HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Cupcake recommendations for Thanksgiving

nyc_londoner Nov 23, 2010 10:13 AM

So i've done the usual suspects Magnolia, Crumbs, Baked by Mellissa - I'm sure Im missing some truly delightful places....any suggestions?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. ellenost RE: nyc_londoner Nov 23, 2010 10:32 AM

    I adore the cupcakes from Chikalicious Dessert Bar. My abosulute favorites are the red velvet and the caramel. Although many (if not most) people love the cupcakes from Two Little Red Hens, I'm not a big fan of them. I find they're almost too large (not enough frosting to cake ratio).

    6 Replies
    1. re: ellenost
      HungryHorn RE: ellenost Nov 23, 2010 11:33 AM

      Try Cupcake Cafe. Two locations: 18 W18th between 5 and 6th Ave and 545 9th Ave between 40 and 50th St

      1. re: HungryHorn
        kathryn RE: HungryHorn Nov 23, 2010 07:23 PM

        Be forewarned: Cupcake Cafe has gorgeous cupcakes with super buttery frosting.

        1. re: HungryHorn
          LeahBaila RE: HungryHorn Nov 24, 2010 08:17 AM

          They're gorgeous to look at, but not so much to eat.

        2. re: ellenost
          Jess321 RE: ellenost Nov 24, 2010 07:32 AM

          As a TLRH fan, I feel obligated to point out that if you go to their bakery on the UES they DO sell mini versions of all or most of their cupcakes, including the amazingly delicious Brooklyn Blackout cupcake! I have not seen these mini versions at Dean & Deluca, only the full-size. I've never tried the minis because if I make the trek to the bakery then I'm getting a big one, but I'm sure they're just as tasty as the full size ones!

          Dean & DeLuca
          1 Rockefeller Plz, New York, NY 10020

          1. re: Jess321
            ellenost RE: Jess321 Nov 24, 2010 11:41 AM

            I've seen the mini-version cupcakes at TLRH, and they're "tiny"--more like one bite. Adminittedly, they are cute! Chikalicious' cupcakes (at least to me) are the perfect size.

            1. re: ellenost
              ellenost RE: ellenost Nov 28, 2010 06:02 AM

              Okay, I tried a bunch of different flavors of the mini cupcakes at TLRH, and I like them better than their full-sized cupcakes. They're about 3 bitefuls. Better icing to cake ratio. Liked very much the carrot cake. Still prefer ChikaLicious' red velvet. Still have the blackout and marble minis to taste (my after the gym treat).

        3. b
          Blumie RE: nyc_londoner Nov 23, 2010 11:08 AM

          The "usual suspects" all suck! The best (imho) are Sugar Sweet Sunshine. I also like Chikalicious, but they're half the size and twice the price of Sugar Sweet Sunshine!

          Sugar Sweet Sunshine
          126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002

          5 Replies
          1. re: Blumie
            Nancy S. RE: Blumie Nov 23, 2010 11:17 AM

            I agree that Chickalicious and Sugar Sweet Sunshine are the best. I happen to like the flavors at Chickalicous better, as well as their icing technique.

            Sugar Sweet Sunshine
            126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002

            1. re: Nancy S.
              r0cc00 RE: Nancy S. Nov 23, 2010 12:35 PM

              Another vote for SSS.
              Have to check out Chickalicious on this trip.

              How are their prices vs. SSS?
              I couldn't believe the prices (low!) that SSS was charging in NYC!
              Another pleasant surprise in this economy.


              1. re: r0cc00
                kathryn RE: r0cc00 Nov 23, 2010 07:28 PM

                Chikalicious' cupcakes also are on the petit side, so it's not exactly an exact comparison. She does lighter, whipped frosting with overall less frosting on the cupcake. I like them a lot but find SSS more satisfying overall. Another option is Butter Lane because they are more about natural ingredients. I find theirs to be more clean tasting. I also like Sage available from Dean and Deluca. Good frosting to cake ratio.

                Thumbs down to Billy's (hit or miss in terms of dryness), Buttercup Cake Shop (chalky frosting and way too much of it), Crumbs (too big and too sugary), Magnolia (way too sugary frosting).

                Butter Lane
                123 E 7th St, New York, NY 10009

                1. re: kathryn
                  uwsister RE: kathryn Nov 27, 2010 05:59 PM

                  I still don't get all the love Sugar Sweet Sushine gets - yeah, it's cheap, but I haven't found a single cupcake that I liked there. Okay, there was one, strawberry creamcheese, and I've tried almost EVERY single kind of cupcake they have. And their chocolate frosting is ghastly.

                  My faves: Chikalicious, TLRH, Butter Lane, Big Booty (red velvet only) in Chelsea

                  Middle-of-the-road: Magnolia, Billy's

                  Thumbs way down to Pinisi, Buttercup, Crumbs

                  1. re: uwsister
                    kathryn RE: uwsister Nov 28, 2010 07:59 AM

                    I really like their lemon, pistachio, and vanilla. Their chocolate frosting is a little off sometimes.

          2. s
            steakrules85 RE: nyc_londoner Nov 23, 2010 11:30 AM

            I like pinisi also

            1 Reply
            1. re: steakrules85
              Pan RE: steakrules85 Nov 24, 2010 09:07 PM

              I can't relate to that. I gave on on Pinisi after several tries. Dry and just not good. I like Chikalicious but have to remember to try Everything Frosted, which sounds interesting to me. I also like Two Little Red Hens a lot but probably prefer the squares there (lime-coconut, lemon, linzer, etc.) to anything else.

            2. c
              comiendosiempre RE: nyc_londoner Nov 24, 2010 04:25 AM

              As a devoted cupcake aficionado, the best cupcakes I (and others in the family) have had in awhile are at the new spot in Chinatown, Everything Frosted. Its on Mosco Street, off of Mott. Up a small flight of stairs. Great, friendly owners. Very cute spot. The cupcakes were perfect. We thought way better than Magnolia, Buttercup and others. The Times had a blurb on the spot recently. Happy eating.


              Everything Frosted
              105 1/2 Mosco St, New York, NY 10013

              1. kelea RE: nyc_londoner Nov 28, 2010 07:52 AM

                I will preface my blurb with the fact that I don't actually care for cupcakes or cakes in general so please take my input with a grain of salt. That being said, due to birthdays galore, i've been eating a number of them recently. Here are the few saving graces.

                LeahBaila is right...Cupcake cafe is gorgeous but overall not too tasty and a little dry. However, the maple walnut cupcake is delicious is moist and the only one worth eating.

                Crumbs is general blah. Too sweet and just too large so the ratios are off. I did find a Samoa cupcake (yes created for the girl scout cookie) at the 37th and 6th location. The caramel and toasted coconut to that simple vanilla cupcake has been the only cupcake I actually truly enjoyed.

                I would lump Sugar Sweet Sunshine with Magnolia and Buttercup. Ridiculously sweet frosting and completely forgettable.

                Most recently, I had Lulu Cake Bakery and I think for boutique bakeries, this is definitely one of the most enjoyable ones. Esp the red velvet and the vanilla hazelnut

                Sugar Sweet Sunshine
                126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002

                2 Replies
                1. re: kelea
                  kathryn RE: kelea Nov 28, 2010 08:00 AM

                  SSS is probably the best of the Magnolia style but that entire class of cupcakes may not be for you.

                  Try Chikalicious or Butter Lane for less sweet varieties.

                  Butter Lane
                  123 E 7th St, New York, NY 10009

                  1. re: kelea
                    uwsister RE: kelea Nov 28, 2010 08:47 AM

                    >I would lump Sugar Sweet Sunshine with Magnolia and Buttercup. Ridiculously sweet frosting and completely forgettable.

                    EXACTLY how I feel. I'll never get why some people bash Magnolia and love SSS - Magnolia has better banana pudding anyway. And no, I've never seen a single episode of Sex and the City...

                  Show Hidden Posts