HOME > Chowhound > Philadelphia >
What are you cooking today?

fish restaurant

rabidog Jun 26, 2010 09:32 PM

finally with a day off from my new job and a little bit of cash to blow, tried out fish restaurant with a couple friends last night. ah, just like little fish, except on the west side of town and with alcohol! i LOVED this place. i'll start off with the only downside of the evening - we weren't big on the wine. my dining companions, having recently returned from a vacation to new zealand, have been smitten with marlborough region sauvignon blancs, which has always been one of my favorites too. fish offers one selection from this region, but even the state store selection is tastier. it didn't have much of the zing which makes me crave this wine in the summer. i can't remember the name of it, but since the cuisine matches a crisp white so perfectly we were ever-so slightly disappointed we didn't enjoy it enough to get a whole bottle. that's the end of my complaints. we switched over to a sweet cucumber martini, which instantly gets my vote for best martini of the summer (yea, i know it's still early on, but it's a pretty safe bet it'll remain at the top of my list). it comes with vodka, but we got one with henricks gin which was perfect as well. beautiful drink - and just one of them left us pretty woozy and happily disoriented. :) after that round we headed outside to a table and got a dozen oysters, four different types, so we could try one of each. i don't know much about oysters and i don't remember their names, but they were fantastic. went on to appetizers - the peekytoe crab with avocado (easily my favorite dish in the city right now!!!), the crouton/pepper/burrata salad (it has a fancier name than that, i can't remember what it was. very tasty) and the lobster, which was our least favorite of the three but still good (i personally thought it might be better-matched with a more simple butter sauce. the lobster itself was cooked perfectly). entrees were the skate wing with corn and a parmesan sauce poured at the table (my favorite) and two fish dishes, covina (i think that might have been its name? that's a guess) and wahoo. can't remember what sauces those came with, but all was excellent. i tend to favor salty things, and the peekytoe and the skate wing both featured not-shy amounts of salt. bottle of champagne to end the night. perfect dinner, great bartender and server. not an inexpensive joint, but definitely worth it. we left stuffed and happy. i can't wait to go back.

  1. in bocca Mar 9, 2011 05:34 AM

    Heading to Fish for dinner. Any must have dishes? It looks like the skate gets excellent reviews. Also, I saw that they have special wine dinners and events but their website doesn't list any thing upcoming. Anyone know of an inside scoop on that info?

    3 Replies
    1. re: in bocca
      rabidog Mar 9, 2011 06:17 PM

      i was under the impression the menu changed periodically, but i've never had a bad thing there. enjoy and report back! oh, shucks, don't skip the oysters either :)

      1. re: rabidog
        FrancisdeR Jan 26, 2012 07:27 PM

        Has anyone been recently? It seems to have moved to the Independent Hotel. I don't know how recent that is, but Zagat's still has it near 17th St.

        1. re: FrancisdeR
          Buckethead Jan 27, 2012 05:48 AM

          Their new location is the building on the southeast corner of 12th and Locust, it's hard to tell from the outside since the only signage is a light gray logo on the door about a foot off the ground. I went there just after they moved so maybe they've put up a bigger sign since then but I walked right past the place before turning around and realizing it was in there. The food is as good as ever, but the space is much nicer (mainly, less cramped) than their old one.

    2. x
      xtian Jun 28, 2010 08:41 AM

      I went to Fish for their classic seafood wine pairing dinner last week-- an amazing deal for $75, especially considering that included a wine pairing for each of the 7 courses. Some of the highlights for me were a lemony mackerel escabeche paired with a cava (I didn't even think I liked mackerel, but this was very flavorful), their take on oysters rockefeller with a rose champagne, crab imperial, and lobster newburg paired with red that I can't recall. Each dish was prepared in classic style, but with a little twist to update it or make it unique. Baked Alaska for dessert was a nice finishing touch.
      Only complaint was that we arrived early and sat at the bar and the service was really scattered. Maybe it was because of the special event that evening, but it was actually really stressful me, just watching the bartender trying to get it together.
      I hope they offer more of these dinners though!

      1. p
        Philly Ray Jun 27, 2010 08:36 PM

        What are the prices like there? I was looking at the sample menu on their website and they don't list any pricing.

        1 Reply
        1. re: Philly Ray
          rabidog Jun 28, 2010 04:53 PM

          ah jeez. we went all-out, since it was a special occasion (that being, none of us had been anywhere nice in months). our food bill was just over $300 after tip for 3 of us, but that's not including two rounds at the bar prior. i think the champagne pushed it over into really expensive territory. after the amount we drank, i'm finding myself not remembering individual prices!

        2. c
          croissantanyone Jun 27, 2010 03:19 PM

          Supremely tempted by fish. But one of my party is a vegetarian... Did it seem like they offered any veg dishes or would be accommodating to vegetarians?

          1. JanR Jun 27, 2010 02:06 PM

            Yes Fish is great. I also like the skate wing with parmesan sauce and the oysters are always fantastic. Miss Littlefish though.

            1. rabidog Jun 27, 2010 10:34 AM

              yes, corvina rings a bell!

              happy hour buck-a-shuck sounds awesome. do they still come with the same tasty garnishes? trying to remember precisely what they came with - i think two came with a cucumber garnish and two came with shallots? is HH at a normal 5-7 time, or is that the late-night happy hour i saw advertised on the chalkboard there? i think it was 9-11? was just raving to a friend about it over brunch today and now she wants to go, so i think another fish dinner is in my immediate future. yes!!

              1 Reply
              1. re: rabidog
                barryg Jun 27, 2010 11:14 AM

                It's 5-7 but I think the late night one is the same deal. They definitely serve them with the mignonette (a cucumber-shallot, I think, for W coast oysters, something else for E coast), but don't think there is any garnish beyond that, though I might be forgetting.

                One thing their HH does not have that I miss is oyster crackers.

              2. b
                barryg Jun 27, 2010 07:59 AM

                Thanks for the writeup. I really like this place. The buck-a-shuck for Happy Hour is a great deal because they have 3 or 4 different kinds of high quality oysters, all of which are better and more interesting than the typical Long Islands you get at other places.

                1. goodhealthgourmet Jun 26, 2010 09:51 PM

                  "covina (i think that might have been its name? that's a guess) "
                  it was probably cobia.

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: goodhealthgourmet
                    Philly Ray Jun 27, 2010 06:50 AM

                    Could have been corvina. I have been hearing that fish mentioned lately during specials recitations.

                    1. re: Philly Ray
                      goodhealthgourmet Jun 27, 2010 09:49 AM

                      i guess i just assumed cobia was more likely since it's easily accessible in Philly...corvina would certainly be more interesting.

                  Show Hidden Posts