HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Tell us about it
TELL US

Romantic Steak dinner?

k
kt_mom Apr 27, 2011 01:31 PM

So I did some searches on here and I've come up with a few ideas but I thought it might be nice to get some opinions.

My husband and I will be celebrating our 12th anniversary in July. Its actually on a Sunday but we could do Saturday dinner if needed. We live in southern/central VA but will be traveling up to the Northern VA area that weekend Sat-Mon. to celebrate our anniversary and also take our daughter to the new American Girl doll store in Tysons. (She'll be staying with family for our dinner.)

Last year for our anniversary we had a wonderful dinner at the Ruth's Chris in fairfax. Best steak I've ever had. We are definitely steak people. But we'd like to try something new this year.

My husband would love to try one of the places with the large course menus or a chef's table or something, but the truth is I'm not sure either of use would really enjoy/appreciate the food and I'm acutally kind of picky. No fois gras for me please.

So that being said, I'm looking for somewhere fantastic to eat that would have a great steak and be good for a special occasion dinner. On my list are Capital Grille and BLT. But I'm open to ideas. We'd probably like to stay around or under $300 give or take a little including wine/drinks and tip.

Thanks!

-----
Capital Grille
601 Pennsylvania Ave NW, Washington, DC 20004

  1. k
    kt_mom Apr 28, 2011 11:21 AM

    Thanks for all the responses so far. What I've gathered so far is BLT is out. And Prime Rib is a definite possiblity. I haven't yet rulled out Capital Grille and Charlie Palmers either.

    -----
    Capital Grille
    601 Pennsylvania Ave NW, Washington, DC 20004

    Prime Rib
    2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

    1 Reply
    1. re: kt_mom
      m
      marcj Apr 28, 2011 08:25 PM

      I haven't been to Prime Rib, but you are right not to rule out CG or CP. You can get a great cut of meat at either place, but the settings are very different, so it will probably mostly come down to aesthetics. Capital Grille is old-school: dark wood walls, low ceiling--this IS your grandfather's steakhouse (not necessarily a bad thing). One strange thing--when I ate there recently, our red wine was quite chilly; we asked the waiter why, and he informed us that they keep all of their wines at 55 degrees. While I'm sympathetic to their need to preserve something like $5 million in wines, I did not appreciate having to warm my wine with my hands in order to bring it up to a reasonable temp.
      CP is much brighter, with high ceilings--it's definitely a more "nouveau"-feeling room.
      The bottom line is that you probably can't go wrong in either place if you're focused on getting a great steak, it's really a question of personal style.

      -----
      Capital Grille
      601 Pennsylvania Ave NW, Washington, DC 20004

      Prime Rib
      2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

    2. e
      elledeepea Apr 28, 2011 11:21 AM

      I'm not a big steak-eater myself, but REALLY enjoy Bond 45 Italian Steakhouse at National Harbor. Steak tender enough for a butter knife.

      Very snazzy place with good sides, service and dessert. Great for date night or celebrations.

      1. ktmoomau Apr 28, 2011 11:08 AM

        We just had a firm dinner at Capitol Grille and the steak was excellent. I liked the steak better than Ruth Chris (although I am not a huge butter person). I also really liked Charlie Palmer, but haven't been in some time.

        Haven't been to BLT, but might be at Bourbon Steak Friday if so will report back.

        1. d
          DMNGOODTIME Apr 28, 2011 10:22 AM

          I would also consider Charlie Palmer Steak, Bourbon Steak and J&G Steakhouse

          -----
          J&G Steakhouse
          515 15th St NW, Washington, DC 20004

          1. r
            Raids Apr 28, 2011 05:15 AM

            The best steak I've had in the District was the porterhouse at Capitol Grille. OTOH, I hated Ruth's Chris, but it seems like the one in Penn Quarter is particularly bad. And we spent a *ton* of $$$ at Cap Grille - more like $400, with wine, tip, etc.

            I really, really like J&G also - just request one of the booths. Skip the steak sauce though. Might be a nice option for you because the non-steak apps, salads, desserts (salted caramel sundae, mmmm) are stellar and the atmosphere is fantastic. You get to skip the line up to POV lounge for an after-dinner drink with an amazing view, also.

            I actually cancelled a reservation I had for Prime Rib for my husband's birthday and went elsewhere after seeing some not-so-great reviews regarding the service. I guess I'll check out what people have said here and think twice about that.

            1. f
              ForFoodsSake Apr 27, 2011 04:59 PM

              I really like Wildfire Restaurant in McLean. They've got great steak, and they do beer pairings as well.

              1. p
                Pappy Apr 27, 2011 01:40 PM

                You will be sorely disappointed int CG or BLT. The answer to your question is most certainly The Prime Rib on a Saturday night. I have previous posts about it on this board.

                -----
                Prime Rib
                2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

                6 Replies
                1. re: Pappy
                  k
                  kt_mom Apr 27, 2011 01:55 PM

                  okay, looking that one up.

                  1. re: kt_mom
                    JonParker Apr 27, 2011 06:01 PM

                    Ditto Prime Rib. Id consider it the only choice. Also Pappy was posting here before I was, and I've been here a long time, so his recommendation carries some weight. Really PR is what you're looking for.

                    -----
                    Prime Rib
                    2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

                    1. re: kt_mom
                      p
                      Pappy Apr 28, 2011 05:37 AM

                      The Prime Rib, to me, is many, many happy memories. It's probably more about the atmosphere than the food, although I am quite happy to eat there.
                      The decor is black walls and white table clothes, mirrors, sconces, gold and silver, and animal skin prints. The chairs are substantial, and made of tufted black leather. Huge fresh flower arrangements are everywhere. It's more supper club than restaurant.
                      The hosts and waiters are in crisp tuxedos, and address you as "Mr. Pappy". There is a baby grand piano in the dining room. Gentleman are dressed, as dictated by the Jacket and Tie Required policy. Women are equally dressed up for a special evening.
                      The service is impeccable. The martinis are large. The wine properly decanted. A request for ice brings a small crystal ice bucket with small silver tongs, gently set on the table. And while there are lots of tables of men, there are many more of couples. What you don't see, as you do typically at Morton's et al, is the "deal close celebration" table. That's the group of 12 bankers and lawyers toasting themselves that is so ubiquitous at other places.
                      I can't really comment on the food beyond "my usual". My standard order is clams or oysters on the half-shell, which are always impeccably clean and fresh. Then the prime rib, Flintstonian in size, literally 3 inces tall, perfect warm reddish doneness end to end, served with real, fresh, shaved/grated horseradish. And the creamed spinach, which is fine. The Crab Imperial is also delicious. I've also had perfect swordfish and salmon, served very plain. This is not Michelin 4 star cuisine. But what they do, they've been doing for a long time, and they do it just right.
                      So it's certainly not for everyone. It is not casual, or laid back, and it not for those who want "not pretensious." It's not cheap, it's not gourmet, it's not "fun" . It's old school, it's wonderful to some and and it's not apologetic about it.

                      -----
                      Prime Rib
                      2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

                      1. re: Pappy
                        JonParker Apr 28, 2011 06:13 AM

                        Excellent summation, although ties are no longer required at the DC location. I prefer that to the original Baltimore location though, which is relaxed to Business Casual all the time, with jackets "requested" on Saturday night.

                      2. re: kt_mom
                        b
                        BlueRidgePro May 1, 2011 05:15 PM

                        Another vote for Prime Rib. We went for an anniversary dinner and were very happy with the food & service.

                        -----
                        Prime Rib
                        2020 K Street, NW, Washington, DC 20006

                      3. re: Pappy
                        GraydonCarter Apr 28, 2011 06:04 AM

                        So I'm guessing they serve Prime Rib.

                      4. e
                        erinnf Apr 27, 2011 01:34 PM

                        I went to BLT last fall, and I have to say while everything (apps, and sides) was delicious the steaks were really underwhelming. Just not up to par - i mean, the ribeye was almost $60! I have heard really great things about Charlie Palmer's and my husband thinks it is one of the best steakehouses in DC. It is a nice atmosphere, very modern and sleek (cool restaurant bathroom!) and the side dishes are apparently out of this world.

                        1 Reply
                        1. re: erinnf
                          k
                          kt_mom Apr 27, 2011 01:36 PM

                          Thanks, I'll llook that one up.

                        Show Hidden Posts