Nantucket - causal, infant-friendly
I'm looking for a place on Nantucket to go to dinner with my in-laws, wife, and 2-month old baby. When I was a kid we always used to go to the Atlantic Cafe (now closed) or the Brotherhood of Thieves (which I've heard is rather bad these days), so something like that is kind of what I'm thinking. I've been to Millie's in Madaket, which was okay, but I'm not dying to return. In town would be much preferable to mid-island. Walking around town Cy's (the new spot that replaced the Atlantic Cafe) and Cambridge Street Vicuals looked promising atmosphere-wise. Anyone been to either of those spots, or have other recommendations?