Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Mar 25, 2010 07:22 AM

Fried Chicken---Deep Fryer or Cast Iron Skillet

I am considering making fried chicken as part of an Easter Brunch menu and I am wondering if it is better to use deep fryer or cast iron skillet? Will the texture/flavor/crunch differ? Any thoughts?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Skillet. You want the ability to cover it on the first side down and uncover for the second side. If the chicken is immersed too deeply, the steam from the chicken is more likely the blast through the batter on all sides.

    The best device (though not for making gravy from pan drippings) is a big electric skillet, where you can get very event control of temperature and have plenty of room to prevent crowding (which is bad for fried chicken).

    3 Replies
    1. re: Karl S

      thank you....a friend suggested an electric skillet but I am hesitant to purchase another gadget that may rarely be used.

      1. re: foufou

        an electric skillet is great to have esp if you entertain a lot. We do pancakes and french toast in it all the time so everyone can eat sooner.

        1. re: LaLa

          I am going to look for one at the thrift stores but probably won't have it before easter; I remember that my mom had one when I was a kid

    2. Cast iron is my weapon of choice whether deep frying or pan frying...Both produce excellent Fried Chicken...All things being equal you should not notice any appreciable difference in texture/flavor/crunch....Never had batter to blow off (on chicken) in a deep fryer....Possibly because I don't batter chicken.
      My personal preference is to start with dry chicken, coated in seasoned flour...allow it to rest for 15-20 minutes...and lightly coat with seasoned flour again just prior to frying......HTH.

      Have Fun!!

      1. That's really a toss-up. I fry it both ways, either in a large 14" cast iron skillet or a large cast iron Dutch oven. Both work equally well. If you want to make gravy, I'd suggest the skillet. I think the secret is to triple dip the seasoned chicken pieces, first in flour, then in an egg wash, and finally in a seasoned flour such as Drakes or Kentucky Kernel. After that, let it rest for at least 20 minutes before frying. That will ensure that the breading will stick to the chicken. 350 degrees it the ideal temp for either method. Good luck!

        1. Cast iron dutch oven is what I use. Holds a more constant heat load and allows more room for the expansion of the hot oil when the chicken enters the pan. Overflowing oil is a big factor in kitchen fires.

          1 Reply
          1. re: todao

            Agreed, cast iron dutch oven. Anyway, if you don't have one, it's a multi-tasker.
            There are cast iron single-handled "chicken fryers" with lids on the market, anywhere from around 3-5 qts., but I never thought they were adequately deep enough. They are meant more for frying in one layer, as Karl S describes upthread. A dutch oven with two side handles is deeper by inches, very good for deep frying and is generally more versatile.

            Never had properly battered or breaded chicken lose it's coating in a deep fryer, FWIW.

          2. thank you everyone that responded; I already have a Lodge cast iron dutch oven that I purchased for no-knead bread but have not used for that purpose and will use that for the fried chicken since I am not planning to make a gravy.....I will report back after the holiday