Longshot: Custom Cookie Cutters
Here's someone on Etsy who makes them for $5 each!
And here's a whole page of them from the google....
Oh my gosh - I bought cookie cutters from that guy at the Philadelphia Folk Festival way back in the 70s! It's funny, when I read the original post his face popped into my mind. Sorry to see that the founders have passed on, but it's nice to know that the business is carried on.