Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Philadelphia >
Jun 3, 2010 08:05 AM

Hand Sliced Smoked Salmon

Are there any places in Philly that still hand slice smoked salmon? Other smoked fish would be a plus as well...

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. They do that on Saturday mornings at the Cheese Trap in the Flourtown Farmers' Market. Sells out quickly.

    1. some but not all of the salmon is hand sliced at Coastal Cave in the RTM. They also have cold smoked Tuna and smoked trout and smoked bluefish but they aren't generally sold sliced. I think Hershel's has sable (again, not sliced)

      1. Not sure if you are looking for smoked salmon that is actually smoked or something like Lox. DiBruno's in the 1700 Chestnut will hand slice their Nova, etc.

        10 Replies
        1. re: FayeD

          Traditional smoked salmon is "actually smoked". (!!) It's a cold-smoked method, so it's not flaky. Seems like this is a very difficult find in Philly (surprised.)

          It is ubiquitous in NY, literally several dozen places to buy smoked salmon sliced to order.

          1. re: menton1

            I think the nova at DiBruno's is what you are looking for. AFAIK Nova is cold-smoked salmon, so I'm not sure what FayeD means.

            If not, you should ask about it at Famous 4th St but I think Smoked Salmon is one of the few things they don't do in house and I think it comes pre-sliced to them, but you never know what they have in the back. They do have filets of smoked salmon but it's the flaky kind.

            1. re: barryg

              While Famous 4th Street doesn't smoke their own, both lox and Nova are hand sliced to order.

              1. re: Cruz

                Web site looks like a restaurant. (Nova sandwich $14.???) (they cost $8 at Zabars/NYC, best in the US)

                Do they have a deli counter for take away smoked fish?

                1. re: menton1

                  Yes, it's a full service deli, at least at the 4th St location. Prices are high but the sandwiches are huge, Carnegie-deli style. The deli prices are high, too, but I doubt it is more per pound than Zabar's. For this type of food, it is best around. Try the corned beef and pastrami if you are into that stuff. Their other smoked fish is great, too.

                  1. re: barryg

                    The 20th Street location has a deli counter too. The fish is high quality (NYC's Acme brand, I think). Equally important, the smoked salmon is expertly cut very thin. The price for Nova and lox is about $50/lb., which seems to be the market price.

                    1. re: Cruz

                      I'm pretty sure $50 is WAY above market price. I would guess its down around $30/lb.

                      1. re: Cruz

                        Ouch, $50/lb? Yeah, that's high even by New York City standards. I just moved back from the Upper East Side, and our go-to (but expensive!) place was called Sables, and it was always about $20-30/lb. Awesome whitefish salad if you are ever there... I'd love to find something like that back here in Philly.

                        1. re: MightyYar

                          Don't know where you live, but if aren't far from the northeast, try Stein's on Krewstown.
                          My husband did his "lox run" this morning. He bought a half-pound for $12.99. Might have been a special, but it's never much more.
                          Good whitefish salad, too.

              2. re: menton1

                Lots of places I was getting cold smoked salmon are no more - Chef's Market on south st always had nova, Irish and scottish (at least) all hand sliced, Assouline in it's various incarnations had it as well. It has become harder and harder to find hand sliced - Coastal cave and DiBruno's hand slice some but not all the salmon they carry

            2. Wegman's if you want some in the suburbs. They have several different kinds at both the Cherry Hill and the Mt. Laurel stores.

              1. About once a month, my husband makes a "lox run" to Stein's deli on Krewstown Road in the northeast. Of course it's hand-sliced, and it is wonderful. Price is much less than downtown.
                He feels that it's worth the trip.
                Once in a while, we also indulge in their corned-beef; also excellent.

                1 Reply
                1. re: sylviag

                  we too, make lox runs to steve stein's Famous Deli--his price is abt $32 a lb. and the slicers are old-school who know what they're doing. He also sells all the other fishes (sable, the salmon that is cold, like poached) He sells bagels, babka and a full deli counter too-- i wouldn't call the whitefish salads "superior quality" ( a bit mushy, heavier on the filler) but they are very serviceable and what you'd expect for a good price. the lox, cream cheese etc.. never disappoints