HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >

Best of Westchester Magazine 2010

c
cubanat Jun 28, 2010 11:39 AM

Before I begin let me first say that I have not dined at Don Coqui nor have I had the salad in a box at Meme's BUT in quickly glancing at the best of list 3 things stuck out glaringly as "you must be kidding moments"--also I realize that some of the category titles were for "schtick":
1. best salad in a box:--meme's
2. best brisket: barnacle
3. best latino: don coqui

Am I reading to much into this or what? It just seemed way off but then again I guess the demographics of Westchester magazine may think this way. I guess they are to scared to venture into Port Chester or White Plains for "latino" food or brisket from Q which is 150 times better that barnacles--which is barely edible. The salad in a box thing is just insane. The baked goods were mediocre the last 2 times I tried it so why on earth would you make a category that gives a thumbs up to a bakery's salad when one could go into any good market (standing room only, cornerstone, june & ho, rye town market, whole foods et al.) and put the same ingredients in a box?

At least they got the Cookery right as best new resto and MELT as best sandwich shop!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. a
    anonymouse1935 RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 11:59 AM

    Hoo boy, I agree on Meme, that place deserves zero in the way of praise. The price is too high and the baked good, whatever I had which proves it was forgettable, was not good. It's laughable to think of going there for a salad.

    I'm not impressed with Q, I would put Big W over it, Westchester or no, any day of the week.

    But yes, MELT is an outstanding sandwich shop and deserves all the praise it can get, unless of course they expand and lose what makes them really good.

    4 Replies
    1. re: anonymouse1935
      c
      cubanat RE: anonymouse1935 Jun 28, 2010 12:39 PM

      Eaxctly! Whhooooo Boy is what I said!! I guess the category could also have been "best bakery in White Plians next to a political campaign office." The copy is laughable!

      Yes Big W is awesome but I was trying to keep it fair and in Westchester. Plates for that matter serves a wonderful bbq brisket on Sundays for their all you can eat bottomless bbq dinner.

      1. re: cubanat
        d
        debmom RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 12:46 PM

        When did Plates start this bbq? sounds interesting. Do you have any details?

        1. re: debmom
          c
          cubanat RE: debmom Jun 28, 2010 02:17 PM

          "Bottomless BBQ" Sundays
          Taken from their website:

          Join in every Sunday for Chef Karp's $28 "bottomless BBQ" Sunday with a $10 kids menu for the 10 and unders. Pulled pork, ribs, brisket, and other "smoker specials". You order it, we keep it coming! Pair it with our beers on tap: Magic Hat #9 or Hefeweizen Circus Boy and take a spot on the outdoor patio or inside as you please. Regular menu also available. Dinner service begins at 5pm.

          also here is link: http://www.platesonthepark.com/events...

          1. re: cubanat
            d
            debmom RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 03:31 PM

            sounds great, we'll have to give it a try, thanks!

    2. w
      wincountrygirl RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 02:04 PM

      I rarely agree with food/restaurant choices at Westchester magazine. They had that awful steakhouse in Croton Falls on their top list for a long time. Salad in a box sounds awful.

      2 Replies
      1. re: wincountrygirl
        p
        Proud_2_Be_A_CH_Peep RE: wincountrygirl Dec 22, 2010 06:37 PM

        Wait till you try the soup in a bag

        1. re: Proud_2_Be_A_CH_Peep
          w
          wincountrygirl RE: Proud_2_Be_A_CH_Peep Dec 23, 2010 02:38 AM

          HA! UGH - sounds like what Fabio cooked on Top Chef a couple of weeks ago!

      2. f
        fragnet RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 07:23 PM

        You should always take all "Best of"Westchester Magazine" ratings with a grain of salt. Frequently, these "ratings" are procured by the amount of advertising an establishment does with the magazine and ballot-box stuffing by the owners/fans of whatever is being rated. I'm not saying all the ratings are phony, just saying that you shouldn't be surprised by questionable "bests" showing up on the lists.

        1 Reply
        1. re: fragnet
          m
          moron66 RE: fragnet Jun 28, 2010 10:30 PM

          u r 100% fragnet u advertise all year and they will make you a catogory but don coqui is pretty good there r better latin places

        2. r
          randomdude RE: cubanat Jun 28, 2010 08:15 PM

          There are so many categories is just BS. About the only thing its good for is to hear of new places, but even then you can't trust the reviews.

          1. w
            wagamamababy RE: cubanat Jun 29, 2010 04:58 AM

            I love how Best Persian Restaurant is given to Shiraz, the only Persian restaurant in Westchester... Coincidentally, it also won the award for Worst Persian Restaurant.

            1 Reply
            1. re: wagamamababy
              a
              anonymouse1935 RE: wagamamababy Jun 29, 2010 07:36 AM

              Nooooo, really? How hysterical.

              Just proves once again that the only reliable opinion for me is mine.

            2. b
              byramgirl RE: cubanat Jun 29, 2010 06:16 AM

              I always love looking at the list and laughing at most of the choices, and saying "right on" to one or two. This year my laugh goes to Mulino's, and my "right on" category goes to The Cookery and Mima.

              I used to work in the magazine business and we did a yearly Top 100 Products issue. I'm not saying advertisers always get placed in these types of listings, but ... you decide.

              1 Reply
              1. re: byramgirl
                Marge RE: byramgirl Jun 29, 2010 07:30 AM

                My laugh went to Guadalejara as the best Mexican...and to wagamamababy's observation about the best and worst Persian!

              2. w
                wplady RE: cubanat Jul 1, 2010 03:19 PM

                Don Coqui has been excellent every time I've dined there or had appetizers at the bar

                5 Replies
                1. re: wplady
                  r
                  RawTunaFan RE: wplady Jul 2, 2010 03:35 PM

                  Sadly we were suckered into the "Salad in a Box" schtick. Tried it the other day and it wasn't worth the parking, the smile-less woman behind the counter, and the cookie that we had which was dry. I've had better salad at airports.

                  Not sure if I agree with the post on ballot stuffing, maybe people really do love mediocre salad in a box or the cupcake winner from some other year that plasters their cupcakes with lucky charm cereal...

                  I think we'll just stay away from the "winners" this year, unless people on this board recommend them. The folks at Westchester magazine should really hire their editors from Chowhound.

                  1. re: RawTunaFan
                    f
                    fragnet RE: RawTunaFan Jul 2, 2010 06:38 PM

                    You don't have to agree with the reality of ballot stuffing, but its a fact. Additionally, the people at Westchester Magazine couldn't care less about picking the "best" of anything and whether you like it or not. Its all about advertising $$ and returning the favor for doing biz with them.

                    1. re: fragnet
                      theAVE RE: fragnet Jul 2, 2010 07:13 PM

                      That could also depend on how the ballots were made available. Was it an online vote and free-for-all or was it Zagat style mail-in ballots for subscribers/ purchasers only?

                      Correct me if I'm mistaken, but New York (the "Manhattan version of Westchester Magazine," if you will) magazine's editor's and people's choice picks seem to have credibility to it, why can't they do the same at Westchester magazine?

                      I guess I won't bother looking for this magazine when (and if) it comes in the mail...

                      1. re: fragnet
                        JMF RE: fragnet Dec 26, 2010 08:12 AM

                        Westchester magazine was always known for it's advertising driven restaurant recommendations. I think a year ago they got a new editor for the food section. They contacted me to write for them but I refused. I didn't want to be the one trying to fight against all the advertising dollars.

                        1. re: JMF
                          a
                          Agapimou RE: JMF Dec 26, 2010 11:24 AM

                          Westchester Magazine is the absolute worst publication ever! It's one of those things that from the surface it looks good but once you experience and reference one of their reviews or features you realize that it is all hype and advertising dollar driven! It truly is not worth the paper it's printed on. For real varied opinions on food establishments and topics nothing beats Chowhound.

                  Show Hidden Posts