Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Sep 21, 2010 03:57 PM

Santarpio's Peabody

Santarpios opened last Wednesday in a very subdued manner with little publicity. I was heading home mid afternoon today and stopped for a late lunch at the bar.The menu is exactly like the original place, lamb, sausage and pizza. I opted for a cheese pizza with garlic priced at a pretty reasonable 12 bucks or so. Service was pretty good; there were 3 people behind the bar.

They have a full bar, fair beer selection and house wines by the glass or! The pizza came out in a reasonable time and was it ever garlicy! Great for me but others might be put off as it was strong. The crust was that quasi-New Haven type, a little charred but not as thin as Pepe's or Sally's. Good flavored sauce and fresh cheese. The folks working there were nice enough but seemed a bit stressed which I guess would be normal with a new opening.

Overall, I liked the pizza....again, it is NOT New Haven but nothing is. The only off putting thing I can think of is the amount of coarse corn meal that is on the pizza. It adds a bit of gritiness that can be a little daunting at first but you get used to it after the first slice. I fully intend to go back for some of that sausage and lamb; it looked fantastic as it was coming to others at the bar.

Check it out if you are on the north shore and have gone to the East Boston location. The pizza is very close to the original and I think you will like it.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Is the crust flabby or somewhat soggy in the middle, like is often the case in Eastie?

    8 Replies
    1. re: Karl S

      Not on the pie I had last week. It was actually way too thick on one side- almost a half inch.

      1. re: Chris VR

        I agree with you. The crust was a bit eccentric, too thick i some spots, something they hopefully will work out in time. Some of the slices were almost perfect, some not. Good flavor, though. I am going to give them a week to iron out the wrinkles and give them another shot

        1. re: Cheffrank

          pizza at its best is imperfect. its like tryin to wait for it to cool, impossible for even jobe. what i like about santarps is the battle of flavors inside your mouth, sauce cheese corn meal all bold and ready to win the battle over tastebuds. havent tried pebidy yet hopefully wont have to.

          1. re: drudy

            has anyone tried anything beside the Pizza? heard the Lamb is not so great, kinda chewy. Haven't been to the old one in years, would like to try the new one

            1. re: bark

              I had the sausage. It's a sizeable link, with enough spiciness to it that my lielee one who loves sausage tok a pass. It had a very smoky charcoal grill flavor to it. Pretty much exactly how I remembered it from the original.

      2. re: Karl S

        The crust was soggy, the cheese/pepperoni pizza painfully salty (and for me this is quite an accomplishment), and the wait for our pie: 2 hours. I'll be back.

        1. re: almansa

          Was it really 2 hours from the time you ordered till the pizza arrived at the table? Or does that include waiting for a table?

          1. re: erwocky

            I meant to clarify: 2 hours after ordering, but the server was clearly mortified.

      3. Ate here tonight. We ordered a sausage pizza and one skewer of the BBQ lamb. Both were yummy. Lamb was juicy and medium rare and just enough crisp / char on outside...and loved their pizza. Sauce is so good, they put the sausage under the cheese and the crust is crispy...a bit thicker than I anticipated, but the cornmeal on the bottom keeps it crisp. Since I do not frequent Santarpio's in East Boston due to annoying parking situation, it was nice to finally get to try it in house (the only other time I ate their pizza was take out a long time ago and it really is much better eaten on site). My only complaint is they have a lot of young inexperienced young lad was carrying two pizzas to a table next to ours and he had the tins stacked on top of each other. I thought that seemed a bit gross to have the bottom of your tin pan touching the cheesy top of your second pizza. Seemed kind of not the most sanitary way to
        deliver to the table and unappetizing. But, I'll be back anyway since I loved the pizza.

        2 Replies
        1. re: bostongal

          For what it's worth, I've never had a problem parking near the East Boston location!

          1. re: Blumie

            We had a cheese pizza (take-out) on Tuesday. I've had better and won't rush back there again.

        2. Went last night, it was mobbed with a wait of 45 minurtes, OK it's new, I don't have an issue with the wait. Our table ordered the lamb and sausage for starters, the lamb was dried out, definately been in the oven, keeping warm, for some time. It was grissley and had no char or grilled flavor, hey for a fiver not tragic. Next, the pizza, ordered a version with too many toppings, not my choice, center extremely soggy. However the dough was very flat tasting and appeared to be preped using a 'sheeter' to get the dough thin. The doness was another story, nothing like Eastie, not even close, I'm convinced that the old oven makes the product. Service was excellent and cordial, nothing like Eastie, which I enjoy. Not rushing back but, will give it another try when the dust settles.

          1. Since I haven't seen this info anywhere at all (including either of the newspaper reviews, which seems quite lame on the part of the authors): their phone number is 978 535 1811, and they're open (at least for now) until 11pm nightly. Presumably that'll make it onto eventually, but not yet.

            It's not totally straightforward to get to from 128/I-95 since the ramps onto US 1 north bypass Santarpio's, but if you take the left fork to Dearborn Rd. (partway down that ramp) you can turn left on Dearborn and then their parking lot will be on the right just before you get to 1.

            1 Reply
            1. re: kf2vv

              True, one challenge is dealing with rte1.

            2. We finally made it to the new location. Had the grilled sausage and a pizza. Place wasn't that busy, just about half full, so there wasn't a wait. The sausage, bread, and cherry pepper is exactly the the same as the original location. The pizza was nearly exact as well. The crust was nicely burnt on the edges, bottom had the requisite cornmeal for bite, but the texture . . well . . it was the same pizza. I'm definitely happy they opened this second location as it's much more accessible for me. The service was prompt and good, but the waiter hovered a bit as he was looking to leave and we were the last table in his section (it was before 10). I hate being rushed when I still have food & drink in my hands.

              3 Replies
              1. re: bewley

                What night of the week did you go and what time?

                1. re: bewley

                  That was my experience exactly. Got there (Wed, Thurs?) at about 6:30, sat at the bar and had the same sausage, lamb and sausage/garlic pizza. Food was right outta easta bost. Got pretty busy by about 7:30 but with the pleasant bartender there was no wait for a beer refill.

                  1. re: powerfulpierre

                    Good to hear. Sounds like they have worked out the new opening kinks.