HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >

questions about copper cookware

c
crna cook Jan 30, 2010 08:10 AM

I just joined today. I have gotten lots of good info on copper pots by reading this site. Thanks everyone for their advice. I will say that i checked out the previninc.com site and the prices were much lower than other sites for the Bourgeat. I'm trying to research all the copper cookware before I buy. Has anyone used the dodici copper cookware from Napastyle? it's beautiful but is it a quality copper? they don't mention the copper thickness. I've e-mailed them today and asked. Anyone have any advice? And I really like the look of the hammered copper. Any suggestions on which brand is best?

Thanks

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. David A. Goldfarb RE: crna cook Jan 31, 2010 07:05 PM

    I have several tin-lined hammered Mauviel pieces, and I'm very happy with them. Some of them are 3-4mm thick, which is heavier than the stainless lined cookware from Mauviel, Bourgeat and Falk. Ruffoni is beautiful, but isn't as heavy.

    2 Replies
    1. re: David A. Goldfarb
      c
      crna cook RE: David A. Goldfarb Feb 12, 2010 07:23 AM

      thanks, I'll look it up!

      1. re: crna cook
        r
        RichardM RE: crna cook Feb 12, 2010 08:22 AM

        Mauviel has 3 lines with different thcknesses. Metrokitchen.com covers them pretty well.

    2. tim irvine RE: crna cook Feb 13, 2010 08:54 AM

      It is hard to tell from a photo unless it is up close from a certain angle, but the stuff from Napastyle does not look heavy. Bridge Kitchenware used to have some really good sales on Bourgeat, but I have not seen any lately. www.buycoppercookware.com seems to have always competitive prices and a very wide selection. Ditto for Dehillerin, especially when exchange rates are favorable. I like the look of traditional shiny copper, having picked up hammered pieces and smooth ones over the years. Everyone raves about Falk, but I just don't like the brushed look. I also steer away from anything that does not have an iron handle unless it is a specialty piece like a pomme vapeur that only comes with brass handles. Some people like everything in a single style so it all matches, like All-Clad stainless or whatever. I figure everything I have, from copper pans to steel pans to Apilco terrines to tinned molds to carbon steel knives matches. It's all in the "Old French kitchen" pattern. Different knowledgeable people will weigh in on all of these issues and even though they are all knowledgeable and authoritative, they still disagree. Cooks Illustrated put Mauviel copper pans at the bottom on their recent saucepan test. I candidly admit I didn't acquire these pans over the years because I needed them to cook better. But they do cook exceptionally well, and I love each of them. They are idiosyncratic as all get out. They are heavy. The handles get hot. You have to watch the tin and clean them gently. If you require them to look nice, they take work. I have adjusted to all of those things. It is second nature to use a towel or a pot holder to grab anything. I'd spring for a really fine workhorse pan, maybe a 2.5 quart Mauviel professional saucepan with a tin lining, get to know it, and build out from there if you love it as much as I would. My first high quality copper was a #24 BIA sautoir I bought in a Seattle suburb in the early 70s. Someone bought it, bubbled the tin, and returned it. The lady at Yankee Kitchen (now long gone) sold it to me for half price. It is about 2.5 mm, hammered, with an iron handle. The tin still has the bubbles but is still serviceable. Little local shops like that can offer some deals. They aren't big enough to afford to hang onto a large inventory the way W-S or Sur La Table can and they are usually run by a softie that wants each piece to find a good home.

      4 Replies
      1. re: tim irvine
        m
        mateo21 RE: tim irvine Feb 13, 2010 10:14 AM

        hehehe... I just did a one-day trial for CI, just to see what they hated about the copper saucepan... funny read!

        1. re: mateo21
          David A. Goldfarb RE: mateo21 Feb 13, 2010 04:30 PM

          I'm not giving them my credit card number. What did they hate about it?

          1. re: mateo21
            kaleokahu RE: mateo21 Jun 24, 2010 09:02 PM

            I'm with Goldfarb--those greedy bast@#ds at CI really piss me off. Do tell... synopsize their copper article for us pikers, will you please?

            1. re: kaleokahu
              tim irvine RE: kaleokahu Jun 26, 2010 02:59 PM

              as i recall they mainly didn't like the shape...said the corners were hard to reach. Also found them too heavy. I enjoy CI when I see it but take most everything they say with a grain of salt. Also, I have to say when you are weighing a product like All-Clad against Mauviel professional, it really is a sort of ridiculous comparison. Plus, they didn't even look at heavy copper with tin linings which, IMHO is vastly superior plus cheaper than SS lined. Last quibble, if they are so hung up on reachable corners in pans, get an evasee ...it won't work as well for what as a saucepan for what a saucepan was designed to do, but it will have no corners to evade your wandering spoon!

              In fairness to CI, I have never read any source that reviewed an array of products for publication that I agreed with. What I like about this site is that I can read a variety of posts and figure out who approaches things the way I do. Their opinions I value. Others inform and entertain, but I am not going to follow their recommendations because I know they will be wrong for me. I can visualize the CI test kitchens and the way they work and cannot imagine cooking the way they do! They obsess on things I don't care about and spend their lives looking for shortcuts and substitutes...yuck. But I do enjoy their recipes and do get ideas.

        Show Hidden Posts