HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >


Tommy's Coal Fired Pizza in Red Bank- Anyone been?

Just heard of this new place. Do any of you CH'ers out there have any thoughts on this place? Please tell.!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: MichelleM131

      Actually went there last night. Excellent pizzas, very spotty service, and for pizza, pretty pricey. This said, we'll go back as the pizza and the meatballs were excellent.

      1. re: sockster

        Did you go to the one in Red Bank or Oakhurst? Red Bank, I'm assuming?

    2. Try the wings. Slightly untraditional, on a hot pan of onions and peppers (and a charred long hot pepper) and noticeable garlic. Ask for a side of buffalo sauce and go nuts. My favorite in the area

      Pizza nothing to write home about.

      1. I found it overrated and overpriced

        1 Reply
        1. re: Tay

          We did not like it at all. The pizza was so bland!!!

        2. Tommy's makes excellent pies (love their clam pie well done)!! They also make great wings and meatballs. And did I mention the sangria is outstanding as well?

          1. Hmmmm let's try this one and see if it works.

            Tommy's is owned by an Attorney in Staten Island who's true intention was to open up a few locations as quickly as possible and start a francise. A combination of the economy and mediocore food I believe has sidelined those plans. I don't think their "heart" or dedication is to being a true or gormet pizza place but rather just an investment.

            1 Reply
            1. re: jrvedivici

              My husband and I love wings. We didn't really love Tommy's, or their pizza either. Anyhow, 20 wings? We get wings a lot but I don't think we've ever counted them. I'm just sayin...