Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Nov 9, 2010 05:35 PM

SF Hound in Town

Hi Manhattan Hounds! Husband and I are heading East to visit friends for a long weekend (Fri to Tues) in a couple weeks. We will be staying in Brooklyn. The only thing planned is Friday late night dinner at Babbo (super excited; missed it last time I was in town). Looking for recommendations for the following:

1. Can't miss cheap eats (example, if someone were coming to SF, I'd recommend heading to the Mission for a big, fat al pastor burrito at Taqueria Cancun).

2. Pizza - I love the thin and the thick so long as the sauce is dynamite! (I love Pizzaiolo in Berkeley but I also like North Beach Pizza).

3. Some hot dog place that is supposed to be amazing---where is it??

4. Reasonably priced ($15-20/entree) restaurant for dinner or lunch. French sounds good...we don't have many reasonably priced French around us (other than Fringale).

5. Great happy hour for Friday and Monday.

FYI, I've posted something similar on the Brooklyn board.

110 Waverly Pl, New York, NY 10011

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. 1. Can't miss cheap eats

    How cheap is cheap? The pastrami at Katz's is not really all that cheap ($15), but it's an iconic NYC food. Pizza, bagels with smoked salmon (will definitely be on the more expensive side of cheap), an egg cream, pickles, though, are typically pretty cheap.

    Please help me eat during a month in New York - some of the nouveau cheap eats around town

    Don't leave NY without eating these foods - focused on the more iconic NYC foods

    For cheap eats, try out some street food -- lots of interesting ethnic here that you might not find in SF:

    I highly recommend RGR's self guided Lower East Side Gustatory tour as a way to do some of the iconic NYC foods, just sub in Pickle Guys for Guss' Pickles:

    2. Pizza

    There are a few different species of thin crust pizza in NY. The Naples inspired whole pies, the coal oven thin crusted traditional NY whole pies (these places usually don't do slices), the gas oven chewier greasy street slice. Not much in the way of thicker crusts unless you mean a square or Grandma slice.

    I find that a lot of NYC pizza is pretty light on the sauce, though, so if you're a sauce-centric person, you might be disappointed.

    A lot of places here in the coal oven and gas oven NY style use canned sauce, so I'm hesitant to recommend one to you. And there's a lot of Naples inspired pizza places in SF these days, so it might not make sense to have that in NY.

    3. Some hot dog place that is supposed to be amazing---where is it?

    Papaya Dog or Gray's Papaya are iconic NYC eats. The dogs themselves aren't that amazing. They are mass produced. Note that an NYC dog is usually all beef, whereas other cities you'll find a beef/pork blend.

    There's no really famous gourmet hot dog place in Manhattan like Chicago has with Hot Doug's. Maybe you're thinking of Nathan's on Coney Island (great atmosphere, haven't really found the food itself to be all that special)?

    My personal favorite, though, is Crif Dogs because they deep fry the hot dogs (no batter), NJ style. They use a beef/pork blend hot dog unlike a lot of other places in NYC. And they have a variety of interesting toppings like cream cheese, bacon, avocado, etc. But it's not what you think of when people talk about a classic NY hot dog.

    Pickle Guys
    49 Essex St, New York, NY 10002

    Crif Dogs
    113 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10009

    Gray's Papaya
    539 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018

    1 Reply
      1. For pizza I would recommend Arturo's on Houston. It's a restaurant that hasn't been changed for decades (the bathroom has a bathtub in it for example), but their pizza is really excellent. A large will feed 2-3 people at about $19. It is popular but if there is a wait it goes fairly fast (about 30 minutes when I went last). The sauce was delicious and they have some live jazz. I just moved out here from San Fran and I thought it was a pretty good experience as far as pizza places I've tried.

        Outside of that there are places like Co., Keste, Totonno's, and Lucali (in brooklyn), but I don't know how New York-y they are.

        1544 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028

        1 Reply
        1. re: XerxesAB

          Yeah, Arturo's has good sauce and a good margherita. I like their pizza ai funghi a lot and also like their clam pizza, which is unique in my experience.

        2. Since you are staying in Brooklyn you will find fabulous pizza @:
          Lucali in Cobble Hill
          Tottonno in Coney Island
          DiFar in Midwood
          L&B Spumoni Garden for unique Sicilian style pizza

          1. I think $15-20 entree might be hard to hit for French - most of the places I'm familiar with are in the $20-25 range. I did look up my old med school standby (Flea Market) which is still in the $15-20 range but it's by no means a destination restaurant.

            Le Mangeoire appears to be doable in that range if you order the smaller portions, which are reportedly adequate for most appetites, and the chef is Christian Delouvrier, formerly of Lespinasse.

            My impression from various reports is that most bistros in the $20-25 range are good, but not destination-worthy, so if you have a preferred neighborhood, that might belp people pick a place.

            I would actually consider Prune, which is not straightforward French, but is heavily French-influenced. It's very personal and creative cooking from Gabrielle Hamilton.

            The other place I strongly, strongly recommend for Bay Area visitors is Momofuku Ssam Bar, which does exceptional creative modern Asian. We still don't have anything like it, although I'm starting to see its influence in a few places.

            Momofuku Ssam Bar
            207 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003

            1 Reply
            1. re: daveena

              I will definitely go to Momofuku. Sounds interesting. Would be interested in comparing it to some of our Asian fusion restaurants out here.