Key West Key Lime pie throwdown - who's your fave?
Years ago I would have answered No Name Pub, but their pie isn't what it used to be. Anymore I would have to say Blond Giraffe. I've heard good things about Roof Top Cafe, but I haven't sampled it myself. Ditto on the Cracked Conch. I used to try every one I could find in the Keys, but I haven't been doing the taste test rounds over the past five years or so. I'm sure there will be some more replies to this one.
No Name Pub
30831 Watson Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043
Cracked Conch Cafe
4999 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Unfortunately, the Blond Giraffe went out of business. They had the best Key Lime Pie and I just hope someone else has the recipe. The second best is the Key West Key Lime Shop down on the harbor across from Conch Republic. It is very limey and tart.
Key Lime Cafe
211 Colorado Ave, Stuart, FL 34994