Mike's Dairy Place
I was there a few months ago. We loved it- but it's more of a neighborhood pizza shop (Mike's words) than a proper restaurant. Basically, you wait on line to order and once you order, you're seated by a hostess. The food is brought out by a waiter. Prices are pretty good, considering the location.
Menu is pizza (slices, pies, individual pies), salads, pasta, and some pasta salad type items. I liked that you could choose from a list of toppings to add to a single slice.. I think my square focaccia slice with portobello mushrooms was about $4.
The staff was super nice- even on a crowded Saturday night. Everyone was so friendly and their recommendations were all great.
pizza is delicious, pastas are also great, especially the homemade stuff. i personally love the mac and cheese. however, it seats around 15 people and its very small with your local pizza shop ambience...not quite a restaurant. would be hard to sit at a table with more than 4-5 ppl, max.