Best atmosphere and food?
Call Bartolotta ahead of time and you'll have no issue getting a table outside. Order the Family Style Tasting option and you'll be quite happy if you enjoy wonderfully fresh, Italian seafood in a beautiful (although faux) lakeside setting. The only thing that could get in the way of your enjoyment is the ubiquitous quest for "value" (i.e. prepare to part with your hard-earned $$).