HOME > Chowhound > B.C. (inc. Vancouver) >

Porterhouse Steaks in Vancouver

m
mikeyjrd Nov 16, 2010 11:15 PM

What places in Vancouver serves porterhouse steaks??

Morton's is closed...any other places.??

Also where can you buy porterhouse steaks to cook at home??

thanks for the info

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. fmed RE: mikeyjrd Nov 17, 2010 04:50 AM

    Hy's, Gotham, The Shoreclub all have porterhouse. Not sure where you can buy porterhouse to cook at home. Try a butcher like Jackson's, Cioffi's, or Armando's (Granville Island)

    2 Replies
    1. re: fmed
      LotusRapper RE: fmed Nov 17, 2010 09:04 AM

      Armando's .... a real stalwart of utmost quality, service and value !

      I'd add Windsor Meats on Main/King Edward.

      1. re: LotusRapper
        v
        vancouvermatt RE: LotusRapper Feb 10, 2012 04:40 PM

        I would definately suggest visiting armando's. I buy ribeyes's from there and they are the best I've ever seen in a store. If they don't have it in the display case ask the staff. they do have some things hidden away in their fridge.

        Also if you are going out to get a steak go to Hy's. flame grilled with a smokey taste. Just cant be beat

    2. v
      vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 17, 2010 07:17 AM

      superstore sells grade AAA porterhouse

      15 Replies
      1. re: vandan
        m
        mikeyjrd RE: vandan Nov 17, 2010 05:01 PM

        i had steaks from superstore twice and i felt that their meat quality is not as good as Safeway..

        However, Safeway never has porterhouse steaks, just slightly bigger T-bones....

        how's the prices at these butcher places compared to franchise markets? if they have good quality and variety, i don't mind paying a little more..

        i live closer to Cioffi's, i can go check it out...

        1. re: mikeyjrd
          fmed RE: mikeyjrd Nov 17, 2010 06:38 PM

          Small butchers charge more, but usually have higher quality meat. Also they usually have a selection special order, game, offal, aged meats, sausages, etc. These places are worth the trip. Cioffi's, for example is a great Italian grocery and a great meat shop. One stop shopping if you include the green grocers close by and the liquor store across the street.

          1. re: mikeyjrd
            v
            vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 17, 2010 06:48 PM

            funny i find the opposite, as AAA is pretty much all i buy and safeways beef is for the most lower grade, just the look of it, the superstore rib-eye has way more marbling

          2. re: vandan
            v
            vandan RE: vandan Nov 17, 2010 05:13 PM

            sorry i totally lied i was thinking of t-bone,( as i'm a rib-eye guy so i never buy either),

            1. re: vandan
              m
              mikeyjrd RE: vandan Nov 17, 2010 10:08 PM

              i only get the steaks from the glass-case section in when i'm in safeway; they say the glass case stuff is always AAA

              i'm a striplion guy cuz of the charred/grilled flavor;

              i also enjoy rib-eye for its marbling, tenderness, and its easier to cook; however its hard to find a decent big piece...

              i went to the Keg last week and the sides tasted better than the steaks. i order a so-called kegsize NY striplion med-rare (it had a good grilled flavor) but felt it i was eating a med-well. My friend's prime-rib was tender but he said it was tasteless... My other friend had a sirlion, he said it was ok but it was a small steak...

              1. re: mikeyjrd
                v
                vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 18, 2010 06:00 AM

                right i forgot about the case i was referring to the packaged stuff

                1. re: mikeyjrd
                  v
                  vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 18, 2010 01:07 PM

                  omg was just @ safeway and had a look in the case , now i remember another reason i don"t buy AAA there, it was going for $39/kg and superstore sells it for $18-$19 ( half the price) thats a huuuuge difference for me

                  1. re: vandan
                    m
                    mikeyjrd RE: vandan Nov 18, 2010 03:32 PM

                    are you sure your comparing AAA in superstore to AAA in safeway ??
                    ~$20 diff. sounds a little unreasonable; maybe its a surprise sale or something..

                    1. re: mikeyjrd
                      v
                      vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 18, 2010 03:50 PM

                      i am talking about rib-eye here and yes that is the regular going price for them at superstore, i believe the highest i"ve ever seen them is still under $21, oh and that is also a club pack price, generally 3-4 per pack

                      1. re: vandan
                        fmed RE: vandan Nov 18, 2010 04:43 PM

                        Safeway is expensive. Urban Fare's prices are better.

                        1. re: fmed
                          v
                          vandan RE: fmed Nov 18, 2010 04:49 PM

                          now thats just plain scary

                          1. re: vandan
                            m
                            mikeyjrd RE: vandan Nov 18, 2010 10:11 PM

                            i'll go check out superstore by the weekend..

                            i like urban fare too,
                            is the Yaletown store biggest with free parking??

                            1. re: mikeyjrd
                              j
                              jcolvin RE: mikeyjrd Nov 20, 2010 08:28 PM

                              Thrifty Foods has a great butcher. well aged and great value. unfortunately you have to drive all the way to Tsawassen :(

                              1. re: jcolvin
                                b
                                badjack RE: jcolvin Nov 22, 2010 11:23 AM

                                Have to agree, Thrifty's meat is simply the best I've had (Coquitlam store instead of Tsww). Some claim that Costco also has great steaks but I don't think they carry porterhouse.

                                1. re: badjack
                                  j
                                  jcolvin RE: badjack Feb 5, 2012 01:49 PM

                                  I find Costco's steaks just don't compare to Thrifty's (not aged as much, I guess; you can tell just from the colour). Thrifty's compares well to pretty much any independent butcher. I had a huge porterhouse from Thrifty's on Salt Spring which they custom-cut extra-thick for me. Here it is about to be seared black-and-blue in the wood fire. Deep dark red, marbled, yellowish fat, crazy tender. Damn was that ever a good steak..

                                   
            2. b
              betterthanbourdain RE: mikeyjrd Nov 21, 2010 02:12 AM

              hy's has a bandsaw upstairs. you can custom order your steaks if you ask ahead.

              glowbal uses a double broil method similar to morton's. AAA 24oz $45. they have a 'case' to display the dry age steaks. link with pic attached:

              http://picasaweb.google.com/timetocho...

              FWIW, I prefered a well cooked charbroiled steak to a double broiled steak.

              iirc, a porterhouse is a rib steak with the tenderloin attached. tenderloin being so valuable they are not so common.

              all things being equal, if all the butchers have the same source of beef(they don't), then the difference in quality comes down to the handling, storage etc.. by the butchers.

              besides armando(better value), i have has some good luck with tenderland's dry aged beef, also on GI. Whole food also has dry age steaks which I have had mixed results.
              agree that the safeway beef 'in the case' steaks are expensive. only the safeway stores with a butcher are worth considering. but the case steaks esp if they are aged properly are far superior to the packed ones. I've never seen the porterhouse either.

              actually never really considered urban fare for beef. all three locations DT have similar butchery items. will look into it next time i am there. have tried meinhardt's and whole food's steaks. dont think meinhardt's has a porterhouse, and the locations have slightly different products. WF does dry age their steaks in house so you can check . but...

              i do prefer the smaller standalone butcher's. you can have a real conversation about what you are getting. but i find them either inconvenient or too far for me.

              2 Replies
              1. re: betterthanbourdain
                i
                islandgirl RE: betterthanbourdain Nov 21, 2010 09:03 AM

                I have to agree that the Safeway "in case" steaks are expensive at regular price but they often have something on sale that is usually an amazingly good deal.

                1. re: betterthanbourdain
                  j
                  jahvay RE: betterthanbourdain Dec 12, 2010 11:36 PM

                  In fact the Porterhouse is the best of the T Bone steaks. It is a t shaped bone with Filet├ętenderloin on one side and Striploin, or New York striploin on the other side. No Rib steak involved.

                2. h
                  headcat RE: mikeyjrd Nov 21, 2010 11:38 AM

                  been buying meat at HopCott in Pitt Meadows lately. Best steak I have ever tasted - worth the trip:

                  http://www.hopcottmeats.ca/

                  Scooter

                  1. j
                    jahvay RE: mikeyjrd Nov 24, 2010 12:31 AM

                    Superstore, Safeway, Cioffis, Armando, yes, you can get a good steak at any of these places, and you can also buy a just okay steak. AAA is excellent quality beef, and PRIME is even better. Armandos has Prime, but it will cost you a premium.

                    The trick is to be able to pick out a good quality piece of beef from the counter. If you can recognise the characteristics of a good steak you will have a good chance of picking out tasty beef, or avoid a lesser quality.

                    Myself, I work at Gotham, so I sell Canada Prime Grain fed beef. It is serious tasty beef. Peoples eyes glaze over from the quality.

                    Today I cooked at home. The 5 NY striploins I picked out at the Superstore were excellent. I found a pack with ample fat marbling, and cut thick. I also noticed some not so great cuts. You just have to be able to pick out the right one...

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: jahvay
                      j
                      jcolvin RE: jahvay Feb 5, 2012 01:58 PM

                      The trouble is that supermarkets rarely age their meat, regardless of grade. Often a well-aged AA will be a better steak than a piece of AAA fresh off the cow, regardless of marbling. While the supermarkets sometimes offer high-grade meat, it rarely seems to have sufficient aging. The majority of supermarket shoppers like that new "bright-red" look to their meat, so that is what they provide.

                      1. re: jcolvin
                        KarenDW RE: jcolvin Feb 5, 2012 08:26 PM

                        one could "age" the cut at home... on a rack, unwrapped, in the fridge.

                    2. v
                      vandan RE: mikeyjrd Nov 24, 2010 05:59 PM

                      fyi, was at superstore today, aaa striploin was $13.20/kg, cap off(with bone) aaa rib-eye was $16.10/ kg and boneles rib-eye was $18.39/kg

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: vandan
                        m
                        mikeyjrd RE: vandan Nov 30, 2010 10:26 PM

                        i had a dinner party at my friend's place last weekend. he got striplions from save-on and price-smart.....Mine was med & it was acceptable; my other friend had a med-well and he said it was tough ....

                        i guess i'm not going to those places ever to get steaks....I'll give super-store another try probably this week...

                      2. c
                        Craft Service RE: mikeyjrd Dec 11, 2010 01:36 AM

                        You can buy Porterhouse steaks at Heritage Meats in Langley. A bit expensive as they cater and double as a specialty gourmet store at the same time. However, probably no more so than supermarket prices. Also, Glory Meats in Surrey I'm sure also has Porterhouse steaks and they're much more reasonable in their pricing.

                        1. b
                          Burnabylifer RE: mikeyjrd Dec 12, 2010 03:53 PM

                          Beefway Meats on Kingsway in Vancouver is an old school butcher that supplies several major restaurants. They definitely will be able to give you an excellent porterhouse. Your best bet for one cooked for you is Hy's.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: Burnabylifer
                            c
                            ck1234 RE: Burnabylifer Dec 12, 2010 05:26 PM

                            I love Beefway for their home made chicken cordon bleu's. I have bought these by the dozens over the years...

                          2. c
                            cucinelle RE: mikeyjrd Dec 13, 2010 08:19 AM

                            Famous Foods on Kingsway & 25th has a great butcher who hand cuts all their meat. Also stocking at times wild boar, bison, fresh duck, and rabbit along with the usual suspects, organic, non-medicated, free range included. It seems to vary upon availability but I've always got a fine cut. Also place an order and he will get it for you. The best advice is to learn what a good cut of meat looks like as jahvay says and you're on the way to grilling bliss!!

                            1. d
                              DeeBee58 RE: mikeyjrd Feb 4, 2012 06:49 PM

                              We have a Super Value out here in Deep Cove whose meat is far better quality than either Safeway or Superstore. To tell the truth, the meat department at Superstore kind of scares me. Queensdale Market at the top of Lonsdale is excellent as well. In East Van, I go to Columbus Meats at Renfrew and First. Excellent service and quality. I bought some beautiful rib-eyes last time for about five bucks each. The guys always ask if you want sausages to go with the steaks. I said 'Sure' last time, trying to fit in, you know. They were awesome.

                              1 Reply
                              1. re: DeeBee58
                                c
                                ctas1906 RE: DeeBee58 Feb 4, 2012 09:33 PM

                                Pied a Terre has 32 oz double cut porterhouse on menu at the moment. Serious cut of beef. Delicious as well.

                                http://www.pied-a-terre-bistro.ca/men...

                              Show Hidden Posts