/

New York State (exc. New York City)

Tips for Dining, Eating and Food Shopping in New York State

Westhampton Area

Is there any place good opened this time of year that isn't a total ripoff? Quogue, East Quogue, Hampton Bays or somewhere thereabouts.

13 Replies

  1. baby moon and joes right next to it in westhampton beach

    1. What kind of food are you looking for?
      I am not a big fan of Westhampton Restaurants. There is a nice hole in the wall Mexican place called Funcho's that we like.
      A gourmet pizza place called Brunetti opened but it was a disappointment. Soggy crust and very expensive.
      We head over to Hampton Bays:
      Matsulin has excellent Asian fusion cuisine.
      Villa Paul is an old favorite for Italian
      Gator's for excellent bar/restaurant fare
      Canal Cafe for a fabulous lobster roll and fresh fish.
      Indian Cove for upscale seafood with a French flair
      Or head up to Riverhead and the North Fork for fabulous food without the Westhampton chic "vibe".
      A new place called Dark Horse just opened. Eclectic cuisine that will knock your socks off.
      Lots more in Riverhead if youa re interested.

      -----
      Villa Paul Restaurant
      162 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

      Matsulin Restaurant
      131 W Montauk Hwy Ste 1, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

      1. re: Motosport

        Thanks for all that...got talked into going to Southampton, The Red Bar. Hope it's good.

        1. re: coldbeer

          good luck with that its pricey stand alone building a little out of town ok food

          1. re: ronhall51

            I gave up on Southampton and W Hampton a long time ago. The main emphasis of the restaurants seems to be "trendy" and a place to "be seen" during the Summer tourist season. Generally good food but much too expensive for what it is.

            1. re: Motosport

              on the bright side lots of farm stands and fresh produce.Hampton bays has two good fish stores .So ill just hone my home cooking

              1. re: ronhall51

                Cor-J is our "go to" place for fish and lobsters!! What's the other place?
                Green Door Farmstand has a very nice breakfast thing going on.

        2. re: Motosport

          i just moved to westhampton beach i definately be interested in hearing about more riverhead choices.Thanks in advance

          1. re: ronhall51

            Some standbys in Riverhead (off 58, which is dominated by corporations and largely on/near Main St., which has its mainstays but is evolving"):
            Snowflake, Funchos (WHB location as well), Buoy One (within spitting distance of each other)
            Farm Country Kitchen
            Haven't been in years : Star Confectionery, Spicy's
            Still hafta try : Dark Horse
            (All of these are within walking distance, if that's something you're into)

            A bit of a trip but not far : Briermere Farms, Grana

            -----
            Buoy One
            1175 W Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901

            Briermere Farms
            4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901

            1. re: ronhall51

              I live and work in the Riverhead area and do my best to support the local restaurants:
              On Main St
              Dark Horse is fabulous! Great atmosphere and very creative menu. Fresh local fish.
              Tweeds specializes in Bison and local seafood.
              Athens Grill has top quality Greek food.
              Haiku Sushi is very good but the service is a little spotty.
              The Rendesvous serves excellent marinated steaks at reasonable prices.
              Buoy 1 on W Main for terrific fresh local seafood. They are opening another place in W Hampton.
              Funcho's on W Main St for very good creative Tex-Mex. Also in W Hampton Beach.
              Farm Country Kitchen has excellent unusual dishes in a nice casual riverside setting
              Cooperage Inn on Sound Ave just North of Riverhead is another favorite
              Phil's Sports Bar in Wading River for good bar/restaurant comfort fare.

              -----
              Cooperage Inn
              2218 Sound Ave, Calverton, NY 11933

              1. re: Motosport

                Ah, the rendezvous (or the "vous" as its called in my house) = One of my favorite places around. Great burgers.

                1. re: kariface

                  Same in our home. Back in the day when Cliff owned all 4 Vous/Elbow places we'd start at the "vous" and if it was busy head to The Elbow Room then to Elbow 2 and finally but not often to Elbow East. Sadly, Cliff is gone.

                  -----
                  Elbow Room
                  1055 Walnut St, Elmira, NY 14905

          2. Squiretown in Hampton Bays, is great as well.

            -----
            Squiretown
            26 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946