HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

"Real" turkey?

  • 7

I'm planning a trip to NYC in June and already obsessing about restaurants, bakeries, etc. This board has been very helpful!
I see (from MenuPages) that many diner/coffee shop places offer a hot turkey sandwich and/or roast turkey dinner. Can you suggest any places where I can expect this to be like Thanksgiving turkey -- hand-carved slices from a whole roasted turkey, rather than uniform thin slices from a processed turkey breast?
We'll be staying at the Eastgate Towers (3rd st. and 39th ave.) but will be getting around to various sights and neighborhoods in Manhattan (and maybe Brooklyn) -- although if I intend to drag my family along to a "destination diner," it would be nice if there were other interesting things in the area.
Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Gemini Diner has a thanksgiving turkey dinner with real turkey, comes with stuffing and cranberry sauce if I remember correctly.

    www.inbundles.com

    1. You are actually staying at 3rd Ave and 39th Street, this is near Grand Central.

      5 Replies
      1. re: paperpest

        Aaargh! Of course you're right -- I'd better get that straight before I get there! And there's no way to edit my original post now, so my embarrassing mistake will remain forever.

        1. re: khoffdenver

          there's no shame in not knowing the finer points of a place you're not familiar with. just don't ask anyone which way 39th Street is when you're standing on 38th...walk one block and if you're on 37th, turn around.

          1. re: coasts

            It's the coming up out of the subway and not knowing which direction is which that worries me (not too much -- I'm not losing sleep over it or anything like that). Here in Colorado we have a very convenient mountain range that marks West from anyplace in Denver.

            >>just don't ask anyone which way 39th Street is when you're standing on 38th...walk one block and if you're on 37th, turn around>>

            I see I'm going to be doing even more walking that I thought I was!

            1. re: khoffdenver

              Don't worry -- you'll find that New Yorkers like to help with directions as much as restaurants!

              1. re: City Kid

                Thanks, everybody. The Gemini diner looks perfect.