Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >
Jan 12, 2006 09:32 PM

Looking for SHEPHERD'S PIE

  • i

Got a relative coming into town and she's hankering for some Shepherd's Pie.

Looking for the traditional kind with mutton/lamb and gravy (not the bastardized American version with ground beef and tomato sauce).

Any leads?

As always thanks in advance.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. s
    sally from LA

    The Cat and Fiddle, on Sunset in Hollywood, has shepherds pie. I haven't tried it myself, as I always go for their fish and chips. My boss, who is an Englishman, swears by it - but is this a good thing?!!!!

    1 Reply
    1. re: sally from LA

      Cat and Fiddle has the best Shepard's pie I've had in Los Angeles! It's REALLY good.

      Lucky Baldwin's in Pasadena has one -- but I was really disappointed. I believe it's made with only ground beef - and it was exceedingly oily.

    2. Cottage Pie is made almost the same way as Shepard Pie but with beef mince. It is a real British dish that often gets misslabeled across the pond. I've never had it here or there with tomato in it although some tomato paste may be added to the gravy.

      1. Brit's in Pasadena
        Restaurant & Pub
        1770 E Colorado Blvd, Pasadena
        (626) 578-1301

        They have Boddington's! See if they have
        the Shepherd's Pie you are looking for.
        Fish 'n chips are great.

        1. I've seen it listed on the menu chalkboard at The Riverside Cafe, a block southwest of the Equestrian Center in Burbank. Not sure if it's lamb or what. I'll ask next time I'm there.

          1. Not sure if Auntie Em's still has the lamb shepherd's pie but you should drive there (do NOT call) and ask. If they do not have any then at least you have the perfect excuse to have a cupcake – “You are already there.”

            Auntie Em's Kitchen (Best Cupcakes, try red velvet and coconut cupcakes, breakfast sandwiches, huge salads, soups or lamb shepherd's pie).
            4616 Eagle Rock Blvd
            Los Angeles, CA 90041-3032
            (323) 255-0800
            Cross Street: Corliss Street