Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
Jul 22, 2010 09:02 AM

Best fish shack in LBI - Long Beach Island?

Hi there,

We have reservations at Daddy O's and Plantation, (any opinions welcome), but as the trip comes closer, I'm in the mood for some good simple seafood at a place with a water view (hopefully). Old and funky is fine. Just want something local, great, friendly and not too hard to get into on a Saturday. Don't mind a wait if there's a good bar. Thanks so much!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Boulevard Clams in Surf City. No question. No water view, or view of anything to speak of, but fabulous. Best seafood anywhere. Most of the places with a view will be higher-end and hard to get seated at on a Saturday night. If you really want a peaceful night and a view, get take out from Boulevard and go over to one of the bay beaches that has picnic benches! Have fun.

    1. I think Plantation is expensive and overrated. If I were going to pick one place on the north side of the island for a "white tablecloth" dinner, it would be Plate right now.

      1. Went to Mud City yesterday, which isn't actually on the island, but both the Blue and Dungeness crabs were delicious! -mJ

        2 Replies
        1. re: njfoodies

          It is a gorgeous Sunday for a top down cruise down the shore for some crabs! That said, Zelda and I hopped in the car and headed down to Long Beach Island, and Mud City Crab House for some fresh seafood. We pulled up and got a good parking spot out front, overlooking the sea grass surrounding an outdoor patio, adorned with big red market umbrellas.

          Upon walking in, we were immediately seated, and the restaurant was a little more than 3 quarters full. All kinds of crab and fish décor covered the walls, and it looked like a classic crab house. Our server came over quick and took our drink orders since we didn’t BYO today, and explained how the different crab on the menu worked. We both started with some soup, Zelda ordering the seafood bisque, while I wanted to try the New England clam chowder. Both soups were rich, delicious, and very flavorful. The bisque was nice and thick, and from the bit that I got, it had a nice clam and large piece of shrimp in it. The base was thick and buttery, and a pleasure. The clam chowder was nice and thin with good spices. The first bite I took had an over abundance of thyme flavors, but the following spoon full’s were perfect. Nice large chunks of clams and potatoes filled the bowl, and it was just darn good “chowda!”

          For entrees, Zelda went for the Dungeness platter, flown in from the upper northwest, while I opted for the Blue Crab, served garlic style. These are smaller blues, cleaned and halved, and slow cooked in the house garlic sauce. A nice cluster of Dungeness crab legs came out, still on the joints, and these were sweet and succulent, steamed to perfection. Zelda opted for slaw and fries on the side, and this came with a nice helping of extremely clear, melted butter. These were great.

          My blue came out, almost looking as though it was covered in a buttery, garlic gravy. 6 ½ small blue crabs, split in half, with nice fresh meat inside them. Next time around, I think I would order the Maryland style with the Old Bay, as the garlic sauce was almost overwhelming, and took away from the taste of the fresh crab. There was plenty of meat in these, and seeing as they were steamed alive, you can’t get them much fresher. The claws were very tasty as well, and the crab meat just had such good flavors. All though it was a lot of work to crack these open and get the meat out, it was worth every second!

          All in all, we had a great meal and great service. The tab came to $57 and change, which is pretty reasonable considering the fact that you are down the shore, and for the amount of food you got. I know that I left stuffed! What is there to say other than fresh seafood and a nice drive with the top down! Cheers! -mJ

          Mud City Crab House
          1185 E Bay Ave, Manahawkin, NJ 08050