I am looking for a Wedding Caterer for between $50-$75 a person in the Philadelphia Area. The event would be in the NE suburbs, and IF possible makes organic/local meals?
If you want really good quality, try Jeffrey Miller. I must admit I paid $95, but that's because I added hors d'oeuvres and went for the high end. But I felt I got every penny's worth. I had some French family over for the wedding, and I wanted to save face. Jeffrey was my man.
Best of luck in your search, however you end up.
We used Culinary Design in Glenside: http://www.culinarydesignassociates.com/
Extensive menu (not sure about local or organic), very flexible and easy to work with, and the food was delicious. We received many compliments from guests. We supplied our own alcohol. Can't remember $/person but wasn't too expensive.