HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

I renjoyed the bread plate.

  • 2

I ~REALLY~ wanted to like the Oyster Bar in Grand Central.

They were out of fried oysters (at approx 7 pm on Thursday). I then ordered the oysters rockefeller for an app. I saw other diners order hot apps after me and receive them before me.

When I received the oysters rock - it was cold. I ate one before catching the eye of the waitress. She asked if it was cold before I had the opportunity to tell her.

The waitress took them back, and brought me a plate after a few minutes

The remaining oysters appeared to have been slid off the plate, heated, and put back on in a jumble - no lemon garnish this time around! It was quite sloppy - and the cheese now had an odd texture, but it tasted okay.

I ordered the lobster roll as an entree. The lobster roll was very tasty. The cole slaw was soggy, and the sweet potato fries were cold and a bit greasy.

Overall, I enjoyed the bread plate.

I just went to oysterbarny.com to send a message to the management, but couldn't find a contact link on that site.

PS - I ate at the Blue Ribbon Brasserie the night before. The oysters at the Blue Ribbon were prepped with great care. The oysters at the Oyster Bar NYC - not so much.

-----
Blue Ribbon Brasserie
97 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. The only good things to order at the GCOB are oysters and clams. The rest of the food....not worth ordering.

    1. Agree with guts. As a raw bar, it's pretty damn awesome - the selection of oysters is simply outstanding. But then, I don't need much with my oyster other than a squirt of lemon...