Elizabeth's is a cab ride from your hotel. Local ll Ten is a pretty good ways also. Noble Fare is about 15 blocks but they are short blocks. The Ole Pink House is the closest at about 3 blocks E of your hotel. I would go with Noble or Pink so you could walk. You will need the exercise after a fine meal.
Flip a coin. They are all outstanding. Elizabeth's is old Savannah located in a beautiful old historical home. Local 11 Ten is a casual fine dining restaurant located in a 1950's restored building serving local southern cuisine. Noble Fare is similar in style and cuisine to Local ll Ten. The Old Pink House is similar to Elizabeth's.
I would probably go to OPH. Bon Appetit.
Bon Appetit Restaurant
621 Highway 441 S, Clayton, GA 30525