HOME > Chowhound > Florida >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Share your food adventure
TELL US

Ohio Style Pizza

Sandwich_Sister Jun 5, 2010 02:47 PM

Is there any good Ohio style pizza places in Florida? The only one I knew of was the famous chain, Dontatos, which has now closed up shop in Florida. It's a shame because it was one of the only few chains I actually liked. Any other places in the Florida?

  1. watch me eat Jun 11, 2010 09:24 PM

    Wasn't Donatos owned by McDonalds during the time they had stores open in Florida? Maybe that explains why I found their pizza to be so bad. Yet whenever company comes to visit from the midwest, they always rave about how awesome Donato's pizza is. Perhaps I missed out on trying an accurate Ohio style pizza...

    1. h
      HotMelly Jun 9, 2010 02:45 PM

      My goodness Sam.You did some research...... Just visit Cassanos.com or marions pizza...... It is the best

      1. y
        YosemiteSam Jun 9, 2010 02:08 PM

        So I'm intrigued by this topic - turns out there are 21 regional styles of pizza.

        Here's what's referred to as Ohio Valley Pizza (from this site: http://slice.seriouseats.com/archives...

        )

        Ohio Valley style: If Trenton can have a style based on a couple places why can't the Ohio Valley? Here, the blog Mine Road describes it: "The first thing that you'll notice that is odd about our favorite pizza is that it's square. Square as in it's made in a square pan and then cut into square pieces. Then you'll notice that the cheese isn't melted all the way. The uncooked toppings are put on after the sauce, base cheese (minimal), and dough are cooked. You always have to make sure to have a slice ASAP before everything melts on the drive/walk back to your place. You'll also notice that our pizza sauce isn't really much of a sauce at all as much as it is just stewed tomatoes. Also the crust is a mix between a deep dish and thin crust. It is very much focaccia bread, if you've ever had that. Oh, and the best part is that you buy it by the slice."

        Or maybe this is the style you mean?

        Midwest style: Variations, I believe, are found throughout the Midwest--from Ohio to Milwaukee to Chicago to wherever. I'd even go so far as to say that the "Chicago-style" pizza just above is really a variation of "Midwest-style." The Midwest style is round (but not always; see Maria's), thin, very crisp yet tender-flaky, and is party- or tavern-cut into the grid. Sauces and topping preference may differ from city to city and region to region, but this style seems to crop up often in the heartland.

        The full list of 21 regional styles:

        Neapolitan-style pizza
        New York–Neapolitan (aka "Neapolitan-American")
        New York–style
        Sicilian-style pizza
        grandma-style pizza
        New Haven–style apizza
        grilled pizza
        bar-style pizza
        Trenton tomato pies
        Old Forge–style pizza
        Detroit-style pizza
        deep dish
        stuffed pizza
        Chicago thin-crust pizza
        Midwest-style pizza
        St. Louis–style pizza
        California-style pizza
        Ohio Valley–style pizza
        New England Greek–style pizza
        D.C. jumbo slices
        Pizza parlor–style pizza

        6 Replies
        1. re: YosemiteSam
          Sandwich_Sister Jun 9, 2010 03:01 PM

          Wow thanks, Ohio Valley and Midwestern are similar. but yes that is what I am referring too.

          I didn't kow about ohio pizza until I met my husband who is from Columbus Ohio.
          but yes, the squares and the sauce is lighter and the toppings are to the edge.

          1. re: YosemiteSam
            r
            RibDog Jun 9, 2010 07:30 PM

            Learn something new every day! Thanks.

            1. re: RibDog
              m
              Maryld Jun 17, 2010 12:57 PM

              Isn't that truth?? I'm originally from NE Ohio and have never heard of Ohio style pizza.

            2. re: YosemiteSam
              g
              gfr1111 Jun 10, 2010 05:52 AM

              Thanks a lot, Yosemite Sam. That article was very helpful. Topic # 476607 is also about the style of pizza which we have been discussing. It is titled "St. Louis style pizza in Tampa?" The first entry was by Panicattack on January 6, 2008.

              In examining the pictures of these different styles of pizza, it appears to me that Chicago thin-crust pizza, Midwest-style pizza, and St. Louis-style pizza look the same. I do think that the thing which makes these pizzas different than most others is probably the use of the provel cheese blend of swiss, provolone, and cheddar. Additionally, there is the ultra-thin cracker crust, ingredients on the bottom, a highly spiced but thin tomato sauce, and cheese on top, as well as the signature square cut pieces.

              Rib Dog, the reason for the square cut, I suspect, is because a larger, traditional, triangular cut would cause the delicate cracker crust to collapse under the weight of the toppings.

              My favorite pizza of all time (well, okay, a tie with Wolfgang Puck's pizza at the bar in Postrio in San Francisco--a totally different style) is the pizza at "House of Pizza" in Hammond, Indiana. This is the Chicago/midwest/St. Louis style described in the article above. i grew up on it.

              Sandwich Sister, the other thread suggests the following as possibly being the type of pizza which you are looking for in the greater Tampa area: Guido's Pizza Cafe in Spring Hill on U.S. 19 forty miles north of Tampa, Paul's Pizza in Safety Harbor, Ledo Pizza on North Dale Mabry, and Charlie and Millie's Pizza, 10953 Seminole Blvd., Largo, FL (phone: 727-391-5661). I can vouch for none of these, having never sampled them. Furthermore, this is information from 2008, so who knows whether they have survived the recession? Pane Rustica's pizza in Tampa was also mentioned and I have had it. While quite good, it is not even close to what we are discussing here.

              I hope this helps.

              -----
              Guido's Pizza Cafe
              7219 Forest Oaks Blvd, Spring Hill, FL 34606

              1. re: gfr1111
                t
                traderphill Jul 5, 2010 07:13 PM

                Paul's Pizza in Saftety Harbor is probably the closest thing to Ohio (Dayton) Style pizza that I've had here in the Tampa area. Theirs is a Chicago thin crust, but it's thin like Donatos, but a little softer. Tell em you want the crust crispy, and that will make it more like the cracker crust that you're used to..

              2. re: YosemiteSam
                askdrtodd Jun 10, 2010 07:28 AM

                Geez, the republic of Todd only recognizes (4) individual styles of pizza:

                Chicago - Thick and awesome
                New York - Thin and awesome
                Pane Rustica - Awesome and awesome
                Other - depends if I've had (or am in the process of having) some beers

              3. h
                HotMelly Jun 9, 2010 02:18 AM

                I grew up in the Dayton area of Ohio. Now in Florida. Donatos which SS was speaking of was part of a family that included Donatos, Donisi, and Cassanos. Cassano's Pizza's are well know in the Dayton area. There is also Marion's Pizza. These (Ohio pizza's) are very thin and cripsy crusts ,and cut into small 1 1/2 " squares. That is Ohio pizza's, and they are great.

                3 Replies
                1. re: HotMelly
                  m
                  Miss E Jun 9, 2010 08:03 AM

                  That sounds similar to the pizza we enjoyed in Minnesota: thin crust, cut into little squares all the way around. Why does cutting it into wee squares make it taste better? Don't know, but it does.

                  1. re: Miss E
                    y
                    YosemiteSam Jun 9, 2010 08:38 AM

                    This has always vexed me - if it's in squares how do you fold it over to a point so that the grease drips into your mouth as you take a bite? I have the same issue with deep dish pizzas. I'll stick with NY or Neopolitan style. Your midwestern pizzas sound more like flatbread to me :)

                    1. re: YosemiteSam
                      a
                      andy huse Jun 9, 2010 01:51 PM

                      i'm all about the little squares. you always have room for more that way. all of my family's favorite pizza places in chicago cut them that way--- and we always got thin crust.

                2. r
                  RibDog Jun 8, 2010 07:27 PM

                  I did not know Ohio had a style of pizza.

                  1. m
                    Miss E Jun 8, 2010 04:20 PM

                    Yes, please do, I've never heard of it!

                    1. g
                      gfr1111 Jun 8, 2010 03:18 PM

                      Respectfully, what is Ohio style pizza? Please describe it.

                      Thanks.

                      Show Hidden Posts