What to drink with four year old sardines?
Have some aged sardines. More info here
What to eat with four year old sardines?
Not sure what to drink.
In a long ago post about sardines someone mentioned they liked non-alcoholic lemonade with sardines because of their affinity with citrus. i'm thinking maybe something with lemon notes.
Then again a sparkling wine might work. That would be half-way to my inclination to drink beer (post is on the beer board for beer suggestions) The vino verde suggestion would be good as they usually have a slight fizz.
Work and lack of inspiration -- which surely has something to do with my not being a canned sardine person (nothing against them; it just never occurs to me to buy them) -- have kept me from replying. And I'd keep quiet except for the fact that whenever I see this thread, I think of Sherry, which no one has mentioned. Obviously I haven't put it to the test, but it seems to me that something like a top-drawer Manzanilla might work quite well with these vintage canned fish.
in general, beer worked better
I was a little hesitant about a Riesling because my experience is that it is either great or swill. Since I hang with lower-priced wines, my Riesling experience is usually swill.
Of the wines I chose
Espiral vinho verdets
Trader Joe-san sparkling sake
Tierra Brisa Malbec. 2008 Argentina (I had it in the house)
The sweet sparkling sake was the winner. The malec was fine ... being neither nasty nor great.
A few years back I was on a vinho verde kick, so I can tell a good one from a bad one. The Espiral wasn't v v greatness, but it was pretty good in that wine category. However, it was awful with sardines. It brought out all sorts of ugly fishy flavors, made the olive oil taste awful, and visa versa. The sardines made the wine lousy.
Aged or new, the pairing of sardines to wine was the same for both.
Someone sent me this link to a great blog about sardines. I’ve referred to this blog many times on Chowhound but forgot the blogger pairs food and beverages with each can of sardines. Here’s some ideas from that site
The sweet wine thing might work. Here's what the blogger said aout 07 Chateau de la Fessardiére Muscadet ... uh, that is a sweet wine, right?
"I tried to find a wine from a bit closer to Vendée ... This is a wonderful wine from the North Coastal region. A bit bigger than I imagined, but a perfect pairing for our Tin Course. Dry, Crisp, and Yummy."
Other wines tried ... good and bad so I know what to eliminate
- White dry Marsannay from Burgandy
- Paco & Lola Albariño.
- 2007 Tomero Torrontes. Mendoza, Argentina
What I got of out this is a direction. I'm thinking if Albariño and i happen to cross paths today I may get a bottle of that. Definately picking up some sweet wine. My budget is more Grocery Outlet than Kermit Lynch so lots if this is just a guide
Muscadet is dry and tart. 2007 might be a bit old.
Lots of Albariño at Spanish Table. Torrontes has a similar profile at a lower price point. Fruity, aromatic, dry, good with just about any seafood.
You might try Oddlots on San Pablo. The owner can give you good advice.
Young Muscadet is one of the driest wines out there. I think you're thinking of Muscat.
Muscadet is as cheap as the low teens at K&L.
But good Muscadet does age. I had one last week.
1993 Domaine de la Louvetrie (Landron & Fils) Muscadet de Sèvre-et-Maine Sur Lie Le Fief du Breil - France, Loire Valley, Pays Nantais, Muscadet de Sèvre-et-Maine (3/11/2010)
This was nice and quite a bit different than other Muscadets I've had. Its age is betrayed by the honey color of the wine. There's still a tanginess to the wine, but it is quite rounded, which Larry notes is to be expected with a 17-year-old wine. On the nose, I get lemon drops and some other candy. On the palate I get some minerality but more lime than lemon. Good finish but no as long as the Franken Silvaner that accompanied it. Aged Muscadet rocks.