Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Feb 12, 2011 12:05 PM

New to Chowhound... Looking for a Valentines Day LES restaurant

Hey folks,
Good to finally register here and get involved: I'm looking for a Valentines Day lower east side restaurant... Preferably no Chinese, some sorta prix fixe would be optimal if it's under $20, $25... Anyone have ideas? It's ya know, I don't want to take the missus to a diner. Some place cozy, romantic. She puts up with a lot from me and deserves a good night now and again. :D

Hopefully this is more or less the format and right board, read through the rules and it looks like this is where this should go, but feel free to move it if it isn't. Like I said, never posted here before.

Much obliged for the help, I'm looking to spend $50 or under for the two of us. Things're tight as heck these days, part of why she puts up with so much. :) A more patient woman ya couldn't ask for.

So there you go... I know there's a smattering of Italian joints, which're usually fairly romantic and have a prix fixe, especially away from the touristy areas, but with NYU near by I'm not sure which ones are noisy college hangout joints. Don't want to risk that. Would be good to be able to actually get a word in without having to yell!


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. $25 per person before tax, tip, drinks? Or after?

    Cozy, LES, romantic, and under $25pp is going to be hard to find on V-Day.

    How about Cafe Katja? I would call to see if they are serving their regular menu first. Also note that they do not take reservations.

    Anything here look good?

    Cafe Katja
    79 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002

    1. Motorino is taking reservations -- heart-shaped pizzas! However, they have a three-course set menu (with lots of options for the first two courses) that's $30 per person.

      349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003

      1. Frankie's 17 is mentioned on the thread kathryn linked to, and I'll second it and add 'inoteca. I don't think either has a prix fixe, but I would abandon that option anyway, since I really doubt one exists within your budget. Another caveat: I don't believe either restaurant takes reservations, and both are likely to be mobbed.

        You might also reconsider Chinatown. I've had a few Valentine's Day meals there, and you could easily have an inexpensive lobster dinner. It will not be candles & roses romantic, of course, but with only $50 to spend, you've gotta make some sacrifices.

        Here's a place I haven't tried (it just popped up on SeamlessWeb the other week) - might be worth a look:

        1 Reply
        1. re: small h

          I like those two suggestions! With the caveat that it is very easy to go over budget unless you order carefully.

          (Note to the OP: 'inoteca in Gramercy takes reservations but the LES one does not.)

          98 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002

        2. Zerza, East Village

          308 East 6th Street, New York, NY 10003

          1. My apologies for not replying to all this help sooner, just walked in the door. I love living in Midwood and attending parties in Williamsburg, ah yes. 2 hours and 30 minutes of joyful commuting one way. Heh.

            Let me see... What to reply to first. Alright, well, yes, let's see, first off neither of us touch alcohol, so that cuts the cost down quite a bit usually. That's why we're somewhat more capable of doing these nights out a bit cheaper, because yeah, really not going to see a glass of wine hit our table any time soon. So that does help. And before tip for sure, I meant $25 per person (pp? Apparently here?) before tip, tax, etc...

            The point raised about the reservations, actually the point raised multiple times, a very valid one. I took a look at a few places with people rating their experience with Motorino and although it looks absolutely lovely, the quality seems to perhaps have declined? Nancy, have you been personally? I'm curious, because that would work. $30 I can do pp.

            I can always change it, at least for a little bit beforehand. I was most impressed with Lina Frey. They've a $55 prix fixe which is well above my budget *but* I'm going to call them, perhaps they're also serving from the regular menu, which is more reasonable. And of course the missus is more than worth it, perhaps I can come up with the cash somehow. *Scratches head* Somehow, anyway. Yes. To do the special one, the $50+ one...

            Really, really appreciate all the help. What a wonderful welcome to Chowhound's community. Thanks to all of you, they all look lovely, just a question of finding just the right fit.

            349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003

            Lina Frey
            201 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002

            2 Replies
            1. re: BewareAlbatross

              I've been to Motorino 4 times -- last night in fact. I think the pizza is great, but so are the first courses and desserts. I highly recommend it.

              349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003

              1. re: BewareAlbatross

                The curse of the pieman is that pizzas can never be 100% consistent due to ovens, dough, weather, etc. That said: I've been to Motorino in the East Village about 10 times and eaten their pies via delivery perhaps 25 more. Sometimes we get extra to freeze for later.

                It's my favorite in Manhattan.

                349 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003