Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
Jun 8, 2010 12:05 PM

Long Island Wineries - where to go?

Taking a trip up to the North Fork this weekend and we were wondering what wineries you recommend for good wine tastings. We primarily like reds and we heard that Merlot and Cabernet Franc seem to be standouts in the region. We are already planning to visit Wolffer in the South Fork. What do you think are the must-visit wineries in the area? Looking for excellent wines, a great atmosphere, and overall relaxing tasting experience. We might also do a picnic lunch so one place that allows it might be worth checking out. Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Duckwalk Vineyard is not to be of the most beautiful tasting rooms on the east coast....

    1. Macari Vineyards in Mattituck.

      1. Diliberto's in Jamesport is great for picnics, very European, and if you like Italian wines, you will enjoy. Also, out by Greenport, we love Old Field, it's also a farm and has a expansive lawn with casual seating, very different with farmyard animals wandering around. Again great reds, we like the blends.

        1. we like pindar and they are the largest in eastern long island. they own duckwalk too. at this point i don't know the general feeling about them but we do enjoy their ice wines.

          3 Replies
          1. re: davmar77

            Love their wines but hate the atmosphere at the visitor's center. It's a circus.

            1. re: davmar77

              Personally, I've always hated Pindar. Too commercial and too obviously pandering to the non-wine drinking crowd, hence the circus atmosphere. We've always like Pelligrini wines and Bedell as well as Lenz (were they bought and have a new name), Martha Clara is not bad -- and close to the goat cheese place. There are a ton of wineries out there, but we've always like the ones that focus more of their energies on making their money from wines and not from wine tasting groups.

              1. re: roxlet

                The best thing at Martha Clara is the horsedrawn ride through the vineyards and around the farm. Last time I went, it was only $4, best bargain in town! Their wines aren't too shabby either.

            2. I think we've decided to go to Bedell, Lenz, and Paumanok for sure.

              If we were to do another one, which of the following would you recommend - Pellegrini, Shinn, Raphael, Palmer, or Peconic Bay? Also, any thoughts on Grapes of Roth?

              3 Replies
              1. re: krystle920

                Pindar is huge and like a circus...Duck Walk is just plain bad. Pellegrini, Macari, Osprey's Dominion, Lenz are all great, as is Martha Clara. Shinn is very good also...winemaker's a great guy, but the owner has attitude. Peconic Bay is also too much like a circus..I liked it a lot in the old days, when Ray owned it. Pugliese is always overlooked....its a small, pleasant place with a pond and has some of the most reasonable wine prices in the area.

                1. re: krystle920

                  Bedell, Lenz, and Paumanok are good stops.
                  Grapes of Roth is not a winery, just a label. You can buy their wine at Roanoke Vineyards.
                  My favorite wineries to vist are as follows:
                  Waters Crest
                  Jamesport Vineyards
                  Sherwood House

                  My list of places to skip: Pindar, Duckwalk. They are more tourist trap (bus stop, limo stop) than fine wine focused.

                  PS: if you are on the South Fork, make sure to hit Channing Daughters in addition to Wolffer.

                  1. re: foleyd7

                    And before you hit any wineries, hit the Cheese Shop on Love Lane (in mattituck, I think). Pack up some cheese or panini's for a picnic lunch. Bedell has a big outdoor deck with tables where you can break out the cheese and buy a glass of wine.
                    If they are open and don't have an event going on, the back patio at Raphael is great for a little cheese picnic.