Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
Feb 8, 2010 05:28 PM

Best Hot Dogs and Ice Cream in Upstate New York

My vote goes to Stewarts Shops. Their ice cream is equal to a lot of gourmet ice creams and their hot dogs with the fixin's are the best.
I took 'em for granted when I lived up there but what I wouldn't give to fix up a couple of those bright red cajun dogs with meat sauce and chopped onions, grab a paper and a cup of coffee and sit at a booth to enjoy my lunch. Buy a gallon (only 40 cents more than a pint) of Death by Chocolate on my way out the door and I'm a happy man.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I certainly agree with the assessment of Stewarts ice cream. Don't necessarily agree with the hot dog part of your post, since in many of the Stewarts the dogs have sat around much too long in the steamer. My vote on hot dogs would be Hot Dog Charlies in the Capital District. Course, most of your post, and my reply, will mean nothing to the usual New York City posters who think upstate is the ten miles north of the George Washington Bridge

    1. I buy my heavy cream from Stewarts as it's the only cream I can find other than from local farms (can't always get to them) that is not ultra-pasteurized. However, when it comes to ice cream--no doubt I am an ice cream snob, but the list of ingredients in Stewarts is beyond off-putting--it's downright unhealthy (yeah, an oxymoron when talking ice cream, but....) And as a chocolate fan, it was Death by Chocolate I was looking at. Full of preservatives, thickeners and questionable other stuff.

      1. i like jane's ice cream. soul dog in poughkeepsie has good hot dogs. i'm curious about this place i recently heard about...noshi's coney island...

        1 Reply
        1. re: applesauce23

          I'm with you on Jane's; think it's the best regionally produced ice cream. Harder to find but definitely quality.

        2. What about Kurver Kreme on Central Ave in Albany (Colonie)? Excellent soft serve.

          4 Replies
          1. re: iluvcookies

            I'll side with Jane's as well. they have a coffee Kahlua ice cream that should be illegal.

            For hot dogs I have to give it to my one true love...Dallas Hot Wieners in Kingston. So wrong and yet so very, very right at the same time.

            1. re: jaylowe

              I'm counting the days until the Jolly Cow ice cream stand in Kingston opens again. Last year, it opened in late March. Another great place is the Coney Island ice cream stand in Catskill. I'm not a hot dog expert, but 5 Guys Burgers and Fries in Kingston has good ones, albeit greasy! Greasy, but good!

              1. re: hudsonvalleygoodstuff

                For soft serve I've gotta go with Holy Cow in Red Hook although Boice's Dairy in Kingston has the largest servings by far!

                1. re: Bumstead

                  I remember when Boice's used to be Babcock's.

          2. Stewart's is okay for a cheap mass-market ice cream but the "best"? No way! Try The Ice Cream Man in Greenwich. It even made TIME magazine! And, if you just want chains, Ben & Jerry's is seriously better than Stewart's.

            3 Replies
            1. re: gerchak198

              Gerchack: is the Ice Cream Man the shop next to the Washington County Fairgrounds? If not, please tell me more!

                1. re: jaylhorner

                  Love their cantaloupe ice cream, when available.