Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Chains >
Oct 19, 2010 04:38 PM

Pumpkin Ice Cream is BACK at Trader Joe's!!!

It's NOT called Double Rainbow Pumpkin Ice Cream, it's called Pilgrim Joe's Pumpkin Ice Cream Super Premium. I don't know if it's the same formula, but it's AWESOME! It tastes like one of the best Pumpkin Pies that I've ever had, only as Ice Cream. I gotta stock up my freezer with enough to try to last a year. Good thing that I don't eat much ice cream, bad thing is that this stuff is SOOO good and addictive that I may go through it too fast to last. Yum!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. oh, yay! thanks for posting, darclyte...the fleur de sel caramel sauce will be TDF on that great stuff! off to joe's now!

    1. I saw the empty spot on monday at my TJ's. I just kind of stared at it for awhile. Gotta check again tomorrow. Early. I did score some truffles though. Can't Believe I'm buying truffles before halloween. But last year I missed out and learned a bitter lesson. :)

      1 Reply
      1. re: givemecarbs

        Just posted about this. It taste like Pumpkin Pie or a can of Regular Libby's (NOT the mix mind you)??

      2. Could you please reply with your locations if you've found it? I'd like to know specifically about NC and the East Coast as we've been shafted in the past when it has come to the West Coast. Thanks.

        5 Replies
        1. re: Erika RollerGirl

          I live in the Detroit Metro area, and it was the store on Woodward Ave in Royal Oak that had TONS of it last week. I plan on going again tomorrow, so we'll see what they have left.

          1. re: Erika RollerGirl

            My cheerless TJs is near philly in north wales or montgomeryville. Managed to score two containers of it this past tuesday and there were about four left. Now if I could only get beer and wine there.

            1. re: Erika RollerGirl

              Erika, I got it in Burlington, MA - the case had probably about 10 quarts of the stuff. They're MINE, I tells ya - all MINE! Bah-hah-hah-hah-hahhhhhhh!!!!!

              1. re: Erika RollerGirl

                We had it this week at the LAX Trader Joes... Didn't get it, but the checker was raving... it tastes like Pumpkin Pie he said...


                1. re: Erika RollerGirl

                  Trader Joes in silver spring, MD was sampling it last week!(and I second the "if only I could get beer and wine there" sentiment)

                2. I just got it today at my local TJs today - the woman at the taste-test counter said she didn't think it was Double Rainbow repackaged with TJ's branding, but after having a small bowl after my dinner tonight, it's pretty darn close! Creamy, nice pumpkin and spice flavor - I'm definitely going back to buy more to stock up they way you are planning, darclyte! LOL

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: LindaWhit

                    In the Thanksgiving flyer we just got, the item about the ice cream says that TJ's worked with a "colorful" supplier...

                    1. re: coney with everything

                      Missed that in the T'giving flyer! Then I'd assume it is repackaged Double Rainbow.

                  2. Meh. PJ's rendition of pumpkin ice cream is probably one of my least favorites considering how good their regular flavors are. It's too heavy on spice and has an odd egg nog undertone that just doesn't belong (too much nutmeg, methinks). Anyway, they have it at the Rockridge, Oakland store and you can have them.

                    3 Replies
                    1. re: oniontears

                      Completely agree with this last comment. This new brand tastes nothing like the previous one. The spice and nutmeg were extremely overpowering, and the pumpkin flavor was faint. I had to mix this ice cream with a higher ratio of plain vanilla ice cream just to make it palatable.

                      1. re: NYC212

                        We do have it in NC! Thanks for all the feedback! Unfortunately I agree with the comments stating it is not as good as the Double Rainbow version from before. It was good but it wasn't mindblowing as I had remembered it to be.

                        I almost prefer taking Haagen Daz Five vanilla bean ice cream and adding some Trader Joe's Pumpkin Butter as a topping to get my pumpkin ice cream fix.

                      2. re: oniontears

                        I agree -- and it's waaay too sweet. Yuck! I actually actively dislike it, and I usually like pumpkin flavored items.