HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >

Discussion

F. Dick Multicut-Shun?

I have a 7inch Shun Classic Santoku, and I'm looking for the best thing to hone it. I heard that the F. Dick Multicut is a pretty good steel. But, I heard that you should get a smooth steel for knives. Which one should I get?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. For Shun, don't even need to hone it with a steel and definitely not that F. Dick Multicut, unless you have a death wish for your knife -- I am serious because you will ruin your Shun edge. Of course, it depends on your definition of "honing", but you don't need a typical grooved steel for hone, that is for sure.

    To maintain your Shun knife edge, you can use a flat waterstone at between 1000 to 4000 grits or so, in my opinion. Best wishes

    2 Replies
    1. re: Chemicalkinetics

      I don't want to sharpen it with a whetstone, just hone the edge. I'm thinking a polished steel would do the trick.

      1. re: nicky63220

        Why do you want to hone it? Do you think the edge will roll? What trick are you referring when you say "it would do the trick"?

    2. Why not get the Shun steel? It's made specifically for Shun knives & is only $40, or $32 with a 20% discount coupon at BBB. It already has the correct angle guide cut right into the handle bolster, & only takes a very light run of the blade across its length to keep the edge in the condition you're looking to maintain.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Eiron

        Because we had this discussion and concluded the Shun steel is a bad idea by everyone at the time:

        http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/666432

        1. re: Chemicalkinetics

          LOL, ah, I see! Thanks for the link. That discussion was before my time.
          I found this quote in this recent thread:
          http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/589654
          "A step above even smooth steels are fine grit ceramic and very fine diamond steels. According to Cliff Stamp, 'A smooth steel just pushes the edge back into alignment, leaving the weakened metal there, which will actually relax back into being deformed in its own time without any use. The ceramic will remove some of the weakened steel while also aligning the edge. The edge will be more stable and stay sharp for much longer. There is more metal removed with the ceramic and diamond rods, but you are looking at between 100 to 1000 sharpenings to remove one millimeter of metal from the edge of the knife depending on the edge angle and the grit of the ceramic or diamond hone – this is years of constant use. In general, the lifetime of most knives tends to be dominated by the occasional accidental damage that forces heavy honing.' ”

          I have a ceramic honing rod that I'd like to fit with a handle. This would give me an easy, quick way to hone my knives. The Idahone ceramics are reasonable at $28, or you could buy a shorter (8-1/2") ceramic for $2 & fit your own handle to it. I actually think the best method for cleaning up any edge would be a 6000 grit waterstone. I just got one, but I haven't tried out the Kanetsune on it yet.

          1. re: Eiron

            Eiron,

            :) You make it sounds like you are very young - with "That discussion was before my time". I don't think a smooth steel is necessary a bad idea. Our buddy Soop has one and is loving it. However, a smooth steel may not be very useful for a hard steel knife. The harder the knife edge is, the less likely it will roll/bend. In fact, that is the reason why people like Japanese knives, they are harder and they maintain their edge better. A smooth steel is to straighten a rolled edge, so it does not seem like the best fit for a hard steel Japanese knives.

            I agree with you that the nicer way for a Shun knife is to use a waterstone to do quick touch-up. I don't mean 5-10 min knife sharpening. I mean just a few swipe on each side, probably less than a minute. One would probably spend more time soaking up the waterstone than actually using it. One might as well touch up all the knives at the same time because of the waiting time for soaking and the clean up.

            I think a smooth ceramic honing rod give you two big advantages. I don't need to soak it up for 10 minutes before using it. I don't need to clean up the counter afterward.

            I read your post on your two Kanetsune. You seem to like them. Did you put a new edge or are they in factory edge? You may like them even more after refining the edge. I hope your wife is not mad at you for buying all these knvies. Best.

        1. thanks. that Idahone ceramic sounds like the right tool to use.

          1. If you want to go a step finer than ceramic yet not as smooth as polished steel, then the HandAmerican glass hone is even lighter on your blade.

            You can actually buy the borosilicate (glass) hone with the ceramic Idahone in one package from them. It might be more spendy than you want, but you will get two fine tools and some extras included.

            Here is the website:
            http://www.handamerican.com/bororod.html

            1 Reply
            1. re: smkit

              Will the Idahone take the mirror-finish off the blade?