HOME > Chowhound > Italy >
What have you made lately?

Florence - Need Recs for 3 Dinners and 3 Lunches

jmk38 Sep 7, 2010 04:46 PM

My husband and I will be in Florence for 3 nights and 3 days. We are staying south of the Arno
not far from Ponte Vecchio. I would love recommendations for good, local food for our lunches and
dinners - we love to eat well but do not want to break the bank. Some of the ones on
my list of possibilities are:
Quattro Leoni
Osteria del Cinghiale Bianco
Il Guscio
Il Ratini
La Cantinetta Verrazzano
Feel free to comment on the list but I also welcome other suggestions.
Thank you in advance!

  1. pikawicca Sep 21, 2010 01:03 PM

    Can someone direct jmk to the hole-in-the-wall (literally) place that makes the fantastic sandwiches? IIRC, it's near the Ponte Vecchio. No tables, but I had the best sandwich ever there.

    2 Replies
    1. re: pikawicca
      zerlina Sep 21, 2010 08:21 PM

      I think you mean I Fratellini, half-way between the Duomo and the Ponte Vecchio.

      1. re: zerlina
        pikawicca Sep 21, 2010 08:28 PM

        You nailed it! In my book, this is a don't miss lunch stop.

    2. j
      jfrao Sep 21, 2010 12:51 PM

      I highly recomend La Giostria which is not far from your hotel. The food, service, wine and atmosphere was terrific. It was one of the best meals my wife and I had in Italy. We asked our waiter to recommend our food and he picked out delicious courses and recommended some outstanding local wine. The kitchen is run by the owner and chef who turns out great meals.

      If you want to try a casual lunch like the locals, I recommend you go to the large market a few blocks from the doumo. It's about the size of a football field, lined with various food stalls selling all kinds of food to the locals. There are several small informal restaurants around the inside of the market that sell good traditional food at very reasonable prices. But most of all, the experience of taking in the local "feel" of the market and people is a show unto itself.

      1. The Florentine Sep 11, 2010 03:48 AM

        right near the Ponte Vecchio:
        Golden View Open Bar, very nice place with stunning overview, sometimes in there is live jazz music in the evening

        Il Latini was nice but i absolutely prefer Marione, if it’s possible for your lunch choose the room with the vaulted ceiling and exposed brickwork. At Marione you will find good food, simplicity and good price.
        Top for bistecca is Sostanza (but call him Troia as we do....) book in advance and bring cash with you, they don't accept card.

        a very tipical luch at Nerbone: inside the
        Mercato Centrale (central market) in San Lorenzo since 1874; you take a
        fast full immersion in the Florentinity trend, you can try trippa alla fiorentina,
        pappa al pomodoro, or a plate piled with boiled potatoes and a single
        fat sausage. But the mainstay here is a panino with lampredotto, a boiled
        beef sandwich that's bagnato (dipped in the meat juices), my absolute favourite,
        ask for it with salt, pepper and green souce. Eat standing with the crowd of
        old men at the side counter, sipping glasses of wine, or fight for one of the few
        tables against the wall. Be sure to get there till 12.30 – 13.00 or you risk a long
        queue for your specialities, infact Nerbone is very very famous for Florentine
        people and you find there a lot of workers of the nearby, from the young boy to the old manager.
        While you are going there you’ll pass inside “San Lorenzo Market” from piazza San Lorenzo to via dell'Ariento, all around his Basilica (in the very historical center of the city) you can find probably the most important market of the city. Just walk around searching for clothing, articles in leather, souvenirs, etc.

        finally one, take a look of what you see from the Rinascente terrace while you are sipping an aperitvo or a nice lunch.

        The Florentine
        follow me on: http://www.weekend-in-florence.com/fl...

        1. l
          LotsC Sep 10, 2010 02:18 AM

          Marione is a good lunch place....re bistecca i know Osteria de Benci does it,,,

          1. Irene65 Sep 10, 2010 01:23 AM

            Lunches - Bank safe ;-)

            da Nerbone - Trattoria - near San Lorenzo Market
            a really convivial place, you will share the table

            Mario - Trattoria - Via della Rosina
            open only for lunch
            you might share the table


            Il Cibreo - the Trattoria - not the Restaurant - near San'Ambrogio Market
            very small place - reasonably priced

            Hosteria del Bricco - Trattoria - San Niccolò
            small place - reasonably price

            A bank breaking treat
            very elegant, romantic, awfully expensive - around 250 Euro each with no wine
            2010 3 forks Gambero Rosso
            Enoteca Pinchiorri

            Enjoy your holiday

            1. ttoommyy Sep 8, 2010 10:44 AM

              Out of the restaurants you listed, I've only been to Osteria del Cinghiale Bianco and found it just OK. My favorite restaurant in Florence is Taverna del Bronzino.

              3 Replies
              1. re: ttoommyy
                jmk38 Sep 9, 2010 05:32 PM

                Thank you both for your suggestions. I will add them to my list. Also glad to hear you LotsC find
                Quattro Leoni and Cinghiale Bianco overrated. I know for one of our dinners we want to have
                the traditional bistecca Fiorentina. Where would you recommend we go for that? Thanks!

                1. re: jmk38
                  jen kalb Sep 9, 2010 07:32 PM

                  Here are a few places that have been recommended for bistecca:

                  of these I have only been to Mario - very good food, very unpretentious, but we didnt have the bistecca.

                  1. re: jmk38
                    ttoommyy Sep 10, 2010 08:00 AM

                    "I know for one of our dinners we want to have
                    the traditional bistecca Fiorentina. Where would you recommend we go for that? Thanks!"

                    Taverna del Bronzino does a wonderful bistecca!

                2. l
                  LotsC Sep 8, 2010 04:05 AM

                  I would say that Vini e Vecchi Sapori is excellent for lunch, really fine food and very popular with the locals some of who dine there every day. If you head to San Miniato I always love Fuori Porta which is a very good enoteca on the way up or down for lunch. Re restaurants Buca del Orafo is very good and buzzing. A typical cellar restaurant with excellent food and good atmosphere, I always rave about Osteria de Benci but then it has never let me down and has looked after people I ve recommended it to over the years. La Posta on Via Pelliceria (very close to piazza della Republica) is very good and popular with locals but never seems to be recognised on these boards which I daresay is a good thing. I have heard good things about Il Guscio, Pane e Vino and Osteria Caffe Italiano which I hope to try on my next visit in November. Also Trattoria del Carmine is very good. To be honest and in my personal opinion I find Quattro Leoni over rated and also the same goes for Osteria del Cinghiale Biano....but whatever you choose I hope you have a fantastic time and remember that everybody has different tastebuds, enjoys different places and has different experiences.....but hope this helps

                  Show Hidden Posts