HOME > Chowhound > Wine >
What are you cooking today? Get great advice
TELL US

Steakhouse dinner for Petite Syrah

m
mikek Apr 19, 2011 11:06 AM

Hi All,

I have a couple of 2005 Petite Syrah's that I have been itching to open recently, and would like to cook a steakhouse type of dinner for my friends. I am thinking of cooking some nice dry-aged steaks and keeping that simple, but would also love some input on cuts, sauces to put on them and specifically sides to make. I really appreciate any help you may offer.

Thanks,

Mike

  1. s
    Sailing77 Apr 19, 2011 12:49 PM

    Hi Mike,

    Petite Sirah is a great match with beef. As you suggested, dry-aged is a solid bet. I would also go with grade prime steaks. IMHO, a good grade prime dry-aged steak does not need a sauce. Let the taste of the meat be the star of the show. As far as cuts, I like ribeye. Bone-in would be preferable.

    If you are looking for steak house type sides I guess creamed spinach is a traditional choice. Twice baked potatoes, pomme frites or potatoes dauphinoise would also be good potato options. Some people like mushrooms sautéed in butter or onion strings with their steaks.

    1. Scott M Apr 19, 2011 04:29 PM

      Ribeye and creamed spinach is classic but I have had some seriously good flatiron steaks with an anchovy compound butter melting over the top of the steak with pomme frites or belgium style fries.

      Another good side that is less common but very delicious with steak is an angel hair pasta tossed with butter, garlic and a heavy dose of Parmigiano-Reggiano. I will sometimes go with this instead of a potato.

      Other sides to consider: creamed corn, brussel sprouts with bacon, truffled mac and cheese.

      Usually a ribeye has enough fat/flavor that it doesn't need a sauce, especially if it has a bone which adds flavor. Sauces are more for leaner cuts like a filet.

      You could go with the Porterhouse which gives you both a strip and tenderloin. Which would be my choice.

      Carmelized onions and sauteed mushrooms are two other nice toppings to throw in for good measure.

      4 Replies
      1. re: Scott M
        s
        Sailing77 Apr 20, 2011 07:13 AM

        "flatiron steaks with an anchovy compound butter melting over the top"

        Excellent idea!

        1. re: Sailing77
          j
          jpc8015 May 14, 2011 08:37 AM

          There is a restaurant in Portland, Oregon that had a flatiron steak with ancho chili butter on the menu. Never had it but I always wanted to try it.

        2. re: Scott M
          m
          mikek Apr 20, 2011 11:13 AM

          Thank you for your suggestions, they sound fantastic. Do you think a buffalo ribeye would hold up equally well?

          Also, would you consider a shortrib type of dish for the petite sirah?

          1. re: mikek
            s
            Sailing77 Apr 20, 2011 01:13 PM

            You bet. Buffalo (Bison) ribeye or beef short ribs would be great with Petite Sirah. If you do end up going with Buffalo/Bison be very attentive when cooking it because it is easy to overcook. Braised short ribs, on the other hand, are almost imposible to screw up. But that dish is also veering away from your steak house theme.

        3. westsidegal Apr 20, 2011 10:06 PM

          imho, it is sacrilege to put any kind of "sauce" on terrific dry-aged beef.
          to me, it's like taking a highlighting pen to a 2 carat clear diamond ring in order to "give it some color."
          maybe i'm weird, but i don't like the heaviness and creaminess of creamed spinach with good beef either.
          a salad and a baked potato is all i'd want if i was being served really top-quality beef.

          rib eye is the cut i prefer.

          on the other hand, when folks serve regular super market type select beef, to my palate that is a good time to break out the sauces, creamed spinach, and to consider dousing the thing with butter

          your petit sirah should be dandy for any beef steaks.

          1. w
            whiner Apr 21, 2011 11:56 PM

            Ribeye/bone-in ribeye

            Red onion / gorgonzola dolce / red wine sauce (optional)

            Roasted root veggies with some garlic cloves thrown in, and maybe a little fresh thyme

            1. m
              mikek Apr 22, 2011 06:54 AM

              Appreciate all of the help. Wound up getting a couple of beautiful ribeyes, med-rare. I did some new potatoes seasoned and baked, and a side of cauliflower with garlic, lemon and fresh rosemary. Had a bottle of the Chiarello 2005 PS and it was beautiful as well. Thank you again for the help!

              Show Hidden Posts