HOME > Chowhound > Spirits >

Discussion

Lower end Scotch tastes

OK.............. so I think I know lots about wine, but I know diddley about scotch. I tend to like it on the rocks but (as with wine) there are tastes that I like and those I don't. I'm not really into the better stuff these days, so I'm looking for anything that comes close to the taste of Chivas for about 30% less or so. I've tried Cutty @ around $23 for 1.75L and find it too strong for my taste (I wish I knew more of the language to use). J&B was even more tough for me.

So............ what does anyone think I'd like in that price range <$25 for 1.5L. I guess than translates to upper teens for 750ml. Pricing is for SoCal if that helps.

Also, any thoughts one vocabulary to describe this would be helpful.

Thanks.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. The best deal in blended Scotch is Famous Grouse which is right about at $25 for a 1.75L. They usually have it in 1Ls at Trader Joe's for less than $20. Between Chivas, Cutty and J&B, it's definitely more similar to Chivas, though it's richer and I much prefer it to Chivas.

    5 Replies
    1. re: sku

      I use to be a Dewers drinker back when but for a blended scotch Famous Grouse is excellent. It has an impressive list of single malts in the blend.

      1. re: sku

        Totally agree with you, not too impressed with Chivas, but that is the great thing about Scotch, everyone's pallet is different. I like Dewars White.

        1. re: Kailyn06

          One thing I noticed about Dewars White recently. I never drink it, but I used it in creating a cocktail at one restaurant, and it was very smoky. I was in another place and playing with it and their was no smoke taste. Does it normally vary like this?

          1. re: JMF

            Maybe the second place didn't really have Dewars in the bottle. Just sayin suppose.

            1. re: Hughlipton

              No, I was in charge of the beverage program at both places.

      2. The only two low-priced Scotch blends I have bought that I will buy again are White Horse and Teacher's Highland Cream, both about $16 for a 750 here in NC. I prefer both to Chivas, but haven't had enough of the Chivas to really compare the taste profiles, just a couple mini bottles - I just remember thinking JW Black was much much better in the same price range as Chivas, so no reason to buy a whole bottle.

        I hated J+B, really has a nasty finish to me. I have also hated Ballantines and Dewars white label, and found Famous Grouse and Glen Salen to be OK but not nearly as good as the two I mentioned earlier.

        2 Replies
          1. re: DavidT

            I agree with him completely - this is an "every day" type of Scotch, when I just feel like having some but not necessarily hitting a $50 bottle of Ardbeg 10 or Highland Park 12.

            There are also a few low-priced single malts I have had which are decent. Tamdhu is not bad at all for $21 here, not the most interesting but it doesn't have anything unpleasant about it either. I also rather like the McClellands islay for $23 here in NC (prob less in CA) - I have heard it is a 5 yr old Bowmore, and though it does taste like a watered-down "real" Islay, it does have some smoke, peat and brine to it, probably the most interesing "cheap" single malt I have had.

        1. This information is very helpful. Please keep it coming.

          I was at my local 'best overall selection' wine & spirits shop yesterday and picked up a 750 of Black Bottle. First impression is that it's easier drinking than the Cutty I'm just finishing up, and much smoother than the J &B. Not sure I love it as much as Chivas, but a nice change so far.

          I went to that paricular shop because they sell a lot of 'mini-bar' bottles, but the choices were pretty nil among the scotches discussed so far.

          2 Replies
          1. re: Midlife

            I think Famous Grouse, Teacher's and Black Bottle pretty much covers your best bets for blended scotch at a reasonable price. Bell's is a big seller in Scotland and is worth trying.

            Since you live in SoCal, you might want to swing by a Trader Joe's and look for Glen Moray single-malt at $20 or Finlaggan single-malt around $18. In theory, they are a step up from the blends. The Glen Moray is a Speyside whisky, rather smooth and "sweet." The Finlaggan is from the Isle of Islay and is smokey/peaty. Both will give you some sense of the characteristics of the regions they come from.

            1. re: DavidT

              I wish I could get Black Bottle here in NC . Or Black Grouse.

              Here's an interesting article

              http://whiskyparty.net/?page_id=1569

          2. Bailie Nicol Jarvie (often called BNJ) is an excellent blended Scotch whisky, with a relatively high percentage on single-malts in the blend. It is produced by Glenmorangie. Unfortunately, I believe it is not available in the U.S. Should you ever see it, be sure to give it a try.

            http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bailie_N...

            http://whiskyforeveryone.blogspot.com...

            1. It's important to note that there is no right or wrong answer here. I prefer an Islay single malt every time (especially Laphroag) and have for over 40 years but I have friends who are much better "tasters" than me who prefer other malts. For a reasonably priced blend, I like Teachers, though a well respected friend had me try some Black Grouse. For just a nudge up in price, I must say I'd buy the Grouse for a party of whisky drinkers. I gave my brother-in-law a 1.5L of Cutty a year ago for his whisky drinking friends. He still has 1/4 of a bottle left but has gone through 4 bottles of Dewars.
              I guess his friends feel the same way about Cutty as I do-- it's not very flavorful compared to Dewars. You should just keep sampling until you find one or more that you like.