Brooklyn Farmacy on Henry St.
Yes, twice. Excellent both times. Really good, fresh ice cream, good fruit for sundaes, shakes and pies, really good whipped cream, pleasant service. A nice addition to the neighborhood, I think. The first time we went we had an unbelievable blueberry milkshake - mostly vanilla ice cream with pieces of fresh berries. This past time it was made with fresh sauce which we didn't like quite as well. Sundaes were excellent, as were ice cream sodas.