Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Southern New England >
May 6, 2011 11:47 AM

Chicago-style Italian Beef hits Connecticut

ReNapoli Pizzeria & Chicago Italian Beef
216 Sound Beach Avenue
Old Greenwich, CT

As a transplanted Chicagoan, I was excited yet skeptical about the prospect of an east coast beef...but I am happy to report that it was much, much better than I expected. To be honest, I was just hoping for something serviceable as I don't know of another place within 500 miles that serves the sandwich, but my craving was more than quenched and I will be a regular.

The beef was high-quality, properly prepared, tasty and juicy enough to satisfy even my beef-savy palate. The giardiniera peppers were indistinguishable from Chicago's finest, but I recommend for newbies to order them 'on the side' so you can determine how much to put on the sandwich. My only quibble is that the roll was not quite authentic, but was close enough not to detract from my enjoyment.

Overall I'd say it was better than 75% of the beef sandwiches I had in Chicago...I just prey that the dish catches on and more places put it on the menu. The chef told me it's their best-selling item, so I'm excited.

Now all they need is a picture of Mike Ditka on the wall...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I was just having a italian beef conversation with another Chicago transplant just the other day. It's really the only Chicago food that I miss. The Chicago pizza is a gloopy mess and I don't eat hot dogs but I do miss the beef. Just wondering if the offer up a "cheesy beef?"

    This is a pretty bold move. I work in Greenwich so I'll have to shoot up that way for lunch some day. Thanks for the tip.

    1 Reply
    1. re: kwhitehead

      Yeah, there is a "Cheesy Beef", but I've never been a fan of that....

    2. I can't wait to try this. I saw they have an extensive pizza menu and they sound really serious about their pies, has anyone tried the pizza there?

      3 Replies
      1. re: cardiak

        mildly serious i would say. its basically an italian restaurant with 4 seats.

        1. re: food4mood

          What does that have to do with the quality?

        2. re: cardiak

          I have tried their Pizza Napoletana (margherita), the NY Pie(cheese), and the Sicilian Pie. Overall I think their NY Pie is their best pie. The crust has the slight/med chew that you would expect from a NY pie. The Napoletana pie out of thier "Cirigliano" oven had some char on the outer crust, but the bottom crust of the pie was limp and somewhat soggy - disappointed. I may give it another try as they learn to use the ovens better. The sicilian pie I had delivered and that was a mistake since the box they use is not high enough to support the thickness of the pie - and therefore the cheese sticks to the top of the box. They use the plastic spaces but, once you close the box it just buries them into the cheese. The crust could be a little thinner - which would give it a little more density - which it needs. Overall I think this place has promise - as Greenwich is a wasteland for Pizza. Going to try the Italian Beef Sandwiches next.

        3. Spicier than I had anticipated but very good. Thanks for the tip.

          4 Replies
          1. re: Builder3

            Is it as good as a double dipped portillos?

            1. re: cubanat

              Just had the beef again, and can't rave about it enough...have taken 5 other Chicago transplants and they all love the sandwich.

              1. re: dirwuf

                Thanks for the tip. My husband is a Chicago boy and a chef with fond memories of the fabled Italian Beef - he has tried recreating this delicacy to no avail. The closest he's come to having it in recent years was when a friend had the sandwich makings overnighted to him from Gino's in Chicago for a recent big birthday. Very yummy, but it will be great to try it fresh.

                1. re: lunabug

                  We tried it this weekend and all I have to say is WOW. That was for the pizza. We got the Pizza Margerita under the Napoletana section. Simple and delicious.

                  The Spag & Meatballs for child was superb. Light meatball and nice sauce.

                  Went for the beef and I would give it an 80%. For certain satisfied the craving. The bread was lousy though and I ordered it "soaked" which it could have used a "double" dip in my opinon. The giardinarira was spicy and a bit more spicy then typical I would say. The au jus/gravy was a bit on the light side but it was nice & sloppy. Portillo's it ain't but it beef wise it was tasty. I would love for them to open in Westchester -- I could see it doing well in Rye Brook, Port Chester, maybe Eastchester...

            1. re: jenjunum

              I've had the beef sandwich a couple times now, as well as a couple of slices of pizza (haven't gotten a full pie yet).

              Very pleased with the beef sandwich; the only gripe I can see is that I did find one of the times I got the sandwich, that it may have been oversalted, but the other times it was fine.

              And I agree with the comments on both the spiciness of the giardiniera and them holding back on the gravy dip.

              After the first time, I noticed that they now ask everyone "are you sure" types of questions when they get the spicy giardineira.

              I've got it Juicy the first time, and Soaked all the other times, and maybe it's the 5min ride home that's killing it, but even the Soaked ones are just wet, not dripping.

              As for the pizza, when you go on their website, they talk big about their ingredients, oven temps, flour types, proofing methods, etc. Frankly, I was expecting to be a little more impressed by their pizza.

              I still reserve final judgment since I've only gotten single slices there so far, and that's obviously not the pizza at its best, but still; they're charging a whole heckuva lot for their pizza, it better be damned good.