Need 4 Fab SF Restaurants
My sister is taking her husband to San Francisco for a birthday trip. They're both sophisticated travelers but not over-the-top adventurous diners. I'd like to give her two restaurant suggestions for dinners and two for lunches - places that would really create a memorable SF dining experience for them. Iconic, quirky, high-brow, dive-ish - they would be open to all. With so many places in the city from which to choose, this task is a bit daunting for me. Any ideas?
that was meant to correspond with your four adjectives, in order. the only thing is that sotto mare isn't quite iconic, but it's very much "san francisco"
Love vulber's choices. I also love how his/her quirky position (Jai Yun) is kinda high-brow, and the high-brow (Aziza) is kinda quirky. Great choices. (I'd quibble with Sotto Mare, both for its choice as "iconic" and for its food (I'm not as much of a fan as others are), but there's no question it has a fun, homey atmosphere and if you're game you're gonna have a fun night of cioppino and beer.)
Obviously anyone's choices in SF are going to be as personal and/or idiosyncratically selected as in any great food city -- the act of narrowing down a list of 200 fantastic options to a handful is necessarily a curatorial exercise. With that caveat, and taking into consideration my sense of your post -- i.e., that there are experiential criteria in the mix as well as culinary ones -- here's a stab:
Iconic: Swan Oyster Depot. Go here for lunch.
Quirky: Alembic. You mentioned they like a good cocktail. They may have tasted Alembic's equals, but I bet they've rarely if ever bested the ones they'll have here -- and the food is pretty darned great, too. (Opting to dine is a great way to get in, too, on a busy night at the bar. You miss the fun of watching/chatting with Alembic's bar staff -- the upside is you actually get in and grab a seat.)
Small/Cute/Neighborhoody/Wonderful Highbrow: Frances. very hard to get in these days, but worth a try, especially if they're up for going at opening and waiting for a two-top to open up. The definition of small-restaurant delight. Alternatively (and nearby), I recommend L'Ardoise,a French bistro as perfectly situated in its neighborhood as a restaurant's ever been. The food's very good, but that's not why you'd go there -- it's the way the space feels, from the atmosphere inside to the way it sits on its corner.
Quirky High-brow: Aziza, or Zare at Fly-Trap.
Lovely Day High-brow: Sit in the courtyard at Foreign Cinema or Bar Agricole and think about moving to SF.
Dive-ish Delight: I love Broken Record, but they might get a bigger kick out of Emmy's Spaghetti Shack, in every way -- cocktail-wise, food-wise, everything-wise. Also not as far south. Tell them to go early and have a drink in the Mexican dive bar that serves as Emmy's's foyer/waiting room for the full experience.
The only thing left off this list is a great Italian/pizza place, as I'm convinced that SF's the best city in the US for both. Delfina, A16, Beretta, Flour + Water, et al. are all great choices as well. But I look at the weekend ahead of them with either vulber's choices or the ones I threw out above and I envy what's about to happen to them. (I.e., no pizza required.)
2355 Chestnut St., San Francisco, CA 94123
3621 18th St, San Francisco, CA 94110
Emmy's Spaghetti Shack
18 Virginia Ave, San Francisco, CA 94110
2534 Mission St., San Francisco, CA 94110
552 Green St, San Francisco, CA 94133
1166 Geneva Ave, San Francisco, CA
355 11th Street, San Francisco, CA 94103
Swan Oyster (iconic), Canteen (quirky), Coi (high-brow), a taqueria in the Mission (dive-ish.)