HOME > Chowhound > Pennsylvania >
Do you create unique foods?

Head to the Pennsylvania Dutch Country.. where to eat

burgeoningfoodie May 1, 2010 12:19 PM

Hello Chowhounds!

My girlfriend and I are heading to the Pennsylvania Dutch country (not sure of home base) and I'm looking for recs both with the typical Dutch food (Shoofly Pie and such) and in general. Girlfriend does not do spicy very well. I've been to the area twice and both times were pretty far apart for me to remember anything outside of going to a Pretzel factory, an old train tour and Zinn's which is no longer there (I only remember this due to a photo with Amos). I know at one point we will be going to Hershey , maybe the Green Dragon, and I know we will do a Pretzel making tour (if anyone wnats to recommend what-to-dos as well that would help) unless you want to warn me of tourist traps. I realize this is a food only board, but we are above all a community that trusts one another to make recommendations. if you fear that your post will be wiped due to non food suggestions that is fine and I understand.

I also saw that food fest will be during our time of stay 26-31. Is that good?

Pennsylvania Dutch
Boothwyn PA, Boothwyn, PA

  1. k
    katiedid31 May 22, 2010 05:11 AM

    Hi there!
    It sounds like you have lots of great ideas, but I am surprised no one mentioned John J. Jeffries at the Lancaster Arts Hotel. I ate there about a month ago and it's one of the best meals I've had in a long time. They use mostly local ingredients from area farms, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was relaxing but classy. I'd highly recommend it for a nice dinner out. Enjoy your trip!


    5 Replies
    1. re: katiedid31
      centralpadiner May 22, 2010 06:53 AM

      In the original post, I was given the impression he wanted traditional PA Dutch cuisine. But for upscale dining in downtown Lancaster, I completely agree. John J. Jeffries is easily my favorite place in Lancaster right now, and I have said so on this board many, many times.

      1. re: katiedid31
        burgeoningfoodie May 24, 2010 08:41 AM

        I think we have listed that as one place to dine. Well I think we want a sample of the region and one of those things will be traditional Dutch Country food. I only definitely remember Shoo Fly Pie. I mean I'm coming from the South and so some things may not seem different (like hams or corn soup). We may pick up some dutch treats just grazing at the markets.

        1. re: katiedid31
          burgeoningfoodie May 27, 2010 01:16 PM

          I think we plan to hit John J.'s. So far we've done Iron Hill and Glassmeyers. Tonight we are looking at Italian probably somewhere in the Lancaster area. Ciro's, Fiorentino's or I see something about Lombardo's are the ones I've come across since being up here.

          1. re: burgeoningfoodie
            centralpadiner May 28, 2010 12:59 PM

            Other Italian options could be Rosa Rosa - very popular, but to be honest not my favorite, it is very close to John J.'s. Mazzi is very upscale and in Leola if you don't want to go into Lancaster City (I don't recall where you are staying). If location is not important, I would probably choose Fiorentino's - Columbia Ave. location over Airport location.


            Rosa Rosa Cafe & Bar
            1040 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603

            1. re: centralpadiner
              burgeoningfoodie Jun 1, 2010 12:57 PM

              So here is where we ate/grazed if I can remember the order...
              Lapp Valley Farm (fun and tasty)
              Samples at Kitchen Kettle Village
              Iron Hill (Good but a bit loud)

              Samples at Sturgis Pretzel Factory
              Samples at Wilbur (though I wouldn't waste time with the "tour")
              Glassmeyer (nice and slow paced and cheap)
              Cupcakes in Lititz (Rachel's)
              Fiorentino's (left much to be desired)
              Carmen & David's (yummy!)

              Whoopie Pies, Pretzels, and Dried Fruit at Green Dragon
              John J. Jefferies (hip and delicious)

              Flavorfest snacks (Mostly different types of sauces to sample.. I hope this becomes something better... It was more or less wine)
              Snacks at townsquare in Strasburg and singerle cookies
              Rachel's Cafe and Creperie for dinner
              Shoo Fly Pie and Apple Dumpling from Green Dragon for dessert.

              Snacks and light lunch in Hershey
              Choc. Ave Grill was closed and What If looked too expensive... forgot about Devon Seafood...
              Ate at Friendly's in Lancaster as it was open late and closer than Olive Garden.

              Thank you for your help and suggestions.

              Olive Garden
              83 E City Ave, Bala Cynwyd, PA 19004

              Kitchen Kettle Village
              RR 340, Intercourse, PA 17534

              What If Cafe
              845 E Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033

        2. MGZ May 8, 2010 05:55 AM

          Not so much a where to eat response, but the highlights of our "Food Geeks' Tour of Lancaster County" were the Waltz Vineyards in Manhein - particularly the blended red and the rose:


          September Farms Dairy in Honey Brook - the Aged Cheddar was outstanding:


          Lancaster Brewing Company - love that Milk Stout:


          And, although I'm not quite sure if it's technically in Lancaster, is my favorite food-related spot in Central Pennsylvania - Stoudt's Brewery and the adjacent Black Angus restaurant, in Adamstown. They have a focus on local ingredients, fantastic beef, and is quite frankly one of the greatest places to try assorted food and beer pairings I've ever found.


          Lancaster Brewing Company
          302 N Plum St, Lancaster, PA 17602

          12 Replies
          1. re: MGZ
            burgeoningfoodie May 10, 2010 07:40 AM

            Neither I nor my girlfriend really do any drinking but may check out LBC for the food.

            As for dining, here is a rundown from other resources we've looked through as to places to eat.. If you have experiences or have heard local things about any please share..

            Smorgasbord/Family Style
            Good and Plenty (which sounds like the Mike and Ike candies)
            Plain and Fancy
            Shady Maple
            Stoltzfus Farm
            Hershey Farm

            Non Smorgasbord (i.e. everything else)
            Character's Pub
            Belvedere Inn
            Annie Bailey's
            Iron Hill
            Dan's (which I believe is in Reading)
            Family Cupboard
            Haydn Zug
            Lily's On Main
            The Restaurant at Doneckers
            The Kling House (at Ketlle Village)
            Blue Pacific Sushi
            The Brasserie
            Doc Holliday's
            Horse Inn
            Lan Viet
            Lemon Grass
            Olde Greenfield Inn
            Olive and Jasmine
            Stockyard Inn
            Tobias Frogg
            1764 Restaurant
            The Catacombs
            The Watering Trough
            Revere Tavern

            Watering Trough
            905 W Main St, Mount Joy, PA 17552

            Belvedere Inn
            402 N Queen St, Lancaster, PA 17603

            Lemon Grass Cafe
            124 6th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222

            Stockyard Inn
            1147 Lititz Pike Ste 1, Lancaster, PA 17601

            Lily's On Main
            124 E Main St, Ephrata, PA 17522

            Stoltzfus Farm Restaurant
            RR 772, Intercourse, PA 17534

            Character's Pub
            38 N Christian St Ste 100, Lancaster, PA 17602

            The Family Cupboard Restaurant
            3029 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird In Hand, PA 17505

            Kling House Restaurant
            3575 W Newport Rd, Ronks, PA 17572

            Horse Inn
            214 N Marshall St, Lancaster, PA 17602

            , Ephrata, PA 17522

            Haydn Zug's
            1987 State St, East Petersburg, PA 17520

            1. re: burgeoningfoodie
              centralpadiner May 10, 2010 08:13 AM

              Donecker's is closed, as is Doc Holidays'. The only other thing I can say is that your "everything else" list is really spread out geographically, and depending on where you are going to be, many of them are not worth a drive. It is also all over the place as far as style and price, so we could easily help you narrow it down if you let us know a little more of what you are looking for and where your non-food related travels will be taking you, budget, etc. It also seems to be a bit of an outdated list, so I'm not sure where you got it. Rice and Noodles is the hands-down best Vietnamese in Lancaster, if that is something you are specifically interested in.

              , Ephrata, PA 17522

              1. re: centralpadiner
                burgeoningfoodie May 10, 2010 09:01 AM

                Well we will be staying in Lancaster. We are going to travel to Lititz, Ephrata, Hershey, and Intercourse at points during our stay. Our budget.. eh not too expensive. We may snack during lunchtimes and save most of our dining money for dinner. We would probably do between 15 and 30/person for an entree. The list was compiled via the most recent Frommers and AAA books. I knew it was going to be all over the place. I slacked off in the organizing department.

                I always try to sample the local wares first and then if there are just good representations of other foods, we'll go that route. Does Rice and Noodles make Bahn Mi?

                1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                  centralpadiner May 10, 2010 10:43 AM

                  Yes, Rice and Noodles has bahn mi.... yummm... http://www.riceandnoodlesrestaurant.com/
                  It is located just north of Lancaster City.

                  In Ephrata, Lily's is probably your best bet now that Donecker's is gone. There is also an Isaac's located in a shopping center on Rt. 272 near the hospital. That is a deli, so good for casual eats.
                  In fact, Isaac's is a regional chain located in or near many of the places you are visiting, so it could be an option on multiple occasions.

                  In Lititz, I already mentioned Cafe Chocolate as an option downtown. I think I'd avoid the General Sutter. It pains me to say that because when we lived in town it was a great place to eat, but I have heard nothing but bad since we left. You can get PA Dutch eats north of town at The LItitz Family Cupboard. I have no idea if it is connected to the other Family Cupboard, but I always enjoyed it when in the mood for that sort of thing.
                  There is also an Italian place up there - Cappricio's (there is a sit-down side, and a pizza take-out side, go to the sit down side). One problem may be that they recently opened up another restaurant and may be stretched a bit. My mother told me that something seemed a bit off the last time she was there. South of town is a pan-asian rest. I enjoy, called Mojo Asian cuisine. I enjoy their sushi rolls, but they also have Thai and the standard Chinese restaurant stuff. They are owned by the same people that own Cafe East in Centreville, so the menu is similar, but with the different sushi chefs, the special rolls are not the same.
                  There is also a Fiorentino's location south of Lititz - actually located inside the Lancaster Airport. We enjoy Fiorentino's very much for your standard Italian fare. Both locale's are good.

                  I think I already posted a list for Hershey. The Chocolate Ave. Grill is a popular place right downtown that I haven't been to. I still think a stop in Mount Joy if you want PA Dutch - you won't find any in Hershey.

                  In downtown Lancaster, the options are so many and so varied, it really depends on your mood. I can't think of any place to get good PA Dutch food. I tend to go for ethnic, "special night out" or "bar scene with friends" while downtown.

                  As for your list, aside from the one's I already mentioned as closed, I would avoid:
                  Blue Pacific Sushi (you can get better and while I am usually forgiving of bad health inspections . . . not with sushi places
                  )Tobias Frog
                  1764 (this is the official name of the rest. at General Sutter Inn in Lititz)
                  The Catacombs (another place my husband and I used to frequent that has nose-dived in recent years)
                  The Watering Trough (you couldn't actually pay me to eat the food here)

                  Nothing wrong with Haydn Zug's (probably a little pricey and fancy for what you want) or Symposium, but I don't see you getting to those areas and they aren't so spectacular that you need to leave Lancaster for them.

                  Watering Trough
                  905 W Main St, Mount Joy, PA 17552

                  Cafe East
                  594 Centerville Rd, Lancaster, PA 17601

                  Family Cupboard Restaurant
                  PO Box 556, Intercourse, PA 17534

                  , Ephrata, PA 17522

                  Haydn Zug's
                  1987 State St, East Petersburg, PA 17520

                  1. re: centralpadiner
                    burgeoningfoodie May 10, 2010 11:47 AM

                    Thanks I use the boards to cross reference what the tourbooks say as they are geared to tourists (which we are), but necessarily towards tourist who want to eat well or eat where the locals would know better. I believe we'll get some PA Dutch food in their either by way of markets, the place in Mount Joy or smorgasbord/family style dining. Just depends.

                    Thanks again. If anyone else has suggestions, in general, doesn't have to be Lancaster but in the Amish country region feel free.

                    1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                      Vladimir Estragon May 11, 2010 01:07 AM

                      Forget the buffets unless you're really big eaters or you have finicky children. The food is rarely better than okay and they are not a bargain anymore. So-called PA Dutch places like Good & Plenty are tourist joints. Some of them make you sit at big common tables, so you can socialize with whatever strangers just got off the bus. Not for me. If you want local flavor, you should definitely hit the Lancaster Central Market, though it's only open two or three days a week and you have to go early. Cucina Mexicana, Spyro Gyro, and Rice & Noodles are all decent, inexpensive ethnic places in or near downtown.

                      Rice & Noodles Restaurant
                      1238 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601

                      1. re: Vladimir Estragon
                        burgeoningfoodie May 11, 2010 06:01 AM

                        Will keep the buffet remarks in mind. Luckily our place does a continental breakfast.. so we don't have to worry about that unless we choose to. And will look into other places to sample regional faire.

                      2. re: burgeoningfoodie
                        Chowrin Jan 27, 2011 06:37 PM

                        general suggestions: in the home of junk food: visit supermarkets! lebanon bologna, martin's potato bread, grandma utz potato chips (costco only, they're freshest there!)

                        1. re: Chowrin
                          PattiCakes Jan 29, 2011 09:31 AM

                          Now you're talkin'! You might try Martin's Country Store, in Morgantown.

                      3. re: centralpadiner
                        pacheeseguy May 11, 2010 04:20 AM

                        For the Lititz area:
                        The Sutter recently opened a new British Pub, The Bull's Head.
                        Nice place to enjoy lunch or casual dinner.
                        It's located on Main Street, with it's own separate entrance.
                        Has a traditional pub menu.

                        Nearby, about 5 miles SW of Lititz, is a new small development,
                        Richmond Square. It has two very good restaurants.
                        Ciro's is Italian, great brick oven pizzas!

                        Coerulea is Asian cuisine & Sushi, also very good.

                        And the Fiorentinos at the airport is decent too.

                        In downtown Lititz,
                        Glassmyer's is great for a inexpensive, traditional breakfast or lunch.
                        I'd strongly suggest avoiding Choc. Cafe.
                        Very expensive for tasteless microwaved meals.

                        Glassmyer's Restaurant
                        23 N Broad St, Lititz, PA 17543

                        1. re: pacheeseguy
                          burgeoningfoodie May 21, 2010 01:45 PM

                          So I think where we are going is Lititz, Ephrata, Hershey, Intercourse, and Strasburg.

                          We want to do a buggy ride but aren't sure which companies are better than others. We will go to a Barnstormer's game and probably hit up Wheatland. Out of those areas and thigns that tourists may think about doing and seeing.. What would you suggest against and what would you suggest that might not have been thought of? We are also thinking about doing one of the covered bridge tours and hitting up Flavorfest.

                          1. re: pacheeseguy
                            tartlette Jan 23, 2011 08:13 PM

                            Yes to Bull's Head in Lititz. We found it after driving around the county for hours in the snow, finding everything else closed for the winter. We hoped for Sutter's Inn (next door) but found it also closed mid-afternoon between the lunch and dinner slots. Bull's Head can get hectic with no waitstaff but we rode it out seated at the bar and were rewarded with several truly good draft beers and a late lunch of scotch eggs and steak pie. Not exactly the PA Dutch we were looking for but satisfying just the same.

                2. PattiCakes May 6, 2010 07:21 AM

                  In Strasburg, if you are going on the train ride, stay away from the food unless you are so famished you might faint. Bad bad bad. Get a bag of kettle corn to tide you over, then go someplace else. Issac's has good sandwiches, and is close by. Looks like they are in other Lancaster County locations as well.

                  4 Replies
                  1. re: PattiCakes
                    burgeoningfoodie May 6, 2010 09:08 AM

                    The prices for the railroad seem a bit high for the out and back trip and so I wouldn't buy the food anyways. I don't recall them having people pay to mess around with the push and pull cart, but I guess those are the changes of the time.

                    Can anyone help me out with the next question. This may be more in the Poconos than the area I'm thinking of... but when I went to the area when I was oh.. maybe 7 or so.. I remember going to a village with a grist mill and also a store that had a bunch of old RCA Victor items on display or for sale. I remember the mill being a grey stone type building and I think I remember a blacksmith as well. Sound familiar to anyone?

                    1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                      brookquarry May 6, 2010 11:06 AM

                      The village you describe might have been Mill Bridge Village. It closed long ago.
                      Landis Valley Farm Museum is a state run museum which recreates non-Amish) rural life of the 1800's. If you like that sort of thing it would be worth checking out.

                    2. re: PattiCakes
                      betsydiver Mar 12, 2011 02:32 PM

                      am i mistaken that strasburg is not far from delaware water gap? you might find some interesting places to munch around there; i seem to recall a family run place right off the highway that sold beatiful homemade fruit pies; if you're going east on 80 the exit is to the right and the pie place is on the left as you come into "town"; also a "middling" diner near-by

                      1. re: betsydiver
                        centralpadiner Mar 12, 2011 06:27 PM

                        Common mistake - East Strasburg is a town near Delaware Water Gap in Northeastern PA. Strasburg is a much smaller community Southeast of Lancaster PA and home to the Strasburg RR.

                    3. Narnia9334 May 3, 2010 03:37 PM

                      You may want to check out http://www.pa-dutch-travel.com/ lots of things to see, to eat and do in Pa Dutch country. Have fun on your trip!

                      5 Replies
                      1. re: Narnia9334
                        burgeoningfoodie May 4, 2010 09:29 AM

                        Okay will do. I remember Miller's I think we went there when I was little. Typical buffet if I remember correctly. Of course we'd like a nice mix of nice and also eats that typify the dutch/german cuisine (like shoo fly pie). Stuff I won't get normally around the middle of NC.

                        Thanks for the replies. We are staying off Lincoln Hwy in Lancaster.

                        1. re: Narnia9334
                          burgeoningfoodie May 5, 2010 11:50 AM

                          Does anyone know if there is a place that will let you milk cows? I saw something about Ice Cream place.. Lapp farms or something like that? Or recommendations for things dealing with cheese/cheesemaking?

                          1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                            centralpadiner May 5, 2010 06:46 PM

                            Lapp's is an ice cream stand in Kitchen Kettle Village. September Farm is one local dairy that makes cheese and has a shop at the farm . . . but I don't know if you get to see any of the process.

                            Kitchen Kettle Village
                            RR 340, Intercourse, PA 17534

                            1. re: centralpadiner
                              burgeoningfoodie May 6, 2010 05:57 AM

                              Right but can't you also still go to the farm in Intercourse? So I guess it might be easier to ask what places should I avoid in general... and just aren't worth the time.

                              1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                                brookquarry May 6, 2010 06:02 AM

                                Lapp Valley still has their store on the farm off Mentzer Road, which is actually closer to New Holland. The ice cream is very good and the location scenic.
                                I don't know of anyplace that lets tourists milk cows. Your best bet in this regard would probably be to stay at one of the working farm Band B's- many allow guest to participate in farm activities.

                        2. p
                          pacheeseguy May 1, 2010 08:54 PM

                          As for restaurants, just look over some of the more recent posts about the same area.
                          These are usually listed at the bottom of you post page. (see below)
                          For the pretzel stuff, that was probably the Sturgis Pretzel Bakery in Lititz.
                          The downtown Lititz visitor site is

                          There are links for Sturgis and Wilbur Chocolate, plus all the shops on Broad & Main Streets. Nice town to visit, but not many dining choices.

                          4 Replies
                          1. re: pacheeseguy
                            burgeoningfoodie May 3, 2010 06:12 AM

                            THanks PA Cheeseguy. But we won't just be in Lititz. We'll be going to Hershey, Bird In Hand, Intercourse, and probably Strasburg.

                            1. re: burgeoningfoodie
                              centralpadiner May 3, 2010 07:52 AM

                              In Lititz, Cafe Chocolate is a nice and unique spot for lunch.

                              In Hershey I like Devon Seafood Grill for finer dining, Isaac's for casual/deli, Fire Alley for a bar, and Hershey Pantry (if it weren't for the wait).

                              Can't help much on Eastern Lancaster Co. restos, but traveling from Hershey to Lancaster on Rt. 283 you can stop at Mount Joy and go to the Country Table Restaurant for authentic local eats - except for maybe shoo-fly pie, I don't remember them having that, not that I look . . . . why buy it out when your own mom makes the best in the world! ;)

                              Hershey Pantry
                              801 E Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033

                              Fire Alley Restaurant & Bar
                              1144 Cocoa Ave, Hershey, PA 17033

                              1. re: centralpadiner
                                angie16 May 3, 2010 08:03 AM

                                Try TJ Rockwell's if it is nice out and enjoy their fabulous deck

                                1. re: angie16
                                  centralpadiner May 3, 2010 09:18 AM

                                  Sorry, I live in E-town and Rockwell's deck may be a fun environment, but the food might as well be TGIFriday's

                          Show Hidden Posts