blah blah low-cut blouses blah blah blah mouthful of too many teeth spoiled Italian bitch blah blah blah over-enunciates/mispronounces Italian words according to what I think Italian sounds like blah blah blah god I hate her blah blah blah.

      Just saving people the trouble of taking this thread into the usual direction it goes for these two personalities. Since there is a 100% chance it will move from your question into these irresistable but totally stupid and immature weeds. This site teems with irrational snarky bile directed at these two people who, people have decided, do not deserve their success. To which I say: Hey, they fill some niche in culinary education and are making some money doing it. More power to them. And I wouldn't turn down a meal cooked by either one.

      As for your question: I'll go with Giada. But then again, her food budget on her travels is basically unlimited. If I'm pinching pennies, I'll go with Rachael's choices.

      1. b
        Breezychow May 19, 2011 04:09 PM

        My personal feelings about both women's personalities aside, I don't think anyone could go wrong visiting a restaurant that either one recommended.

        1. m
          Maximilien May 19, 2011 08:21 PM

          As far as I remember the shows, both have different target audience.

          Ray's was more low/mid end restaurants and family style place (other than the bar and dive) and Giada was more mid/high end (?) restaurants in more fancy place.

          Both show have/had their places in the food TV arena.


          1. s
            Shann May 20, 2011 04:51 AM

            I would go to many of the places Rachael Ray went. Probably would never go to where Giada di Laurentis went.

            I really hated how cheap Ray was on the tip though. They should have just done $40 per day without tip.

            4 Replies
            1. re: Shann
              rozz01 May 20, 2011 03:41 PM

              It was hilarious on No Reservations when Bourdains asked the waitress at The Hominy Grill about how RR tips. Couldn't help cackling out loud...

              1. re: rozz01
                hobbess May 21, 2011 12:26 AM

                I'm surprised Rachel Ray would be cheap with her tip because I believe she was a waitress for awhile and you'd expect somebody with that background to appreciate how difficult that job may be.

                But, I guess the poor tips were a function of the show where the total, including tax and tip, had to be under $40. I wonder if she's a better tipper off the show, or maybe even over compensates because of her stingy image from the show.

                1. re: hobbess
                  cstr May 21, 2011 11:28 AM

                  I traveled for many years with a per diem of 40-45 p/day, ate and tipped well, what's the big deal? Never got the jist of that.

                  1. re: cstr
                    choctastic May 23, 2011 04:39 PM

                    I think the $40 a day show showed the bill without tip for a while, but nasty foodies kept hounding her about the lack of tip on the show, so at some point the producers had Ray try for $40 a day, including a 10% tip to the balance. I doubt she tips poorly in real life; she just doesn't strike me as a person like that.

                    I like $40 a day show because I tend toward the lower end of the restaurant eating spectrum. Also, I like Ray's personality.

            2. Withnail42 May 24, 2011 04:23 AM

              Are they even making these shows any more? You might be about five years too late.

              Show Hidden Posts