HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >

Napa Valley

cherishg Oct 26, 2010 10:59 PM

With Terra and French Laundry closed for Xmas, I opted for Redd where we now have reservations for xmas eve. Should I have gone with Medowood? I'm only asking because it recently got 3 Michelin stars. Most people seem to highly recommend Redd. Any thoughts?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. d
    Dawgmommy RE: cherishg Oct 27, 2010 04:05 PM

    I went back in March and it was great. Have reservations for Nov 19 (made before the 3 stars), will let you know. The atmospere is more subdued, but they definitely make you feel special. You can also check out an example of their fall menu on their website.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Dawgmommy
      d
      Dawgmommy RE: Dawgmommy Oct 28, 2010 06:45 PM

      oh, one more thing... I would recommend the prix fix menu rather than the tasting menu unless you're a huge eater. The tasting menu is just way too much food. Meadowood doesn't get the buzz because it's a little bit out of the way, inside a resort and private club.

    2. l
      Littleman RE: cherishg Oct 28, 2010 07:56 PM

      I was at Meadowood not too long ago. It's a great resort but the restaurant is quiet, secluded and has very little atmosphere to me. The food was outstanding. I just thought I was at a funeral home. Even the bar was quiet and it was prime season. Go to Redd.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Littleman
        maria lorraine RE: Littleman Oct 29, 2010 08:58 PM

        I, on the other hand, find the restaurant elegant, restrained and swanky, with soft lighting, plush booths and professional service. Amazing meal and experience.

        I suppose it depends on what you like. I find the food wonderful at Redd, but the interior, to me, is noisy, austere, and not as comfortable as I'd like. The front room is especially lacking.

        1. re: maria lorraine
          d
          Dawgmommy RE: maria lorraine Oct 30, 2010 11:02 AM

          It does depend on the atmosphere you are looking for.

          Maybe I'm just getting old, I like it that Meadowood is more quiet, and you can use your indoor voice to have a conversation. The seating is comfortable so you don't get a sore back at the end of dinner... ;)

          The staff address you as Mr & Mrs, gives you a wrap to keep you warm when you go to the facilities (you have to walk thru an outside walkway). I find the experience very genteel.

          BTW, the chef was recently on Iron Chef and won against Cat Cora in battle Oat Meal.

          1. re: Dawgmommy
            cherishg RE: Dawgmommy Oct 30, 2010 08:12 PM

            Hmmmm maybe I should find a way to have dinner at both places! =) Thanks for your replies!

      Show Hidden Posts