HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Do you create unique foods? Tell us about it

Big Apple Barbecue Block Party Fast Pass Now On Sale-- This Year they have added a $25 "service" charge

stuartlafonda Feb 28, 2010 05:25 PM

$125 for $100 worth of Q,that ain't right. I love this event and have gone every year. I have purchased a fast pass the last few years but a $25 charge to wait in a shorter line seems a bit much. It is not like the fast pass means no line, every year there are still very long lines for some stands despite the pass.The non fast pass lines are insane and I won't spend my whole day standing on a line so the bottom line for me is that I love the food,can afford the extra charge, and as I'm unlikely to visit the out of towners at their own restaurants I guess I'll buy a Fast Pass. I'm not happy about it though.


  1. m
    mambwe Mar 1, 2010 07:43 AM

    I agree, The $25 is a little steep given the lines and no extra bbq. When I went last year some booths were running out of food pretty early. To me there is no way to go without a fast pass.

    If anyone is not using their companion pass I would be interested in it. I have an extra person coming this year and we don't want to buy a new pass as we won't need the extra $$ in food. If anyone isn't using the guest pass I would be willing buy it.

    3 Replies
    1. re: mambwe
      meatme Mar 1, 2010 07:58 AM

      Unless things have changed, there is no such thing as a companion pass. One pass admits two persons past the security guards at the entrance to the Fast Pass areas.

      1. re: meatme
        mambwe Mar 1, 2010 08:19 AM

        With each pass you get 2 separate passes. One is the punchcard with the money and the 2nd is for your guest. That is how it was last year.

        I'm trying to get a guest pass.

        1. re: meatme
          ESNY Mar 1, 2010 08:55 AM

          Last year was the first year with the companion pass. A separate pass with no monetary punch cards.

          I will not be spending the extra $25 on the fast pass this year. Prepaying (and guaranteeing I'll spend) $100 on BBQ should be sufficient for the fast pass.

      2. gnocchi May 8, 2010 09:52 AM

        My memory might be failing me on this subject but I seem to remember the original pass (Bubba Fast Pass?), offered value GREATER than the purchase price. I recall paying $100 for $120 worth of food. Anyone else remember that?
        Then the last few years it was even-up, and now this.

        1 Reply
        1. re: gnocchi
          kathryn May 8, 2010 10:04 AM

          In 2007, I remember it was $100 for $84 worth of food/goods/seminars/etc. plus a free t-shirt. I think in 2006, it was $150 for $150 of food.

          I think they change it up dependent on performance/demand.

        2. d
          drmoze May 9, 2010 12:12 PM

          BABBP=fail. I'll pass this year. Thanks for the heads-up on this ripoff.

          1. c
            comiendosiempre May 9, 2010 12:36 PM

            Thank you for the head's up. The $25 is steep, frankly, when you consider you are already committing to buy $100 of bbq and --- most importantly, the fast pass lines are still insane.

            I'm not sure if there is any answer but, each year the lines seem to have gotten worse. Though they were never great. Perhaps if you go before noon, and have a bbq bkfst they aren't so bad. I don't know. I do know that last year it was absurd. Has the event outgrown its location? Or, they need yet more vendors?

            13 Replies
            1. re: comiendosiempre
              sugartoof May 9, 2010 10:42 PM

              Adding vendors only seems to make it worse. I long for the days when it was only a bunch of trucks parked outside Blue Smoke, and a 25 person line seemed daunting.

              On top of the prices, and insane lines, it always appears to fall on one of the hottest days of the year, and they manage to set it up just perfectly to minimize the possibility of finding shade.

              Blue Smoke
              116 East 27th Street, New York, NY 10016

              1. re: sugartoof
                runwestierun May 9, 2010 10:48 PM

                I have never gone. Could you please elaborate on what the lines are like?

                1. re: runwestierun
                  sugartoof May 10, 2010 03:55 AM

                  They're usually well organized, once you figure out where the end of the line is, and what vendor they're lined up for, but expect some of the most daunting lines in all of Manhattan.

                  There is no way to predict how fast or slow the lines will go, but more often than not, they're slow. In past years, it wasn't uncommon to get halfway there and find out they're out of food, or the pitmaster was in between batches. More often than not the lines will just stop, and you're not sure why.

                  The major reason people buy the passes are to skip the general lines, for the VIP lines, which are still absurdly long. That said, there will be some booths without much lines at all, some that zip through in 15 minutes or so, and some that just never move, and take an hour. That hour estimation isn't a joke, be prepared to stand in line for upwards of an hour for the more popular cuts of meat/pitmasters. You can walk around and decide who you want to eat from based on the line, or which line you want to avoid.

                  1. re: runwestierun
                    kathryn May 10, 2010 08:26 AM

                    The longest lines are always at Salt Lick (brisket) and 17th Street (baby back ribs). Both of them are from out of town, offer items that the other vendors don't (most offer one signature item and that is it), and are pretty big names.

                    My hunch is that the lines progress slowly or are burst-y because making BBQ to feed a big crowd is an inexact science. They put a bunch of meat into smokers and batch them, spreading them out by hours at a time. When one batch is ready, the next one won't be ready for maybe another 30 minutes or another hour. Since BBQ is a slow cooking process, if you mis-estimate demand, you're screwed. And the vendors don't want to bring home a ton of uneaten meat, either, so they plan to sell out by the end of the day. Most of them lose money by doing this since they drive to NYC with all of their own meat and equipment. They're doing it for cred and for charity.

                    My tips:

                    Get there before noon, bring a friend, split up. You *must* hit up these out of town pitmasters:
                    1. Chris Lilly, Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q, Pulled Pork Shoulder. With the best BBQ sauce. Sweet, tangy, tomato based sauce. The pork is pulled and comes in nice chunks.
                    2. The Pit, Ed Mitchell, for NC style Whole Hog (the entire hog is chopped up, not just the shoulder), it's very tender, soft, chopped very finely. Almost melts in your mouth. Nice vinegary sauce.
                    3. 17th Street Baby Back Ribs, Mike Mills. Saucy and sweet. Fatty.
                    4. The Salt Lick, Driftwood, TX for brisket and sausage (ask for the deckle, which is the fatty part, I think their brisket is very good but not the absolute greatest, but I've been to places in hill country in Texas like Smitty's, Black's, Cooper's, etc).
                    5. Skip all NYC vendors.
                    6. Don't eat a big breakfast. Eat some salad for dinner, if you actually get hungry later.

                    Lines are HIGHLY dependent upon who we're talking about (Salt Lick and 17th Street are perenially long) weather and time of day (earlier is better, there will be fewer people if it's super hot or muggy or rainy). And overall, Sunday is always more smooth than Saturday since it's volunteer staffed. I've gone the last 3-4 years and rarely had a problem with lines. I have a FastPass, I get there around 11:30am and I'm usually done by 2pm. Longest line last year I think was 30 minutes.

                    Every year has been different in my experience, from "the registers just went down and nobody knows what to do" to "oops, we just ran out of food, can you wait for the next batch?" to "the lady in front of me just bought 12 plates of BBQ!" to "something went wrong with this batch of hush puppies and we need to all start over." It really depends on how organized each individual vendor is.

                    Reports from last year:

                    1. re: kathryn
                      metfan630 May 10, 2010 10:47 AM

                      Great tips. I STRONGLY recommend abiding by the "show up before noon and split up" rule. Two friends of mine live right near there, and we hit the stands at 11:30 or so every year, splitting up of course.

                      In general, the BBQ joints from out of town have the longest lines, so hit up Big Bob Gibson/Ed Mitchell/etc first - sending one person in your group to each line, then if you are still hungry, try some of the NY places.

                      I have never experienced a stand being out of food, however, I have never gone to a stand past 1 or 2 pm.

                      1. re: kathryn
                        sugartoof May 10, 2010 02:37 PM

                        I can't imagine they're losing money. They wouldn't continue to come back year after year if that was the case. These are people who do the BBQ festival circuit. One would think they'd rather end the day with some uneaten BBQ they can donate to charity rather than leave put people through the abusive lines with the possibility you're sending people home unfed.

                        It's just an avoidable experience I can't ever picture myself repeating.

                        1. re: sugartoof
                          ESNY May 10, 2010 03:26 PM

                          Every single long line I've been on (all while holding a fastpass) had nothing to do with running out of bbq. It is either sheer ineptness and/or overselling the fastpass.

                          To be honest, allowing people with a fastpass to also pay by cash doesn't help things either, it just slows down the process even more. I personally think they should also ditch the drinks at each vendor. That way they are selling one thing, at one price, no cash which would make the whole process, at least for a fastpass holder.

                          Instead they decided to jack the fastpass price up 25% for the privileged of only waiting an hour for Salt Lick or 30 minutes for BIg Bob Gibson.

                          1. re: sugartoof
                            kathryn May 10, 2010 03:28 PM


                            Organizer Danny Meyer pays a fixed travel allowance, $2,500 in recent years, which barely covers costs for most out-of-state vendors.

                            1. re: kathryn
                              sugartoof May 10, 2010 05:06 PM

                              Why would food profits all go back to the Park? I question the accuracy of that. The event started on 27th Street a couple blocks from the park. The vendors wouldn't have stayed on and moved to the park location for a growing event that was going to deny them profits.

                              In all the years of the event, no effort has been made to decrease the lines or handle the crowds with faster service. Plus let's be honest. It's not uncommon to find yourself standing in a line that's not moving, with piles of meat sitting there waiting to be served.

                              By the way, my observations are without the vip pass. Paying $80-125 for a tasting always seemed steep.

                              1. re: sugartoof
                                kathryn May 10, 2010 05:48 PM

                                In 2009, the event generated $100,000 for the Madison Square Park Conservancy.

                                1. re: kathryn
                                  sugartoof May 10, 2010 06:28 PM

                                  Sounds like they could triple their travel stipend to the vendors and still provide a healthy donation to the park.

                                  There must be some reason the vendors participate aside for sweetening Danny Meyers preexisting Shake Shack agreements with the city parks dept.

                                  Shake Shack
                                  Madison Ave and E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010

                                2. re: sugartoof
                                  gnocchi May 11, 2010 10:15 AM

                                  "In all the years of the event, no effort has been made to decrease the lines or handle the crowds with faster service. Plus let's be honest. It's not uncommon to find yourself standing in a line that's not moving, with piles of meat sitting there waiting to be served."
                                  Well, to be honest they have done a few things to smooth out the confusion. They have added additional vendors and expanded more onto Madison Ave. In the early years i remember the lines being really chaotic, people didn't even know what line they were on, all kinds of line cutting, etc.
                                  Also early on, no cash was accepted, you had to purchase paper tickets, an additional hassle.
                                  So the spreading out with more corrals and Fast Passes have helped, but now it seems to be evolving into something more elitist, with surcharges for passes, hospitality tents for those willing to pay, while the average poor schmuck waits on a long line. I can tell you for sure I remember paying $200 on AMEX and getting $225 of food. Now it's the other way around, in essence "what the NYC traffic will bear". I can bear it, but I don't need it that bad.

                                  1. re: gnocchi
                                    sugartoof May 11, 2010 12:42 PM

                                    I partially agree, but even the expansion on the Madison has caused chaos. They're now allowing promotional vendors giving out soft drinks, by the afternoon it looks like a pack of bears tore threw the place.

                    2. c
                      comiendosiempre May 12, 2010 03:41 PM

                      With their sales, I think it would be impossible not to make a small fortune. And, if that wasn't being made, the pit masters wouldn't come year after year.

                      3 Replies
                      1. re: comiendosiempre
                        sugartoof May 12, 2010 07:46 PM

                        exactly....and sales are almost guaranteed....they'll sell as much meat as they can bring/cook.

                        1. re: comiendosiempre
                          kathryn May 12, 2010 08:34 PM

                          Keep in mind, though, there's probably a difference in catering a barbecue festival in the South with a few thousand attendees vs. one in NYC with tens of thousands of people showing up.

                          I did some digging and this is what I've found as paraphrased by someone who was associated with the organizers, but is no long as close to the event:
                          - The event organizers provide all the local support. They provide staff, infrastructure, and ingredients.
                          - Some vendors bring their equipment, others rent locally.
                          - The vendors bring a small crew to handle cooking and some parts of assembly. The rest are from the events team.
                          - Every vendor gets a travel stipend based on distance, plus an attendance fee.
                          - Every vendor agrees to serve a set number orders per day for a flat fee. If they choose to serve more, that's their choice, but the fee doesn't increase.

                          1. re: kathryn
                            sugartoof May 13, 2010 03:14 AM

                            EIther way, the set up looks hectic for the vendors, it's hectic for the attendees... and I know I'm not the only one who gave up on the event a long time ago.

                        2. f
                          foodismylife May 13, 2010 07:51 AM

                          man this is just bbg
                          why subject yourself to such nonsense
                          rub blue smoke hill county dinosaur all great choices and be a human not an animal

                          1. b
                            BiteForBite Mar 14, 2011 08:55 AM

                            Soooo.... the fast pass works all weekend right? And do you have to bring the same person each day?

                            1. junescook Mar 14, 2011 09:17 AM

                              After all the waiting in all that heat, do they have enough tables and chairs (hopefully under cover) for people to be able to sit down and eat and enjoy their food?

                              This is starting to make the Norwalk Oyster Festival (and BBQ Competition) sound like heaven.


                              2 Replies
                              1. re: junescook
                                Wilfrid Mar 14, 2011 10:42 AM

                                Chairs and tables under cover are available if you buy a $500 ticket. I am not even joking.


                                Whether you'll need to stand in line to access the VIP tent I can't say.

                                1. re: junescook
                                  Jess321 Mar 17, 2011 05:37 PM

                                  Last year my friends and I ended up sitting on benches or indentations of buildings wherever we could find! The most hilarious place was sitting in front of the gym, to the North side of the park, watching people work out while we gobbled up as much meat as we could handle.

                                2. c
                                  comiendosiempre Mar 17, 2011 06:42 PM

                                  Pay more, get less.

                                  I do believe I am over the BBQ block party, which goes on for blks and blks and feels more like a TSA security line at LGA. Even I have my limits of humiliation and waiting when it comes to food. Now, if we could only get a competing BBQ festival going for the week before ......

                                  Show Hidden Posts