Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Mar 9, 2011 12:31 PM

Best butter in Boston area?

Having recently come back from vacation in a country with excellent dairy (Iceland), I am craving a source of incredibly delicious butter in or near Cambridge/Boston, or even anywhere in the Greater Boston region.

Does anyone have any suggestions? The best I've had so far is Kate's which I found in Whole Foods.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Kerrys Irish Butter is excellent
    can be found at Market Basket and Stop and Shop
    I think i saw it at Russos

    1 Reply
    1. re: Locutus

      That's Kerrygold, not Kerry's. And I agree, their salted Irish butter is my favorite, really delicious, and pretty widely available - in addition to the places Locutus mentions, Whole Foods carries it, as does Trader Joe's (at least sometimes). But then, my wife prefers Kate's unsalted. So we're a two-butter household.

      You can also find Smjör Icelandic butter at Whole Foods.

      Trader Joe's
      1427 Massachusetts Ave, Arlington, MA 02476

    2. Don't think you'll do much better than Kate's, which is outstanding.

      You should also try their buttermilk, which unlike just about everything else you can buy bearing that name really is nothing but the liquid expelled by their butter making process.

      9 Replies
      1. re: Jenny Ondioline

        Just used Kate's Buttermilk to make my fried chicken. Wow, what a great buttermilk! Very fresh.

        1. re: three of us

          Hint: any cake recipe you make--right down to boxed mixes--replace the liquid with Kate's buttermilk. The change is amazing.

          1. re: Jenny Ondioline

            File this under "why didn't I think of that", it's a great idea.

          2. re: three of us

            try to buy butter at a place where it moves rapidly and then store it in the freezer

          3. re: Jenny Ondioline

            Any suggestions on where to find Kate's buttermilk? I pretty much only shop at Russo's and occasionally WF, and haven't seen it at either place, but would be willing to make a special stop to give it a try. I love good buttermilk and have often wished High Lawn would start producing some, so maybe Kate's is my answer!

            1. re: ziggles

              Shaw's/Star and Stop & Shop both carry Kate's buttermilk.

              1. re: ziggles

                Most Market Baskets that I have shopped at carry Kate's Buttermilk. Occasionally they run out, though. The stores in Burlington and Woburn seem to be fairly reliable sources.

                1. re: ziggles

                  I've bought Kate's buttermilk at either the Shaw's or the Stop & Shop that are down the street from Russo's on the Waltham/Watertown line. I know for sure the Shaw's carries it (although they were out when I looked on Saturday) and I think the Stop & Shop may have it too.

                  1. re: ziggles

                    Maybe not in your neck of the woods, but spotted Kate's at the Fruit Center at Milton Marketplace.

                2. Are you looking for a cultured butter like Vermont Butter & Cheese (available at Whole Foods) and some imported butters? A salted spreading butter like Kate's and most of the recommendations you received? Or a high-fat (baking) butter like Cabot 83 and Plugra and a few others ("organic family farms" or something like that is occasionally carried)? Each of these are covered in past threads. You might also check with Sherman Market in Somerville or City Feed in JP. There are some farmers market options in season, but I am not up on winter farmers markets... and its not that difficult to make your own from local dairy which has also been covered in some detail.

                  Sherman Market
                  22 Union Square, Somerville, MA 02143

                  1. South End Formaggio and Cambridge's Formaggio Kitchen carry some lovely, expensive butters, both imported and from American producers. The water buffalo one from Italy is amazing.


                    South End Formaggio
                    268 Shawmut Ave, Boston, MA 02118

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: MC Slim JB

                      Lots of good butters out there; many already mentioned. I also enjoy the Polish butter from Baltic Mkt and an Italian butter at Bina Osteria.

                      Bina Osteria
                      581 Washington Street, Boston, MA 02111

                    2. Kate's is great - and widely available (my Shaw's carries it now) - but my favorite is the Amish country roll butter available at Russo's. It's *quite* salty and a little bit funky/cheesy (note: I have very occasionally had some with too much barnyard taste, but that's rare). Last time I put some out for dinner my friends couldn't stop slathering it on bread. Also, it's pretty cheap - about $4/lb. I've never seen it anywhere but Russo's.

                      I've also noticed that the Polish markets near Andrew Square have lots of kinds of butter I've never seen - I got some once and it was good but unremarkable - I don't know if there are any especially good Polish brands to look out for.

                      32 Replies
                      1. re: MichaelB

                        I don't recall the brand I bought at Baltic. It was recommended by the saleswoman.

                        1. re: MichaelB

                          I think I saw that Amish butter at Baza in Newton. Was thinking of trying some.

                          30 Tower Road, Newton, MA 02464

                          1. re: MichaelB

                            I'll second the Amish rolled butter @ Russo's. It is produced by the Minerva Dairy in Ohio who use naturally cultured cream, churn it in small batches and season it with sea salt. Russo's cut the rolls into ~ 1# pieces. Yes, it is salted, but, it tastes... like BUTTER! We put it in a covered crock, leave it on the counter, refill it as needed.
                            You know that Irish soda bread you're going to make next week? It is improved greatly by a schmear of this butter!

                            560 Pleasant St, Watertown, MA 02472

                            1. re: okra

                              The Amish are great at the farmed products and homemade tasting food one craves. And Russo's, unlike some places (FK), profits from wholesale and offers great retail pricing. Once you try the Amish butter, bet you don't use other butters. I was in Iceland many times the past 10 years and love their dairy products: This Amish butter is more rustic, but first-rate.


                              1. re: scotty27

                                I've got that Amish butter in my drawer along with some leftover Trader Joes and Kates. Since I find the Amish butter has a very pronounced flavor, I only use it for putting on bread or sometimes to cook eggs or throw on a steak.

                                Market Basket has the tub of Kate's and the pounds for dirt cheap (under $3), that's about $2.50 less than Whole Foods. Stock up there.

                              2. re: okra

                                At Russo's is it w/all the other butters or in the cheese case?

                                1. re: viperlush

                                  It's with all the butters, top shelf, I think. What's amazing about it, too, is that it is so rich, so much the butter of childhood, that you don't need as much compared to others butters to create flavor. So: It has economical and health factors added to taste. To say nothing of buying from US farmers rather than the EU. Not that I don't love the EU...but this is closer to home, n'est-ce pas?


                                  1. re: scotty27

                                    Cool, thanks. I've been on a butter tasting kick (shopping at Russo's and WFs on River), but I think I've missed that one. I go through so much butter baking that I tend to buy only unsalted butter (Cabot or LOL, whichever is on sale). But, I do like to keep a good salted butter on hand for spreading on bread.

                                    1. re: viperlush

                                      Yeah, this is butter for cooking vegetables, spreading on Hi-Rise rye or walnut bread toasted, or just gazing at. Not baking material.

                                      1. re: viperlush

                                        Cabot 83 is my favorite for baking, and it eats nicely, too. If you're heading to Russo's, they also have a heavy cream (local I think) that is unbelievable. It's golden, and absolutely blew my mind with how fresh and deep tasting it is. They sell it in plastic bottles right near the butter (heck, maybe you could make your own butter from it).

                                        1. re: nsenada

                                          I agree about Cabot's. Wow, heavy cream. What, are you Satan?

                                          1. re: nsenada

                                            For the Cabot 83 fans, Restaurant Depot (Tax ID number required) has it for super cheap, something like $3 a pound.

                                            1. re: nsenada

                                              Is that the cream from High Lawn Dairy?

                                              1. re: PinchOfSalt

                                                I think so - it is devilishly good.

                                            2. re: scotty27

                                              I've been buying this Amish butter from Russo's since reading these posts and love it. However, it's been gone the last three weeks. Anyone seen this anywhere else? I asked the guy stocking the dairy about it this morning and he wasn't sure if it was coming back. He said maybe next week, but seemed like he was guessing.

                                              1. re: Ali G

                                                That is concerning news. Please keep us updated. I've been busy with my current pound for the past few months…

                                                1. re: smartperson

                                                  Ok..I was at Russo's this morning and they were fully stocked with about 20lbs of Amish butter. Crisis averted. Great stuff.

                                                  1. re: Ali G

                                                    Yup - grabbed some on Saturday. They also have Grillo's pickles, which I hadn't noticed before.

                                                2. re: Ali G

                                                  I've noticed droughts in the Amish butter supply at Russo's in the past and it's always come back. I like to think it's because the cows are taking a winter break but I don't really know. In any case I wouldn't panic just yet.

                                              2. re: viperlush

                                                It's on the top shelf of that dairy case between the few prepackaged meats and the yogurt. It has gone away for months at a time in the past, so... I hope increased demand will result in an equal increase in supply.

                                                1. re: okra

                                                  If you ask the owner, bet he'll buy it. Dude is very chill.

                                              3. re: okra

                                                Just scored some of this Amish rolled butter at Russo's today: looks great. I've bought just about every other butter in that section, never noticed this stuff or overlooked it as some other kind of product. Thanks for the directions, Hounds!


                                                1. re: okra

                                                  Wow. I picked up some of that butter this past weekend. What an incredible specimen of butter! My sister (a huge butter lover) is in town and now she wants to take the whole pound I purchased back with her to New York! This was an excellent tip, Chowhounders! After she takes all my Amish butter I will try one of the other suggestions you guys provided :-)

                                                  1. re: smartperson

                                                    I also got some of the Amish butter at Russo's. I need to freeze it, because I'm eating way too much, and I just decided I have to work at taking this weight off, not putting on more.

                                                    It's actually cheaper than the generic, store brand at the local Stop & Shop!

                                                    Not to make my fellow chowsers jealous, but I actually now live in the neighborhood. :D (After being isolated in what was really a culinary wasteland for so long, I feel like I'm in heaven). In fact, I could actually walk there in good weather (as long as my knee heals, and *if* I could haul back my findings without killing myself, haha). Russo's is amazing - what's so terrific is they have great things like this that's competitive w/the local grocery stores. The milk they carry that's from local dairies costs about the same as the Stop & Shop brand, the farm eggs cost less - oh, today I noticed that the fresh ginger is $1.50 a pound - in S & S it's $3.49!!

                                                    1. re: threedogs

                                                      Their prices are *more* than competitive: this afternoon, I bought a couple pounds of gorgeous green beans for 98 cents a pound, a lovely bunch of beets with gorgeous greens (and another bunch of greens because some damn fool had torn them off and left them there) for $1.49, two heads of leaf lettuce for $1.49 each...Russo's is a goldmine. My only worry is that more people will discover both its awesomeness and its relative ease to get to and thereby make it even more of a madhouse than it can sometimes be already. Although this afternoon at 2 it was a breeze.

                                                      1. re: Jenny Ondioline

                                                        Oops - I just sent my son down to buy some more veggies. Hoping he doesn't get the madhouse.

                                                        I fortunate that I can go first thing in the morning (which varies according to how awake I am). Never have a problem with crowds. Shhh - this is our secret, OK? ;-)

                                                        1. re: threedogs

                                                          I definitely know when to go and when not to, but even when it's busy, there are tricks to get in and out quickly. There's one register that's always open and almost never has a line, for example, although that's one I'm keeping to myself.

                                                          1. re: Jenny Ondioline

                                                            Hahaha - ah, I see that I am only a grasshopper, oh wise one! (Hmm, going to look for that register now..)

                                                            1. re: Jenny Ondioline

                                                              I see I am not the only one who has developed a set of Russo's strategies. My wife and I always go in with a game plan -- we have this stuff down to a science.

                                                        2. re: threedogs

                                                          Gotta love Russo's. Aside from killer food, their flowers are some of the best in Boston at Great prices.