My sister is visiting this weekend and loves tiramisu. She actually uses the version at the Olive Garden as the gold standard. I guess theirs is indeed a standardized product, and pretty decent actually (I've had much much worse at many well regarded shops here).
There must be also be much much better offerings here.
If you're looking for takeout, I really like the tiramisu at Sahadis on Atlantic Ave.
It's in the rear of store with the other prepared foods. The homemade taramaslata and other salads are also excellent. I usually get whatever looks good that day and am never disappointed.
187 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201
We had plans to be in E Williamsburg to get lard bread from Napoli, so decided to try Motorino. Their tiramisu is very good. It tasted very fresh and not really boozy, but with enough coffee flavor. The sweetness was on the subtle side, which was fine by me. The texture was perfect, being dense yet still light, if that make sense. It's a well-balanced tiramisu. Although I prefer my ladyfingers boozy, and my mascarpone more funky, it was very enjoyable.
I'll keep the other recs in mind for future excursions. Thanks everyone!
319 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211