Maine trip- should it be Natalie's in Camden or Marcel's in Rockport or Primo in Rockland?

[hopegoode]

We'll have one night for a splurge restaurant. Not clear which of these is the best... We have gone to Chef Kelly's first restaurant in NY, which preceded Primo's, and enjoyed it immensely. However, recent threads have revealed disappointed diners there. We are open to to other suggestions as well for that special night. Can you help us?

[MidCoastMaineiac]

No question...Primo. I'd like to see those recent threads...I'm not aware of it. In any event, you'll always get the occasional kook.

[Shooley]

Definitely don't make it Marcel's. If I were choosing, I'd choose Primo hands down.