HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

Discussion

Peter Luger as a vegetarian?

  • m
  • msan Feb 12, 2011 08:32 AM
  • 36
  • Share

Hi,

Friends have made reservation for group at Peter Luger. I want to go (to hang out w/friends), but just checked out the menu, they really don't have much of a menu. Just steak and sides. I'm okay w/eating salad, but am I better off skipping this?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. You've seen the menu, isn't this a decision only you can make? Are you okay having a just a salad and possibly some potatoes and dessert? How much do you want to hang out with your friends? It certainly won't be a memorable meal for you.

    3 Replies
    1. re: reatard

      Sometimes restaurants are acccomodating and will have unlisted stuff. Does PL or is it just what is on the menu.

      1. re: msan

        What you see is what you get at Luger. It's an old school steakhouse. They will accommodate you with bread, salad, creamed spinach and potatoes.

        1. re: reatard

          creamed spinach is often made with chicken stock. just in case ask before ordering it...

    2. Do them a favor and stay home. You sitting there picking at a salad while they tuck into big steaks will just cast a pall over the evening.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Bob Martinez

        and the salad isn't even a salad, if i remember correctly--it's some slices of tomato and onion. and if the sides are chicken brothy spinach and meaty potatoes, you might be better off skipping. you'd do much better just about anywhere, including meat-intensive diner across the street.

      2. Call and ask if there's anything off-menu they can do for you.

        3 Replies
        1. re: invinotheresverde

          It's really not that kind of place.

          1. re: invinotheresverde

            I take it you're referring to the vegetarian tasting menu.

            1. re: Bob Martinez

              Obvs. ;)

          2. Peter Luger's is not a place for a vegetarian. Join them at a more veggie friendly restaurant in the future.

            1. Skip it unless you are cool spliting the bill and ending up paying $100 for a salad.

              1. I'm in your veggie boat. Nothing to eat there, but happily went to be with friends. All comes down to your choice.

                1. Unless you eat fish, I would pass.

                  1. I also want to point out that there is an overwhelming aroma of beef throughout the restaurant. Those that doesn't eat red meat might not find it pleasant. It's your call.

                    1. Your not serious are you? Peter Luger is known to be the meat lovers paradise. Even the potatoes are cooked in fat. i would stay home and not suffer or make the waiters at Lugers laugh when you order a salad.

                      1. I'm a vegetarian, but I LOVE steakhouse sides. Unfortunately, the potatoes at Luger's are cooked in some kind of meaty fat (maybe bacon drippings?) and I think the creamed spinach may not be veggie (you can call and ask). If they are set on steak, maybe your friends will be willing to go to a veggie-friendlier steakhouse?

                        1. I would happily go to Peter Luger's and not eat a bite of steak if you allowed me to just eat as much of their bacon as I could.

                          But if I was not going to have any type of meat? Then, no, I don't think Luger's will do you justice.

                          1. i have to confess, when i saw the title of your post i thought it was going to be about a strange, random story claiming that Peter Luger had been a vegetarian at some point :)

                            as most of the others have indicated, Luger may very well be the worst possible choice for a vegetarian - your only options will be broccoli, mixed green salad, sliced tomato & onion, fries, baked potato, and onion rings. sure, you *could* cobble together something resembling a meal out of those, but IMHO it's just not worth it.

                            -----
                            Peter Luger Steak House
                            178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

                            1 Reply
                            1. re: goodhealthgourmet

                              ...... the fries are done in beef tallow. The Holy Cow sundae works for you though. I'm with the others, skip it, and Peter Luger is one of my favorite restaurants.

                              -----
                              Peter Luger Steak House
                              178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

                            2. If you really want to go here is my suggestion; get the tomato and onion salad and 2 shrimp cocktials. Cut it all up into small pieces, smother in the PL Steak Sauce and enjoy. Now if you dont eat shrimp...............

                              2 Replies
                              1. re: princeofpork

                                You mean the steak sauce is not made of steak?! Next you'll tell me that duck sauce isnt made of duck.

                                At any rate, as someone who's been there and done that with a vegetarian friend or two over the years, I'd recommend staying away because of all the reasons already given. However, if you define your vegetarianism to include fish/shellfish, then believe it or not, folks have given thumbs up on the lobster and the fish there. Not as a destination place of course but as a decent option when going with meat eaters. If you cant eat anything other then the veggies and desserts, you're out of luck, as I'm pretty sure that you wont get a guarantee on anything being meat free due to the stock used. Actually, I think they clean the tables with a meat based liquid cleaner :-)

                                1. re: Steve R

                                  thanks for making me laugh, Steve.

                                  if you are going to stick to dessert, then the one advantage you'll have over your friends is that you'll actually have room left for the mounds and mounds of thick whipped cream

                              2. i would not count on anything on the menu being untouched by meat. the potatoes cooked in fat, stock in the spinach, etetc

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: thew

                                  The home fries ARE cooked in beef tallow.

                                2. I went with a group which included a vegetarian (not known to me at the time). She ordered the broiled salmon and the tomato/onion salad. So, if you eat fish, you might be OK.

                                  1 Reply
                                  1. re: Sluggo1407

                                    If she ate fish she is not a vegetarian:}

                                  2. msan so - what happened? Did you go?

                                    1. I ended a 15 year stretch as a vegetarian at Peter Luger's on a Mothers Day celebration in the late 1990's. If that doesn't tempt someone, then nothing will. It is arguably the finest steak to be had. I ordered salmon and tomato onion salad that day. I caved when seeing everyone enjoying that juicy steak.

                                      -----
                                      Peter Luger Steak House
                                      178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

                                      1. Dont bother the entire place is the mecca of meat. And I am not sure if I would tell those old crusty waiters that you do not eat meat... scary...

                                        1. I went. I ate salad and a hot fudge sundae. I ate a couple of fries and then remembered about the tallow. I think that just breathing Peter Lugar air probably counts as eating meat. I had fun w/my friends. I enjoyed the retro room, I found the waiters to not be as gruff as reported, I was awed by how expensive it was (my friends treated me, since my bit was ridiculous compared to their bit). The experience brought me back to the NY or the cranky, opinionated cab drivers of the '70s. I'm glad I went, I'll never go again.

                                          2 Replies
                                          1. re: msan

                                            So glad it worked out. And super glad you wrote back to tell us all about it!

                                            1. re: msan

                                              I am glad to hear you had the experience.. It is a very old school Brooklyn experience. I love the fact that you would go to the mecca of meat being a vegitarian. Thats cool. The vegans I know would never be so open.. They might even protest or adopt a cow or something..

                                              Ciao-

                                            2. Funny....when I think of all the opportunities that I could have had to go to Peter Luger's. When I was a kid, my parents used to go there frequently. But as a kid, I didn't like meat all that much, and I particularly disliked steak, so I never went with them. In fact, I didn't learn to enjoy steak until about 15 years ago. Now I love it.....and I've only been to Peter Luger's once....but boy, was that steak good! The rest of the meal, meh.

                                              -----
                                              Peter Luger Steak House
                                              178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211

                                              1. there is absolutely nothing for you to eat. I'd bet the cheesecake is made with real lard and I wouldnt be surprised if the creamed spinach had some kind of meat greaser in it too. It is very good tho.

                                                1. It may be too late to do it for this meal, but in the future I suggest calling the restaurant and letting them know your situation. They just may have a vegetarian special planned, or can suggest something not on the menu. Many restaurants do this if you give them enough notice.