Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
Apr 14, 2010 12:30 PM

FOUND: Never frozen Florida Shrimp

The Beach Fish House, located at 1963 Queen E., receives a shipment of fresh Florida shrimp every Friday afternoon (approximately 15 per pound). I tried them this weekend, and it was my best Toronto shrimp experience ever!!! $19.99 per pound.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. You can also get fresh florida shrimp at Mike's at the St Lawrence Market.

    9 Replies
    1. re: missp58

      And Bill's Lobster has something similar, they call them Gulf Shrimp. The price is usually $13.99/lb, and they are fresh, not frozen and defrosted.

      Bill's Lobster
      599 Gerrard St E, Toronto, ON M4M, CA

      1. re: foodyDudey

        I usually buy my fresh wild, never frozen, Gulf shrimp at Bill's Llobster and they did tell me last time I was there that they were from the Gulf of Mexico. They always taste so good and I sure don't mind paying more for these vs the low cost shrimp from Asia (Thailand, Vietname, etc) that are grown inland in artificial ponds laden with chemicals, antibiotics and the like (apparently these ponds also undergo a chemical bath in between raising new crops of shrimp in order to clean out all the debris)..

        But, I am wondering though, are these Florida shrimp farm-raised or wild?

        1. re: Flexitarian

          From what I can tell from, they're most likely wild caught. Unfortunately, that still makes them rate at least "of concern", due to the rates of bycatch and impact on habitat from bottom trawling.

          1. re: tbonetak

   does not tell you whether the particular seafood you are buying is wild caught or not. The way you use that website and the wallet card or (free) iPhone app they provide is to identify what you are buying (ie wild caught/farmed, the species, method of harvesting, etc) and then check to see if it is the best choice, you should avoid it or there are concerns.

            Maybe there is no farmed Florida shrimp so the only shrimp from Florida is wild but do we know this?

            1. re: Flexitarian

              Hence the words "from what I can tell" and "most likely."

              I wasn't for a moment suggesting that can tell you how or where the fish sitting in front of you was caught; I am aware of how the wallet card works, thanks.

              But with a quick scan of the viability, variety and sources of the shrimp species listed on their site, it's evident (at least to me) that the odds are against them being from a sustainable source if they're from Florida.


              Do I know this for a fact? No. I know there are shrimp farms in Florida, but I also know that most of the shrimp we get from Florida are some variant of Mexican brown shrimp, which fall into the last two categories of shrimp on's site: Warmwater. They are both either listed has "avoid" or "some concerns."

              Does this mean conclusively there are no sustainable shrimp from Florida for sale here? Of course not. And it's definitely worth asking the question. Even if they're not sustainably sourced, at least fishmongers will become aware of the increasing demand for them. But if I didn't have anyone to ask and I had to hedge my bets, I'd expect they're wild caught.

              1. re: tbonetak

                Just to correct a small inaccuracy in my previous post, it seems the pink shrimp, also listed by seachoice as "some concerns" or "avoid," are the most-harvested shrimp in Florida.



                I think it's also telling that while the Florida Department of Agriculture has vigorously promoted wild-caught shrimp...


                their brochures on aquaculture make no mention of shrimp farming whatsoever.

                Again, is this conclusive proof that the ones the OP found are not farmed and thus (possibly) sustainable? No. It's just that much more unlikely.

                1. re: tbonetak

                  Whoops. Forgot a link to the Dept of Agricultlure Aquaculture brochures.


      2. re: missp58

        I've asked, and those shrimps are previously frozen.

        1. re: eatravel

          I'll have to ask again. Maybe I was mistaken. Still, they taste incredible. I'd rather have previously frozen but wild high quality shrimp than never frozen but should have been.

      3. I've purchased fresh Florida shrimp at Diana's Seafood but it's good to know about the Beach location.

        Diana's Seafood
        2101 Lawrence Ave E, Toronto, ON M1R, CA

        1. Around June and November, when weather is more ideal for shipment and hence lower perishable rate, one would actually find ' live swimming Florida Shrimp' being sold in outfit like the small specialist fish monger ( Silver dragon? ) at Finch and Midland!! Usually cramped into two huge fish tanks! Price varies from $14.99 to $21.99 depend on season.

          1. I would love to find some live shrimp here in Mississauga/Brampton!